Hovhannes Kajaznuni

Hovhannes Kajaznuni Յովհաննէս Քաջազնունի
1st Prime Minister of Armenia
In office 6 June 1918 – 7 August 1919
Preceded by	position established
Succeeded by	Alexander Khatisyan
Chairman of the National Assembly of Armenia
In office 4 November 1920 – 2 December 1920
Preceded by	Avetik Sahakyan
Succeeded by	Soviet Armenia
Personal details
Born	February 1, 1868 Akhaltsikhe, Tiflis Governorate, Russian Empire
Died	1938 (aged 69–70) Yerevan, Armenian SSR, Soviet Union
Nationality	Armenian
Political party	Armenian Revolutionary Federation

Hovhannes Kajaznuni, or Hovhannes Katchaznouni (Armenian: Յովհաննէս Քաջազնունի) (1 February 1868 – 1938), was the first Prime Minister of the First Republic of Armenia from June 6, 1918 to August 7, 1919. He was a member of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation.

Early life

Hovhannes Kajaznuni was born in 1868 in the town of Akhaltsikhe, then part of the Russian Empire, now part of Georgia. He attended secondary school in Tiflis from 1877 to 1886. In 1887 he moved to St. Petersburg and entered the Citizens' Architectural Institute, graduating with honors in 1893. In St. Petersburg he joined the Armenian Revolutionary Federation, eventually becoming one of its most important members. After graduation, he worked at the construction department of the Baku provincial administration (1893–95), as an architect in Batumi (1895–97), and as regional architect at the Tiflis provincial administration (1897–99). Between 1899 and 1906 he worked as a senior architect in Baku, designing hospitals and apartment buildings, his most notable work being the Saint Thaddeus and Bartholomew Cathedral completed in 1911. After 1906 he devoted himself to political and social activities.^[1]

Political career

Kajaznuni was forced to leave the Caucasus in 1911 to avoid being called to testify at the trial of Armenian Revolutionary Federation members mounted by the Russian government in St. Petersburg in January 1912. He lived in Istanbul and then in Van until 1914, when he returned to the Caucasus. He became a member of the Armenian National Council in 1917 and was an ARF representative in the Seym (the Transcaucasian Parliament) until 1918.

Trebizond Peace Conference and Transcaucasian Federation

He was part of the Armenian delegation that conducted peace talks with the Ottoman Empire at the Trebizond Peace Conference, beginning on March 14, 1918.^[2] The three groups of Transcaucasus delegates—Muslim, Georgian and Armenian—had divergent aims, and were in a weak position to negotiate with the Ottomans.^[3] While the talks progressed, the Ottoman Third Army retook Erzurum and advanced to the previous frontier with Russia.^[3] These setbacks spurred Akaki Chkhenkeli, the Georgian Menshevik leader of the Transcaucasus delegation, to unilaterally inform the Ottomans that he would accept the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk as the basis for negotiation, and thereby abandon Armenian claims to portions of Ottoman territory.^[4] This concession was repudiated by the Seym, which ordered Chhenkeli and the delegation to return to Tbilisi.^[5]

The capture of Batumi by Ottoman troops on April 14, 1918 sapped the will of the Georgian Mensheviks to continue fighting the Ottomans, and they pushed their Transcaucasus allies to accept the two Ottoman prerequisites for resuming negotiations: a recognition of Turkey's territorial rights and a full break with Russia.^[5] This resulted in the Mensheviks and Muslims in the Seym proposing on April 22, 1918 to establish a Transcaucasian Democratic Federative Republic with reluctant endorsement from the increasingly isolated Armenian representatives.^[6] The new republic's cabinet was selected by Chhenkeli as premier-designate, and included Kajaznuni as one of four Armenians.^[7] One of Chhenkeli's first acts, without consulting the Seym or the Armenian cabinet members, was to order the Armenian army to surrender Kars to the Ottomans.^[8] The furious Armenian leaders tendered their resignations from the cabinet and demanded Chhenkeli be replaced. The Mensheviks would only agree to replace him with Kajaznuni or another Armenian. The Armenians realized that nominating an Armenian premier would cause the Ottomans to attack Russian Armenia, which was on the front-line since the loss of Kars. Accordingly, Kajaznuni and his fellow Dashnaks allowed the Seym to confirm their cabinet positions on April 26, 1918.^[9]

