Automated X-ray inspection

X-ray of an electronic circuit board (zoom series into an old token ring network adapter board).

Automated X-ray inspection (AXI) is a technology based on the same principles as automated optical inspection (AOI). It uses X-rays as its source, instead of visible light, to automatically inspect features, which are typically hidden from view.

Automated X-ray inspection is used in a wide range of industries and applications, predominantly with two major goals:

1. Process optimization, i.e. the results of the inspection are used to optimize following processing steps,
2. Anomaly detection, i.e. the result of the inspection serve as a criterion to reject a part (for scrap or re-work).

Whilst AOI is mainly associated with electronics manufacturing (due to widespread use in PCB manufacturing), AXI has a much wider range of applications. It ranges from the quality check of alloy wheels^[1] to the detection of bone fragments^[2] in processed meat. Wherever large numbers of very similar items are produced according to a defined standard, automatic inspection using advanced image processing and pattern recognition software (Computer vision) has become a useful tool to ensure quality and improve yield in processing and manufacturing.^[3]

Principle of Operation

Similar to an optical inspection, an x-ray inspection produces images of the object. The image is then processed by image processing software that detects the position and size/ shape of expected features (for process optimization) or presence/ absence of unexpected/ unintended objects or features (for anomaly detection). Instead of (visible) light it uses x-rays (typically generated by an x-ray tube) that pass through the object. Opposite the x-ray emitter is a detector that either converts x-ray into visible light (creating an optical image which is then picked up by a camera) or sensor arrays that directly pick up the x-ray and convert it into an electronic image. The image is produced due to the different absorption of x-rays when passing through the object and can therefore reval structures inside the object that are hidden from outside view.

Applications

With the advancement of image processing software the number applications for automated x-ray inspection is huge and constantly growing. The first applications started off in industries where the safety aspect of components demanded a careful inspection of each part produced (e.g. welding seams for metal parts in nuclear power stations) because the technology was expectedly very expensive in the beginning. But with wider adoption of the technology, prices came down significantly and opened automated x-ray inspection up to a much wider field- partially fueled again by safety aspects (e.g. detection of metal, glass or other materials in processed food) or to increase yield and optimize processing (e.g. detection of size and location of holes in cheese to optimize slicing patterns).^[4]

In mass production of complex items (e.g. in electronics manufacturing), an early detection of defects can drastically reduce overall cost, because it prevents defective parts from being used in subsequent manufacturing steps. This results in three major benefits: a) it provides feedback at the earliest possible state that materials are defective or process parameters got out of control, b) it prevents adding value to components that are already defective and therefore reduces the overall cost of a defect, and c) it increases the likelihood of field defects of the final product, because the defect may not be detected at later stages in quality inspection or during functional testing due to the limited set of test patterns.

Use of AXI in electronics manufacturing

The increasing usage of ICs (integrated circuits) with packages such as BGAs (ball grid array) where the connections are underneath the chip and not visible, means that ordinary optical inspection is impossible. Because the connections are underneath the chip package there is a greater need to ensure that the manufacturing process is able to accommodate these chips correctly. Additionally the chips that use BGA packages tend to be the larger ones with many connections. Therefore, it is essential that all the connections are made correctly.^[5]

AXI is often paired with the testing provided by boundary scan test, in-circuit test, and functional test.

Process

As BGA connections are not visible the only alternative is to use a low level X-ray inspection. AXI is able to find faults such as opens, shorts, insufficient solder, excessive solder, missing electrical parts, and mis-aligned components. Defects are detected and repaired within short debug time.

These inspection systems are more costly than ordinary optical systems, but they are able to check all the connections, even those underneath the chip package.

Related technologies

The following are related technologies and are also used in electronic production to test for the correct operation of electronics printed circuit boards.

• In-circuit test (ICT)
• Joint Test Action Group (JTAG)
• Automated optical inspection (AOI)
• Functional testing (see acceptance testing)

References

1. "Automated Radioscopic Inspection of Aluminum Die Castings", Domingo Mery, Departamento de Ciencia de la Computación Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile Av. Vicuña Mackena 4860(183) Santiago de Chile http://www.ndt.net/article/v12n12/mery.pdf
2. Thickness-compensated X-ray imaging detection of bone fragments in deboned poultry—model analysis Y Tao, JG Ibarra - Transactions of the ASAE, 200 - elibrary.asabe.org http://elibrary.asabe.org/abstract.asp?aid=2725
3. "Application and Technology of X-ray Inspection in Processing and Manufacturing Industry". www.x-rayinspection.us. Retrieved 2016-03-08.
4. Brosnan, Tadhg; Sun, Da-Wen (2004-01-01). "Improving quality inspection of food products by computer vision––a review". Journal of Food Engineering. Applications of computer vision in the food industry. 61 (1): 3–16. doi:10.1016/S0260-8774(03)00183-3.
5. X-Ray Inspection for PCB and BGA

6. X-ray inspection - Packaged product