Multi-threshold CMOS

Multi-threshold CMOS (MTCMOS) is a variation of CMOS chip technology which has transistors with multiple threshold voltages (V_th) in order to optimize delay or power. The V_th of a MOSFET is the gate voltage where an inversion layer forms at the interface between the insulating layer (oxide) and the substrate (body) of the transistor. Low V_th devices switch faster, and are therefore useful on critical delay paths to minimize clock periods. The penalty is that low V_th devices have substantially higher static leakage power. High V_th devices are used on non-critical paths to reduce static leakage power without incurring a delay penalty. Typical high V_th devices reduce static leakage by 10 times compared with low V_th devices.^[1]

One method of creating devices with multiple threshold voltages is to apply different bias voltages (Vb) to the base or bulk terminal of the transistors. Other methods involve adjusting the gate oxide thickness, gate oxide dielectric constant (material type), or dopant concentration in the channel region beneath the gate oxide.

A common method of fabricating multi-threshold CMOS involves simply adding additional photolithography and ion implantation steps.^[2] For a given fabrication process, the V_th is adjusted by altering the concentration of dopant atoms in the channel region beneath the gate oxide. Typically, the concentration is adjusted by ion implantation method. For example, photolithography methods are applied to cover all devices except the p-MOSFETs with photoresist. Ion implantation is then completed, with ions of the chosen dopant type penetrating the gate oxide in areas where no photoresist is present. The photoresist is then stripped. Photolithography methods are again applied to cover all devices except the n-MOSFETs. Another implantation is then completed using a different dopant type, with ions penetrating the gate oxide. The photoresist is stripped. At some point during the subsequent fabrication process, implanted ions are activated by annealing at an elevated temperature.

In principle, any number of threshold voltage transistors can be produced. For CMOS having two threshold voltages, one additional photomasking and implantation step is required for each of p-MOSFET and n-MOSFET. For fabrication of normal, low, and high V_th CMOS, four additional steps are required relative to conventional single-V_th CMOS.

Implementation

The most common implementation of MTCMOS for reducing power makes use of sleep transistors. Logic is supplied by a virtual power rail. Low V_th devices are used in the logic where fast switching speed is important. High V_th devices connecting the power rails and virtual power rails are turned on in active mode, off in sleep mode. High V_th devices are used as sleep transistors to reduce static leakage power.

The design of the power switch which turns on and off the power supply to the logic gates is essential to low-voltage, high-speed circuit techniques such as MTCMOS. The speed, area, and power of a logic circuit are influenced by the characteristics of the power switch.

In a "coarse-grained" approach, high V_th sleep transistors gate the power to entire logic blocks.^[3] The sleep signal is de-asserted during active mode, causing the transistor to turn on and provide virtual power (ground) to the low V_th logic. The sleep signal is asserted during sleep mode, causing the transistor to turn off and disconnect power (ground) from the low V_th logic. The drawbacks of this approach are that:

• logic blocks must be partitioned to determine when a block may be safely turned off (on)
• sleep transistors are large and must be carefully sized to supply the current required by the circuit block
• an always active (never in sleep mode) power management circuit must be added

In a "fine-grained" approach, high V_th sleep transistors are incorporated within every gate. Low V_th transistors are used for the pull-up and pull-down networks, and a high V_th transistor is used to gate the leakage current between the two networks. This approach eliminates problems of logic block partitioning and sleep transistor sizing. However, a large amount of area overhead is added due both to inclusion of additional transistors in every Boolean gate, and in creating a sleep signal distribution tree.

An intermediate approach is to incorporate high V_th sleep transistors into threshold gates having more complicated function. Since fewer such threshold gates are required to implement any arbitrary function compared to Boolean gates, incorporating MTCMOS into each gate requires less area overhead. Examples of threshold gates having more complicated function are found with Null Convention Logic^[4] and Sleep Convention Logic.^[5] Some art is required to implement MTCMOS without causing glitches or other problems.

References

1. Anis, M.; Areibi, Mahmoud, Elmasry, (2002). "Dynamic and leakage power reduction in MTCMOS circuits". Design Automation Conference, 2002. Proceedings. 39th (ISBN 1-58113-461-4): 480–485. Cite uses deprecated parameter |coauthors= (help)
2. Oklobdzija, Vojin G. (1997). Digital Design and Fabrication. CRC-Press. pp. 12–18. ISBN 978-0-8493-8602-2.
3. Smith, Scott and Di, Jia (2009). Designing Asynchronous Circuits using NULL Convention Logic (NCL). Morgan & Claypool Publishers. pp. 61–73. ISBN 978-1-59829-981-6.
4. Fant, Karl (2005). Logically Determined Design: clockless system design with NULL convention logic. John Wiley and Sons. ISBN 978-0-471-68478-7.
5. Smith, Scott and Di, Jia. "U.S. 7,977,972". Retrieved 2011-12-12.