Batumi Peace Conference

Kajaznuni also accompanied Chhenkeli as a delegate to the Batumi Peace Conference that began on May 11, 1918.^[10] The conference saw the Ottomans extend their demands to include Akhaltsikhe and Akhalkalaki in Tiflis Governorate and the western half of Erivan Governorate.^[10] Before the Transcaucasus delegation had delivered a response, Ottoman forces invaded the Erivan Governorate, and on May 15 captured Alexandropol.^[10] A week later, they had approached both Yerevan and Karakilisa.^[10] Unable to negotiate anything more favorable than capitulation with the Ottomans, the Georgian leaders at the Batumi talks arranged a side-deal with Germany to exchange German protection for access to Georgia's economic resources. The result was that the Seym dissolved the federative republic on May 26, 1918, with the Democratic Republic of Georgia declared the same day and the republics of Azerbaijan and Armenia declared on May 28.^[11]

Independent Armenia

The Armenian National Council elected Kajanuni as the first prime minister of the independent Armenian state on June 6, 1918 and his cabinet was formed on June 30. Kajaznuni held this position until August 7, 1919; with the nomination as a prime minister abroad from June 5, 1919. He was in diplomatic missions in Europe (beginning in August 1919) and the United States (from October 9, 1919 until August 1920). He returned to Armenia to become chairman of the parliament on November 4, 1920. Kajaznuni was arrested after the Bolsheviks came to power in December 1920 but was liberated during the February 1921 revolt against the Soviet regime.

Soviet Period

After the end of the revolt in early April 1921, he left the country and lived in Bucharest from 1921 to 1924. In 1925 he returned to Soviet Armenia and worked as an architect in Leninakan. He also taught at the technical department of Yerevan State University, lecturing on construction and architecture. In 1930 he joined the newly established Construction Institute and attained the title of professor there. Kajaznuni became a member of the Armenian Union of Architects. Kajaznuni was a victim of Stalin's Great Terror—arrested in 1937 and imprisoned, he died in prison in 1938. The exact date of his death is unknown.^[12]

Report to the 1923 ARF Congress

Kajaznuni prepared a critical report for the Armenian Revolutionary Federation party convention held in Bucharest during April 1923 (the 10th Congress of the Party was held in 1924)^{[13][n 1][14][n 2]} titled Dashnaktsutyun Has Nothing More to Do, which called for the party's support of Soviet Armenia.^{[15][16][17][18]} Before this event, every single Armenian political party in exile was opposed to Soviet Armenia's stance.

Kajaznuni published his report in Vienna in 1923. In the same year it was republished by non-A.R.F. circles in Tbilisi, Alexandria (Egypt), and Bucarest.^[19] Its claims immediately drew rebuke from the party.^{[20][n 3][21][n 4][22][n 5]}

A condensed version of the report was translated into English in 1955 by Matthew Aram Callender, and edited by Arthur Derounian.^[23] In the introduction written by Derounian (whose birth name was Avedis Boghos Derounian), an anti-Dashnak journalist,^[24] Kajaznuni is described as a "patriot" whose report was a "deep and incisive self-study" that is a "refutation" of the "grandiose, exaggerated and even outrageously false claims of the Dashnag leadership today".^[25]

The Armenian original was reprinted twice in Yerevan in 1994 and 1995.

Turkish denialist translation

In 2007 Turkish historian and genocide denier Mehmet Perinçek produced new texts in Turkish and English that he claimed were translations of Kajaznuni's 1923 report, allegedly based on a Russian copy (printed in Tbilisi in 1927) held in the Russian State Library in Moscow.^[26] Perinçek alleged that the Russian State Library copy was unabridged and that translations for these copies were unavailable before, yet he had provided no proof for these claims. Callender's translation did abridge the main body of the book but translated Kajaznuni's introduction verbatim - this is the key section which contains the description of the holocaust.^{[n 6]} Mehmet Perinçek is the son of veteran politician Doğu Perinçek, who in 2007 became the first person to receive a criminal conviction for denial of the Armenian Genocide, a conviction that was overturned on free-speech grounds in 2015.

