Civil union in New Zealand

Civil union has been legal in New Zealand since 26 April 2005. The Civil Union Act 2004 to establish the institution of civil union for same-sex and opposite-sex couples was passed by the Parliament on 9 December 2004.^[1] The Act has been described as very similar to the Marriage Act 1955 with references to "marriage" replaced by "civil union". A companion bill, the Relationships (Statutory References) Act, was passed shortly thereafter on 15 March 2005, to remove discriminatory provisions on the basis of relationship status from a range of statutes and regulations. As a result of these bills, all couples in New Zealand, whether married, in a civil union, or in a de facto partnership, now generally enjoy the same rights and undertake the same obligations. These rights extend to immigration, next-of-kin status, social welfare, matrimonial property and other areas. Non-married couples are not however permitted to adopt children, although people in non-marital relationships can adopt as individuals.^[2]

History

Both the Civil Union Bill and the Relationships (Statutory References) Bill were promoted as part of their Ministerial responsibilities by the Labour MPs and Ministers David Benson-Pope and Lianne Dalziel. The Civil Union Bill was treated as a conscience issue by most parties, including the largest parties on the left and right, and passed its third and final reading by 65 votes to 55.^[3]

Civil Union Bill – Third Reading^[3]

Party		Votes for	Votes against
	Labour	45 Rick Barker Tim Barnett David Benson-Pope Georgina Beyer Mark Burton Chris Carter Steve Chadwick Ashraf Choudhary Helen Clark Michael Cullen David Cunliffe Lianne Dalziel Helen Duncan Ruth Dyson Russell Fairbrother Martin Gallagher Phil Goff Mark Gosche Ann Hartley George Hawkins Dave Hereora Marian Hobbs Pete Hodgson Parekura Horomia Darren Hughes Jonathan Hunt Annette King Winnie Laban Janet Mackey Moana Mackey Steve Maharey Nanaia Mahuta Trevor Mallard Mahara Okeroa David Parker Mark Peck Jill Pettis Lynne Pillay Mita Ririnui Dover Samuels Jim Sutton Paul Swain Judith Tizard Margaret Wilson Dianne Yates	6 Clayton Cosgrove Damien O'Connor Harry Duynhoven Taito Phillip Field Ross Robertson John Tamahere
	National	3 Katherine Rich Clem Simich Pansy Wong	24 Shane Ardern Don Brash Gerry Brownlee David Carter John Carter Judith Collins Brian Connell Bill English Sandra Goudie Phil Heatley Paul Hutchison John Key Wayne Mapp Murray McCully Simon Power Tony Ryall Lynda Scott Lockwood Smith Nick Smith Roger Sowry Georgina te Heuheu Lindsay Tisch Maurice Williamson Richard Worth
	NZ First	2 Brian Donnelly Ron Mark	11 Peter Brown Brent Catchpole Bill Gudgeon Dail Jones Craig McNair Pita Paraone Edwin Perry Jim Peters Winston Peters Barbara Stewart Doug Woolerton
	ACT	5 Rodney Hide Richard Prebble Heather Roy Ken Shirley	5 Deborah Coddington Gerry Eckhoff Stephen Franks Muriel Newman Kenneth Wang
	Green	9 Sue Bradford Rod Donald Ian Ewen-Street Jeanette Fitzsimons Sue Kedgely Keith Locke Nandor Tanczos Metiria Turei Mike Ward	–
	United Future	–	8 Paul Adams Marc Alexander Larry Baldock Gordon Copeland Peter Dunne Bernie Ogilvy Murray Smith Judy Turner
	Progressive	2 Jim Anderton Matt Robson	–
	Māori	–	1 Tariana Turia
Totals		65	55

During consideration of the bill, various amendments were proposed. These included making the issue subject to a binding referendum, (a motion moved by New Zealand First MP Ron Mark who voted for the first two readings of the Bill, but against in its final vote). Another was to replace it with a "civil relationships" bill that would allow any two people to register any personal relationship and to gain joint property rights (moved by National MP Richard Worth, a consistent opponent of the bill). These proposals were dismissed by supporters of the bill as delaying tactics rather than serious proposals and were defeated in Parliament by a block vote of Labour, the Greens, and the Progressives.

