John P. Elkin

John P. Elkin
Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
In office January 2, 1905 – October 3, 1915
Attorney General of Pennsylvania
In office January 18, 1899 – January 21, 1903
Preceded by	Henry Clay McCormick
Succeeded by	Hampton L. Carson
Personal details
Born	January 11, 1860 West Mahoning Township, Indiana County, Pennsylvania
Died	October 3, 1915 (aged 55) Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Political party	Republican
Spouse(s)	Adda Prothero
Children	3
Occupation	Judge, lawyer

John Pratt Elkin (January 11, 1860 – October 3, 1915) was a Pennsylvania lawyer and judge. He served a term as the state's Attorney General, and was an Associate Justice of the state's Supreme Court. He was a central figure in a scandal concerning influence buying on the Supreme Court.

Life and career

Elkin was born the son of Francis Elkin and Elizabeth Pratt. The family moved to the village of Smicksburg in 1869, where Elkin received a rudimentary education. In 1873, the family moved to Wellsville, Ohio, where the father opened a tin plate factory, and Elkin worked there in his early teens. In 1875, the factory failed, and the family moved back to Smicksburg, where Elkin was hired as a teacher.^[1]

In 1881, Elkin studied law at the University of Michigan, graduating in 1884. In 1884, he graduated, married Adda Prothero that summer, and was elected to the state House that fall. Elkin was admitted to the bar of Indiana County in 1885, and served two terms in the state House, 1885–86 and 1887–88.^[1]

Elkin was appointed Deputy Attorney General in 1895, which he resigned under pressure in 1897. He was also 1896 chairman of the state Republican committee, and had backed Senator Quay, the party's "kingmaker", for President.

Elkin was appointed Attorney General in 1899.

In 1902, Elkin tried to run for governor, and expected to win the Republican nomination on the first ballot, but Quay backed Judge Pennypacker and successfully bribed key Elkin supporters at the nomination convention.^[2][3]

In 1904, a vacancy arose on the state's Supreme Court. Governor Pennypacker was nominated by his party to run in the special election to replace the vacancy, but he declined. Elkin was then nominated and elected.^[4] Elkin served on the bench until his death in 1915.

Controversies

The Secretary of the Commonwealth, Frank Reeder, and Elkin were forced to resign by Governor Hastings over an "indemnification" bill. The pressure was claimed to be political maneuvering against Quay.^[5]

In 1899, when Quay was tainted with scandal and the state legislature refused to seat him, Elkin was his main defender in the General Assembly, and advised Governor Stone to proceed with the appointment.

In 1908, William Randolph Hearst published letters sent to various Pennsylvania officials by John Dustin Archbold, then vice-president of Standard Oil, suggesting judicial appointments. The two letters addressed to Elkin mentioned $15,000 in donations.^[6]

References

1. Blanchard 1900.
2. Hudson 1909, p. 327.
3. Kehl 1981, pp. 240–42.
4. Pennypacker, p. 346.
5. The Outlook 1897.
6. Hearst's 1912.

Further reading

• "—". The Outlook. 57 (4): 205. September 25, 1897.
• "More Archbold Letters". The Independent. Oct 29, 1908. pp. 1009–10.
• "Standard Oil and the Judiciary". Hearst's Magazine. XXII (3): 2–16. September 1912.
• Blanchard, Charles (1900). The Progressive Men of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. 2. Logansport, Indiana: A. W. Bowen & Company.
• Hudson, Sam (1909). Pennsylvania and its Public Men. Philadelphia: Hudson & Joseph.
• Kehl, James A. (1981). Boss Rule in the Gilded Age: Matt Quay of Pennsylvania. University of Pittsburgh.
• Pennypacker, Samuel W. (1918). The Autobiography of a Pennsylvanian. John C. Winston Company.

External links

• Biography by a descendant