The Armenian scholar Viken L. Attarian claims Perinçek's "discovery" is actually a forgery made by partisan Turkish historians to deny the fact of the Armenian Genocide.^[30] As evidence for his position, Attarian notes that these alleged translations into Turkish, English and German were published by Kaynak Yayınları in Istanbul as the first in a book series titled Ermeni Belgeleriyle Ermeni Soykırımı Yalanı (in English: The Lie of the 'Armenian Genocide' in Armenian Documents).

Attarian said: "The Turkish denialists are the ones who talk most about Katchaznouni and ... use texts and falsified translations that have nothing in common with the originals... Whatever the Turk denialists present about K is wrong and a lie... Katchaznouni never denied the Genocide and ... never betrayed his homeland.". In Matthew A. Callender's translation, made directly from the original Armenian text, Kajaznuni clearly describes what happened to the Armenians as a "holocaust" (p. 7):

The second half of 1915 and the entire year of 1916 were periods of hopelessness, desperation and mourning for us. The refugees, all those who had survived the holocaust, were filling Russian provinces by tens and hundreds of thousands.^[31]

Bibliography

• Kachaznuni, Hovhannes (1923). Dashnaktsutiwne anelik chuni aylews. Vienna: Mkhitarean Tparan.
• Katchaznouni, Hovhannes (August 1955). Carlson, John Roy, ed. The Armenian Revolutionary Federation (Dashnagtzoutiun) Has Nothing to Do Anymore. Translated by A. Callender, Matthew. New York: Armenian Information Service. (Book cover), Full text online
• Ovanes Kachaznuni. The Hundred and Ten Days in Europe. Baku, 1911 (new edition in Russian, Saint Petersburg, 2013)

See also

• First Republic of Armenia
• John Roy Carlson

Notes

1. Svajian describes this as "...the manifesto to the 'Dashnag Party Congress' in Bucharest, April 1923. His manifesto is entitled, 'Dashnaktzoutune Has Nothing To Do Any More.'"
2. Bast's description is a "...book which was originally 'a manifesto' he had presented to the convention of the foreign branches of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation (Bucharest, 1923)"
3. Reuben Darbinian's first name is also transliterated as "Rouben", "Ruben", "Rooben", etc.
4. Gakavian writes "In the early 1920s the ARF experienced a split between its left and right wings over what policy the party should take towards Soviet Armenia. At the same time, the former Prime Minister of Armenia, Hovhannes Kachaznouni, published a book, The ARF Has Nothing More to Do, and migrated to Soviet Armenia. As the title suggests, Kachaznouni argued that the ARF and the other parties had no role to play in Armenian political life, now that Armenia was Bolshevik. The opponents of the ARF, of course, capitalised on this. In the same year, a response was written to Kachaznouni by high-ranking party member Rouben Darbinian, who argued that Kachaznouni was wrong to give up hope, because Sovietisation would be short lived, and the ARF needed to continue the struggle for freedom."
5. Derogy quotes an April 11, 1923 letter from Shahan Natali to the Boston committee: "I was informed too late to be able to express my view towards the item put on the agenda of the next interim conference in Vienna; the position of the Party toward the sovietization of Armenia. You are not without responsibility for this delay, which has prevented me from making the party return to its revolutionary line."
6. Katchaznouni's description of the holocaust is given on pages 6 and 7 of Matthew A. Callender's translation.^[27] A note on page 4 explains that Callender has translated most of Katchaznouni's remarks directly: "Except for abridgements, made for the sake of brevity by the translator and the editor, Katchaznouni's utterances appear verbatim."^[28] On page 8, after the holocaust description, Callender indicates that he is switching from verbatim to selective translation: "Translator's Note: Up to this point the words of the author have been translated verbatim in order to give an idea of Mr. Katchaznouni's logical mind and the exposition of the facts that drove him to present his 'Manifesto' to his colleagues at the 1923 Convention. From here on, and solely for the sake of brevity, we shall quote excerpts of his arguments which led to his decision as to why the Dashnagtzoutiun, in his opinion, should 'decisively end its existence' because 'there is no work for the Party.'"^[29]

