Olivia Egleston

Phelps Egleston family tree published in Stokes Records 1910

Olivia Egleston was born Middletown, Connecticut on March 30, 1784, and died New York 24 April 1859. She was the daughter of Elihu and Elizabeth (Olcott) Egleston and the wife of businessman Anson Greene Phelps, co-founder of the Phelps Dodge Company. The other partners in the business were their son Anson and sons-in-law, Daniel James, William Dodge and James Stokes. After the death of Olivia's husband on the 30 November 1853, the partners in the firm bought his holdings from her for seven hundred thousand dollars.^[1] Olivia, who was also the sole executrix of his will, continued to live in their home on the East River with her daughter Olivia and husband Benjamin Bakewell Atterbury plus their children.^[2]

This house had originally been built by Henry A. Coster, the Dutch merchant, in about 1810. He planted the grounds with rare fruit, plants, trees, and it was said to have been one of the finest private gardens in America. It was bought by Phelps in 1835 who then acquired adjoining properties, so that the land eventually extended from Third Avenue to the East River, and from Twenty-ninth to half-way between Thirty-third and Thirty-fourth streets. The house was of old Colonial architecture, with out-buildings, hothouses, a large conservatory of rare fruits and flowers, gardener's lodge, stabling, summer house and boat house. From the east portico there were views over the lawn, garden, pasture, and river. A cedar of Lebanon that shaded the ice-house was said to have been brought from Mount Lebanon by Henry Coster.^[3]

The Anson Greene Phelps house New York on the East river, formally owned by Henry A. Coster, the Dutch merchant.

Olivia Egleston shared in her husband’s religious devotion and charitable works, supporting many causes including the Society for the Relief of Half Orphans and for 25 years she was a member of the board for the Association for the Relief of Aged and Respectable Indigent Woman.^[4] In her home, she entertained missionaries and evangelists including Charles Grandison Finney who, with his family, stayed with the Phelps during his preaching at the Presbyterian church in Vandewater Street, New York (1829-1830).^[5]

Olivia’s final years were difficult. Initially there were three executors of her husband's will, Olivia, her son Anson and son-in-law William Earl Dodge. Anson and Dodge withdrew because of conflicts of interest in respect to their business connections to Phelps Dodge & Co. The will was contested on many points by the beneficiaries, including their children and grandchildren, and Olivia sought clarification via the courts. The complexity of the arguments resulted in up to 12 lawyers in court at any one time.^[6] In 1858 tragedy struck when Olivia’s only son, Anson Greene Phelps Jr., died of smallpox and within a year Olivia was dead. It was 1861 before the final verdict on Anson Greene Phelps's will was given by the Court of Appeal.^[7][8]

Children of Anson Greene and Olivia (Egleston) Phelps

Elizabeth Woodbridge Phelps, born in Hartford, Connecticut, 22 August 1807; died 19 June 1847; married in New York City 24 March 1829 Daniel James.

Melissa Phelps, born in Hartford 3 March 1809; died in New York City 15 March 1903, married 24 June 1828 William Earle Dodge.

Caroline Olivia Phelps, born in Hartford 5 January 1811; died young, probably before 30 November 1812, when another daughter was named Caroline.

Caroline Phelps, born in Hartford 30 November 1812; died in New York City 9 March 1881, married in New York City 12 April 1837 James Boulter Stokes.

Harriet Phelps, born in Hartford or New York City 24 September 1815; died in New York City 24 April 1892, married 24 May 1836 Charles F. Pond.^{[lower-alpha 1]}

Anson Greene Phelps Jr.., born in New York City 13 October 1818; died in New York City 18 May 1858, married 1845 Jane Gibson.^{[lower-alpha 2]}

Olivia Egleston Phelps, born in New York City 5 January 1821; died at The Dakota, New York City, 30 March 1894, married 21 April 1847 Benjamin Bakewell Atterbury.^{[lower-alpha 3]}

Lydia Ann Phelps, born in New York City 5 March 1823; interred in the Phelps vault in New York Marble Cemetery 13 July 1831.^[9]

Notes

1. Charles Floyer Pond, the only child of Caleb Pond, was born in Hartford, Connecticut, 21 January 1809, and died at his residence in the same city, 10 May 1867. He was President of the New Haven, Hartford and Springfield Railroad Company.
2. Jane Gibson, daughter of New York merchant James and his wife Catherine (Van Keuren) Gibson; born 1819, died 31 December 1908 and buried in Sleepy Hollow Cemetery. She took interest in many charities. Anson and Jane's house at Sleepy Hollow was eventually purchased by their cousin Arthur Curtiss James.
3. Benjamin Bakewell Atterbury, born Newark, New Jersey, 8 August 1815, died New York, 2 May 1900. Related to Bishop Atterbury and grandson of judge Elisha Boudinot who was the brother of Elias Boudinot.

References

1. Cleland, Robert Glass (1952). A History of Phelps Dodge. New York: Alfred A Knopf. p. 37.
2. "New York, State Census, 1855,". Family Search. FamilySearch. Retrieved 5 November 2014.
3. STOKES, ANSON PHELPS (1910). Stokes Records Vol 1 (Part 1 ed.). New York: Printed Privately. pp. 13–16.
4. Annual report and by-laws of the Association for the Relief of Respectable Aged Indigent Females. Broadway New York: John F Trow. 1859. p. 6. Retrieved 11 November 2014.
5. Rosell/Dupuis, Garth/Richard (1989). The Original Memoirs of Charles G Finney. Michigan: Zondervan. pp. Chapter XX Revivals in Columbia and New York City.
6. "The Will of Anson G Phelps" (Morning Edition). New York Herald. 23 July 1856.
7. "PHELPS' EXECUTOR v. POND". casetext. COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK. Retrieved 7 November 2014.
8. "Case and Opinion upon the Will of Anson G. Phelps". HathiTrust’s digital library. Retrieved 14 November 2014.
9. Tombstone of Daniel and Elizabeth (Phelps) James (Volume 144 Number 1 ed.). The New York Genealogical and Biographical Record. January 2013. p. 45.