The Relationships (Statutory References) Bill was also treated as a conscience vote and passed by 76 votes to 44 votes.^[4]

Civil Unions came into effect on Tuesday 26 April 2005 for licence applications and at least two couples had applied for licenses by 9:30 that morning. The first civil union ceremonies were performed on Friday 29 April 2005 (marriage and civil union licences need to be applied for at least three working days before the ceremony).

Public opinion

Before passage, the New Zealand public supported the bill, with opinion polls indicating around 56 per cent in favour. The bill was controversial in some quarters, attracting strong opposition from the evangelical Destiny Church and the Catholic Church in New Zealand. However, not all Christians were opposed to the Bill. Christians for Civil Unions played a role in the debates^[5] along with other Christian groups including the World Student Christian Federation.^[6]

In the build up to the vote, there were several instances of anti-gay and lesbian protests and rallies as a way of dissuading public favour. The most publicised rally was the 'Enough is Enough' march through central Wellington, terminating at Parliament, in August 2004. The march was organised by the Brian Tamaki-led Destiny Church and involved thousands of church members and supporters, many wearing black shirts, marching down Lambton Quay punching the air with their fists and chanting 'enough is enough'. Also present on this march were members of the Christian Heritage Party and white supremacist group National Front.

Other protest action saw a theology student cover the windows of David Benson-Pope's South Dunedin electoral office with posters denouncing the bill. These bore the message 'Civil Unions Is (sic) Not Gay Marriage. Yeah Right' in a parody of Tui beer advertisements. Three months after the Civil Union Act came into effect, a Herald-DigiPoll survey revealed that a plurality of people who expressed an opinion either way were happy with the legislation. When asked "whether they were happy or unhappy with the way the law allowing civil unions is working," 46% said they were happy, 35.7% were unhappy, and 18.1% were undecided or refused to comment.^[7]

Conservative Christian groups such as Family First New Zealand have questioned the low uptake of civil unions.^[8] LGBT organisations claim that this criticism is unfounded as there are fewer divorces after incompatible civil unions than with heterosexual marriages, particularly amongst Christians in the Southern US, who have displayed a higher than average divorce rate.^[9] This suggests that LGBT community members and heterosexuals who enter civil unions give more prior deliberation than those who enter heterosexual marriages.

Numbers

A civil union ceremony in Wellington, late 2006.

As at 31 December 2012, 2455 civil unions were registered to New Zealand residents. These comprised 1920 same-sex unions, of which 1131 had been between females and 789 had been between males, and 535 opposite-sex unions. In addition, 474 civil unions were registered to overseas residents. 124 civil unions had been dissolved.^[10][11]

Civil unions of New Zealand residents in New Zealand, 2005-12^[11]

Year	Same-sex civil unions		Opposite-sex civil unions	Total civil unions
	Female couples	Male couples
2005	105	98	46	249
2006	182	115	77	374
2007	150	103	63	316
2008	145	111	71	327
2009	147	97	68	312
2010	127	73	73	273
2011	133	99	69	301
2012	142	93	68	303

See also

• Marriage in New Zealand
• Same-sex marriage in New Zealand
• LGBT rights in New Zealand
• LGBT in New Zealand
• Property (Relationships) Act 1976

References

1. "Civil Unions Bill passed". The New Zealand Herald. 9 December 2004. Retrieved 24 September 2011.
2. Collins, Simon (20 August 2009). "Judge: Time to let gay couples adopt". The New Zealand Herald. Retrieved 2009-08-20.
3. Civil Unions Act
4. Relationships (Statutory References) Act
5. "Christians support Civil Unions Bill". Scoop. 16 June 2004.
6. "Student Christian Movement submission on the Civil Union bill".
7. Berry, Ruth (1 July 2005). "Majority happy with civil union, prostitution laws". NZ Herald.
8. Civil Unions Irrelevant Five Years On
9. U.S. divorce rates for various faith groups, age groups, & geographic areas
10. "Marriages, Civil Unions, and Divorces: Year ended December 2012" (PDF). Statistics New Zealand. 3 May 2013. Retrieved 8 August 2013.
11. "Marriages, Civil Unions, and Divorces: Year ended December 2012 – tables". Statistics New Zealand. 3 May 2013. Retrieved 8 August 2013.

External links

• Parliamentary Counsel Office - text of the Civil Union Act 2004
• Department of Internal Affairs on civil unions