References

1. Tigranian 2003, pp. 236–241.
2. Hovannisian 1971, p. 23.
3. Hovannisian 1971, p. 24.
4. Hovannisian 1971, pp. 24–25.
5. Hovannisian 1971, p. 25.
6. Hovannisian 1971, pp. 25–27.
7. Hovannisian 1971, pp. 27–28, note 60.
8. Hovannisian 1971, p. 27.
9. Hovannisian 1971, pp. 27–28.
10. Hovannisian 1971, p. 28.
11. Hovannisian 1971, p. 29–33.
12. Encyclopedia of the Armenian Question 1996, p. 456.
13. Svajian 1977, p. 418.
14. Bast 2002.
15. Katchaznouni 1923.
16. Hovannisian 1974, Footnote 12.
17. Nassibian 1984, p. 105.
18. Libaridian 1991, p. 20.
19. See http://www.armunicat.am:8991/ARMA and search for Յովհաննէս Քաջազնունի.
20. Darbinian 1923.
21. Gakavian 1997.
22. Derogy 1990, p. 167.
23. Katchaznouni 1955.
24. https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=rXfHAAAAQBAJ&pg=PA74&lpg=PA74&dq=avedis+derounian+ramgavar#v=onepage&q=avedis%20derounian%20ramgavar&f=false
25. Katchaznouni 1955, p. 3.
26. Özdemir 2007.
27. Katchaznouni 1955, pp. 6–7.
28. Katchaznouni 1955, p. 4.
29. Katchaznouni 1955, p. 8.
30. Attarian n.d.
31. Katchaznouni 1955, p. 7.

Sources

• Attarian, Viken L. "Hovhannes Katchaznouni - the Intellectual Politician and Unique Patriot (A Lecture in Armenian)". Montreal.
• Bast, Oliver (2002). La Perse et la Grande Guerre [Persia and the Great War] (in French). Institut français de recherche en Iran. ISBN 978-2-909961-23-1.
• Darbinian, Reuben (1923). Mer Pataskhane H. Kachaznunii [Our Answer/Response to H. Kachaznunii] (in Armenian). Boston: Hayrenik Tparan.
• Derogy, Jacques (1990). Resistance and Revenge. Transaction. ISBN 0-88738-338-6.
• Հայկական Հարց Հանրագիտարան [Encyclopedia of the Armenian Question] (in Armenian). Yerevan. 1996.
• Gakavian, Armen (October 1997). "Armenian Diasporan Identity Reimagined, 1915–1985". Homeland, Diaspora and Nationalism: The Reimagination of American-Armenian Identity Since Gorbachev (PhD thesis). Department of Government and Public Administration, University of Sydney. Archived from the original on August 22, 2011. Retrieved September 2, 2008.
• Hovannisian, Richard G. (1971). "The Republic of Armenia: The First Year, 1918–1919". University of California Press. ISBN 9780520018051.
• Hovannisian, Richard G. (January 1974). "Dimensions of Democracy and Authority in Caucasian Armenia, 1917–1920". Russian Review. Blackwell Publishing. 33 (1): 37–49. doi:10.2307/127620. JSTOR 127620.
• Katchaznouni, Hovhannes (July 1923). Dashnaktsutiune anelik chuni ailevs (in Armenian). Vienna: Mechitarist Press.
• Katchaznouni, Hovhannes (1955). The Armenian Revolutionary Federation Has Nothing To Do Any More: The Manifesto of Hovhannes Katchaznouni. Translated by Callender, Matthew A. New York: Armenian Information Service.
• Libaridian, Gerard J (September 1991). Armenia at the Crossroads: Democracy and Nationhood in the Post-Soviet Era. Blue Crane Books. ISBN 0-9628715-1-6.
• Nassibian, Akaby (1984). Britain and the Armenian question, 1915–1923. New York: St. Martin's Press. ISBN 978-0-312-09809-4. (also London and Sydney: Croom Helm)
• Özdemir, Sadi (November 2, 2007). "Ermeni isyanını Perinçek buldu İTO ABD'ye gönderiyor". Hürriyet (in Turkish). Retrieved August 7, 2008.
• Svajian, Stephen G (1977). A Trip Through Historic Armenia. GreenHill.
• Tigranian, Edmond (2003). Հայ ճարտարապետների գործունեությունը Անդրկովկասում XIX դարի վերջ - XX դարի սկիզբ [Contributions of Armenian Architects in the Transcaucausus at the End of the 19th Century and the Beginning of the 20th Century] (in Armenian). Yerevan.