National First XV Championship (New Zealand)
The National First XV Championship is the Premier Rugby Union competition for Secondary Schools/Colleges in New Zealand.
Qualification
The National First XV Championship is ultimately broken down via the Top 4, which is made up of the winners of the four regions: Blues, Chiefs, Hurricanes and South Island.
Each region operates its own different qualification system.
Blues:
The Northland and North Harbour champions meet, with the winner of that match facing the Auckland champion.
Chiefs:
Each regional province determines their own winner, followed by a knockout bracket.
Hurricanes:
The winner and runner-up of the Wellington Premiership and the top-two region schools that play in the Super 8 competition play in a seeded knockout. A 'challenger' place is available to any region school that does not play in either competition, with that match taking place prior to the seeded matches.
South Island: The winner of the match between the Crusaders winner and the Highlanders winner. The Crusaders winner is the top side from the region-wide UC Championship, while since the Highlanders-region competition was discontinued after 2015 a provincial-based knockout format has been used.
These 4 teams then have 2 semis finals with the winners advancing to the National 1st XV Final. The semifinal matchups change each year, for example the Blues winner plays the Hurricanes winner one year, the Chiefs winner the next, and finally the South Island winner in rotation.
As listed below, some titles have been shared. There have been calls for overtime to be included to determine an outright winner, but this is currently not allowed for under World Rugby's Under 19 variations. In the event of a drawn semi-final, the team that advances is determined by a hierachy of factors starting with which team scored the most tries in the match.
National Championship Finals
List of Top Schools
This list is based on those schools and colleges that have won the most National Top 4 titles since its inception in 1982. The decider being the number of runner up.
| Rank | College | Win(s) | Runner Up(s) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1st | Wesley College | 5 | 2 |
| 2nd | Kelston Boys High School | 5 | 0 |
| 3rd | Rotorua Boys' High School | 4 | 1 |
| 3rd = | Hamilton Boys High School | 4 | 1 |
| 5th | Gisborne Boys' High School | 3 | 2 |
| 6th | Christchurch Boys' High School | 3 | 1 |
| 6th = | Auckland Grammar | 3 | 1 |
| 6th = | Mount Albert Grammar | 3 | 1 |
| 9th | St Stephens College | 2 | 3 |
| 10th | Mount Albert Grammar | 2 | 1 |
| 11th | St Peter's College | 2 | 0 |
| 12th | Napier Boys' High School | 1 | 4 |
| 13th | Scots College | 1 | 1 |
| 13th = | Otago Boys' High School | 1 | 1 |
| 13th = | Saint Kentigern College | 1 | 1 |
| 16th | De La Salle College | 1 | 0 |
| 16th = | Te Aute College | 1 | 0 |
| 18th | Palmerston North Boys High School | 0 | 2 |
| 18th = | St Bedes College | 0 | 2 |
| 18th = | Wellington College | 0 | 2 |
| 21st | Kings College | 0 | 1 |
| 21st = | Southland Boys' High School | 0 | 1 |
| 21st = | St Paul's Collegiate School | 0 | 1 |
| 21st = | Waitaki Boys High School | 0 | 1 |
Wins by Region
| Chiefs | 15 Titles |
|---|---|
| Wesley College (Counties Secondary School Rep) | (5) |
| Hamilton Boys High School (Waikato Secondary School Rep) | (4) |
| Rotorua Boys High School (Bay of Plenty Secondary School Rep) | (4) |
| St Stephen's College (Counties Secondary School Rep) | (2) |
| Blues | 14 Titles |
|---|---|
| Kelston Boys High School (Auckland Secondary School Rep) | (5) |
| Auckland Grammar (Auckland Secondary School Rep) | (3) |
| Mount Albert Grammar (Auckland Secondary School Rep) | (3) |
| St Peters College (Auckland Secondary School Rep) | (2) |
| De La Salle College (Auckland Secondary School Rep) | (1) |
| Saint Kentigern College (Auckland Secondary School Rep) | (1) |
| Hurricanes | 6 Titles |
|---|---|
| Gisborne Boys' High School (Poverty Bay Secondary School Rep) | (3) |
| Napier Boys High School (Hawkes Bay Secondary School Rep) | (1) |
| Scots College (Wellington Secondary School Rep) | (1) |
| Te Aute College (Hawkes Bay Secondary School Rep) | (1) |
| South (Crusaders/Highlanders) | 4 Titles |
|---|---|
| Christchurch Boys High School (Canterbury Secondary School Rep, Crusaders Rep) | (3) |
| Otago Boys High School (Otago Secondary School Rep, Highlanders Rep) | (1) |
National Co-Ed 1st XV championship
In 2007 a co-educational division was added to the top 1st XV Top Four tournament as an avenue for these schools to participate on a similar basis to the open division. Co-ed schools have the option to choose to play in either competition, but must declare this by a designated date and once they do so are ineligible for the other. Notably in 2011 Saint Kentigern College elected to try and defend their Co-ed title, but also went on to win the Auckland schools title. Having chosen the Co-ed route (which they) the national place was taken by Kelston who went on to win that title.
Like the national championship, the Top Four comprises the respective winners of the Co-ed sections from the Blues, Hurricanes, Chiefs and South Island regions with each region again setting their own process for identifying their representative.
Co-ed championship finals
| Year | Winner | Score | Runner-up |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2007 | Tamaki College | 22-15 | Mana College |
| 2008 | Mana College & St Andrews College shared | 6-6 | |
| 2009 | Feilding High School | 31-9 | Aorere College |
| 2010 | Saint Kentigern College | 37-22 | Manurewa High School |
| 2011 | Saint Kentigern College | 53-24 | Cambridge High School |
| 2012 | Onehunga High School | 18-11 | St Andrews College |
| 2013 | Tangaroa College | 32-13 | Manurewa High School |
| 2014 | Feilding High School | 43-10 | Cambridge High School |
| 2015 | St Andrews College | 30-13 | Cambridge High School |
| 2016 | Feilding High School | 25-5 | Aorere College |
Girls 1st XV championship
A third tournament was added in 2012 reflecting the growth of girls rugby. Like the two boys championships its brings together the winners of the four regions.
Girls championship finals
| Year | Winner | Score | Runner-up |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2012 | Feilding High School | 22-5 | Auckland Girls' Grammar School |
| 2013 | Feilding High School | 29-12 | Southland Girls' High School |
| 2014 | Hamilton Girls' High School | 73-0 | Southern Cross Campus |
| 2015 | Hamilton Girls' High School | 27-5 | Southland Girls' High School |
| 2016 | Southland Girls' High School | 46-29 | St Mary's College, Wellington |
Traditional fixtures
During the regular season the majority of schools also compete in traditional fixtures or rivalries. Some of these traditional fixtures (more commonly known as 'Traditionals') date back to the mid to late 19th Century. Listed below are some notable traditional fixtures (in no particular order):
| School | School | Title of Traditional Fixture | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Palmerston North Boys High School | vs | Napier Boys High School | Polson Banner (Competed since 1904) |
| Palmerston North Boys High School | vs | Wanganui Collegiate | (Competed since 1923) |
| Palmerston North Boys High School | vs | St Patrick's College Silverstream | (Competed since 1933) |
| Auckland Grammar | vs | Kings College | (Competed since 1896) |
| Wesley College | vs | St Stephens College | Gill Trophy (Contested since 1847) |
| Christchurch Boys High School | vs | Otago Boys High School | (Competed since 1894) |
| Otago Boys High School | vs | Kavanagh College High School | (Competed since 1938) |
| Otago Boys High School | vs | Southland Boys High School | (Competed since 1902) |
| Wesley College | vs | Te Aute College | Scarlett Trophy |
| Wellington College | vs | St Patrick's College (Town) | Centennial Shield (Competed since 1885) |
| Wellington College | vs | St Patrick's College (Silverstream) | Ken Gray Memorial (Competed since 1931) |
| Wellington College | vs | Christchurch Boys' High School | (Competed since 1995) |
| Wesley College | vs | Rotorua Boys High School | Chris Grinter Trophy |
| Hamilton Boys High School | vs | Auckland Grammar | |
| Christchurch Boys High School | vs | Christs College | (Competed since 1892) |
| Waitaki Boys High School | vs | St Kevins College | Blood Match |
| De La Salle | vs | Otahuhu College | |
| St Stephens College | vs | Te Aute College | Whetumaharatanga Trophy (Competed 1930-2001) |
| Te Aute College | vs | Gisborne Boys High School | Rongowhakaata Trophy |
| Gisborne Boys High School | vs | Napier Boys High School | (Competed since 1911) |
| Napier Boys High School | vs | Hastings Boys High School | (Competed since 1931) |
| Rosmini College | vs | Westlake Boys High School | |
| St Kentigern College | vs | Green Bay High School | Competed since 1983 for the Paul Smortions Memorial Trophy |
| Glendowie College | vs | Tamaki College | Dox Lodorum Cup |
| ACG Senior College | vs | ACG Strathallan College | Paul R. Smeenis Memorial Banner |
| Nelson College | vs | Christchurch Boys High School | |
| Timaru Boys High School | vs | Waitaki Boys College | (Competed since 1884 - Reputedly the longest continuous match in New Zealand) |
| New Plymouth Boys High School | vs | Francis Douglas Memorial College | (Competed since 1996) |
| Sacred Heart College | vs | Gisborne Boys High School | |
| St Patrick's College, Town | vs | St Patrick's College, Silverstream | Old Boys' Cup (Competed since 1931) |
| Wataki Boys' High School | vs | Otago Boys' High School | (Competed since 1905) |
| Timaru Boys' High School | vs | Otago Boys' High School | (Competed since 1907) |
| Christ's College | vs | Otago Boys' High School | (Competed since 1883) |
| Kings' College | vs | Wanganui Collegiate | (Competed since 1920) |
| St Patrick's College, (Town) | vs | Rongotai College | (Competed since 1958) |
| St Patrick's College, (Town) | vs | St Bedes' College | (Competed since 1920) |
| St Patrick's College, (Silverstream) | vs | Rongotai College | (Competed since 1957) |
| St Patrick's College, (Silverstream) | vs | New Plymouth Boys' High School | (Competed since 1931) |
| Wanganui Collegiate | vs | New Plymouth Boys' High School | (Competed since 1920) |
| Onehunga High School | vs | Massey High School | (Competed Since 2012) |
Moascar Cup
The oldest and most prestigious nationwide trophy in 1st XV rugby dates back to the end of World War One. At the end of the Great War, ten divisions of troops, six British, three Australian and a New Zealand division were waiting in Ismailia, Egypt to be sent home. Authorities within these divisions decided competitive sport would be a good way to fill in the time. A committee of officers was formed and they visited Cairo in search of a suitable trophy for a rugby tournament. When they returned they had a magnificent but somewhat cumbersome trophy made of Sterling Silver and stamped with "Made in London, 1904". The trophy was named the Moascar Cup. (Moascar was thought to be the name of a village in Egypt but it is, in fact Arabic for "camp".) It was decided that the trophy in honour of the occasion should be mounted on the centre part of a sawn off German propeller shot down in Palestine. The Cup, also contested by a South African division, was won by the New Zealand Mounted Rifle Brigade who won eight and drew one of its nine games.
On return to New Zealand, there was considerable debate about what was the best use for the trophy. It was agreed that it should be returned to the New Zealand Rugby Union and used for an appropriate competition. The individual charged with convincing the New Zealand Rugby Union of the trophy’s merit was Lieutenant-Colonel E J Hublert, commanding officer of the Mounted Rifle Brigade. The trophy was accepted and the New Zealand Rugby Union decided the best use for the trophy was to use it to promote Secondary Schools rugby which had suffered badly because of the War. A knockout competition in both the North and South Islands was inaugurated with the final to be played at Athletic Park in Wellington. However the best intentions of administrators were undone by apathetic attitudes by some schools and three years of expensive and time-consuming matches. Soon the knockout competition was abolished and replaced by a challenge system.
The current rules state that holders must nominate matches in which other schools can compete for it. A total of 7 matches must be announced once the cup is in contention. There used to be a tendency where holders would withhold putting the cup up for grabs against stronger opposition while making it available against perceived lesser sides. Doing so reduced the risk of losing the cup. There have been calls for the cup to be put up more regularly such is the demand and prestige of it. Many have voiced that the cup be put up at all home games and all knock out fixtures.
Another call to change has been regarding a tied score at full time. Like the National Top 4, no extra time is applied. The Moascar Cup defender continues to hold the cup if the scores are tied at full time. There is an overwhelming need to include an extra time period to determine an outright winner.
The current holder is Nelson College which beat St Thomas of Canterbury College in July 2016.[1]
Super 8 and Quadrangular Tournament
There are two other major tournaments that are contested. Neither hold effect on qualification to the National Top 4. However the Moascar Cup may be put up for contention.
Formed in 1997, the New Zealand Super Eight group of schools incorporates the 8 boys' high schools from their respective provincial cities of the central North Island. The first sporting competitions were sponsored by Canterbury International and commenced in 1998, involving rugby and cricket. Since that time, the Super Eight concept has grown to include not only 10 sports competitions, but also a cultural festival and professional development programmes for management staff and curriculum teachers. For rugby, many argue that the Super 8 is on par with the Auckland 1A competition where both are the toughest pre-Top 4 round robin competitions in New Zealand secondary school rugby. The Super 8 is contested between, Gisborne Boys High School, Hamilton Boys High School, Rotorua Boys High School, Tauranga Boys High School, Napier Boys High School, Hastings Boys High School, New Plymouth Boys High School and Palmerston North Boys High School.
The Quadrangular Tournament is the oldest secondary school rugby tournament which is competed between Wanganui Collegiate, Wellington College, Nelson College and Christ's College. It was initially known as the Triangular Tournament from 1890 to 1924 till Nelson College joined in 1925. In 2012 the 85th Quadrangular Tournament was contested. Regardless of being oldest tournament in New Zealand secondary school rugby, it does not receive the same recognition as the National Top 4, Auckland 1A or Super 8 as no school that competes in it has ever gone on to win a National Championship (with the exception of Nelson College that won the Moascar Cup in 2016).
References
- ↑ Page, Jacob (2016-07-09). "Injury time penalty keeps Moascar Cup in Nelson". Nelson Live. Retrieved 2016-07-18.
A last-gasp penalty goal ensured Nelson College would keep the Moascar Cup with a 27-25 victory over a determined St Thomas' of Canterbury in secondary school rugby action today.
- ↑ http://blog.skysport.co.nz/collegerugby/a-history-of-the-moascar-cup/
- ↑ http://blog.skysport.co.nz/collegerugby/holders-of-the-moascar-cup/
- ↑ Super 8 schools
- ↑ https://sites.google.com/a/wellington-college.school.nz/rugby-club/draws/quad-2011