Same-sex marriage in New Hampshire

Same-sex marriage has been legal in New Hampshire since January 1, 2010, based on legislation signed into law by the governor on June 3, 2009. The law provided that civil unions, which the state had established as of January 1, 2008, would be converted to marriages on January 1, 2011, unless dissolved, annulled, or converted to marriage before that date.

Civil unions

Following the first same-sex marriages in Massachusetts in May 2004, New Hampshire established a 14-member commission to consider the question of civil recognition of same-sex relationships. The group, composed of legislators, politicians, and activists, reported its findings in November 2005. By a 7-to-4 vote it recommended modifying the state constitution to restrict marriage to heterosexual unions, reinforcing the state's statutory definition of marriage to prevent the judiciary from finding a constitutional requirement that same-sex couples be allowed to wed. Their report opposed as well the idea of civil unions like those recognized in Vermont in July 2000. The commission proposed instead certificates that would guarantee certain rights like hospital visitation, but no financial benefits. The certificates would be available to siblings, parents, and children as well. The commission members who dissented said it spent too much time hearings attacks on the morality of homosexuality. The chairman, Tony Soltani, a Republican member of the state House of Representatives, said; "If we redefined marriage, we'd be tarred and feathered, but if we give them some rights, it will be accepted." He said homosexuality could not be compared to race, because it is an "acquired behavior" or a "combination of both nature and nurture." He added: "I know it's not a long-term solution, but it is something a child can point to and say, my representatives say I'm OK, and I'm not a freak."^[1][2]

Democrats became the majority party in the New Hampshire state legislature in the 2006 general election. Both Democratic and Republican legislators proposed legislation to grant same-sex couples greater civil rights. The proposals ranged from allowing a couple to enter into a "contractual cohabitation," a "civil union," a "spousal union," or a same-sex marriage. Governor John Lynch opposed same-sex marriage, but indicated that he was receptive to discussing civil unions as a means of granting certain rights to same-sex couples.^[3]

In early 2007, the legislature briefly considered a bill authorizing same-sex marriage until Democratic leaders assigned it to a study committee.^[4] On April 4, 2007, by a vote of 243 to 129, the New Hampshire House passed a civil unions bill that gave partners in same-sex civil unions the same "rights, responsibilities and obligations" as heterosexual married couples.^[5][6][7] Lynch took no public position until April 19, when he said that he would sign legislation establishing civil unions for same-sex couples because he believed "it is a matter of conscience, fairness and preventing discrimination."^[4][8] On April 26, 2007, the New Hampshire Senate approved the civil unions bill 14-10 on a party line vote.^[9][10][11] On May 31, 2007, Governor John Lynch signed the civil unions bill into law,^[12][13] making New Hampshire "the first state to embrace same-sex unions without a court order or the threat of one."^[11] The law took effect January 1, 2008.^[14] Licenses for civil unions became available on December 10, 2007^[15][16] allowing civil unions to be formalized in the very early hours of January 1, 2008. Deputy secretary of state David Scanlan said, "As far as we're concerned, everything is on schedule."^[15]

The first civil unions were formed throughout New Hampshire just after midnight on January 1, 2008. The largest gathering occurred on the steps of the State House in Concord. An estimated 40 couples participated as 200-300 friends, family and onlookers observed. The event drew one protestor who "quietly handed out a statement calling all sex outside of heterosexual marriage a sin".^[17]

Under the New Hampshire civil unions law, same-sex civil unions or marriages conducted in other jurisdictions were recognized as civil unions in New Hampshire.^[18] Representative Maureen Mooney introduced legislation to repeal that portion of the civil unions bill, but her proposal was deemed inexpedient to legislate, a legislative procedure equivalent to not passing the bill out of committee.^[19][20][21]

At the end of 2008, after the law had been in effect for one year, approximately 600 civil union licenses had been issued by the state, while approximately 8,700 marriage licenses were issued by the state during the same period.^[22][23]

Civil unions in practice

Though the civil union law intended to provide "all the rights and ... obligations and responsibilities provided for in state law that apply to parties who are joined together,"^[24] they actually entailed a more limited set of benefits and limitations.^[25][26][27] The benefits included:

• Access to medical care information and decision making;
• Access to proceedings and information related to partner's death, and ability to make funeral arrangements;
• Right to be placed in the same room in a nursing home;
• Health care coverage under state-regulated family plans;
• State pension benefits;
• Inheritance without a will;
• Ability to transfer property between partners without paying state taxes;
• Ability to change names by showing civil union certificate to government agencies, banks, etc. and simply stating a name preference;
• Pay or receive alimony and/or child support ordered by a court in a divorce;
• Ability to adopt as a stepparent.^[26]

The limitations associated with civil unions included:

• Legal status only recognized in certain states;
• Unclear divorce proceedings should one or both partners move out-of-state;
• If partner's death occurs out-of-state, unclear whether surviving partner may obtain death certificate and claim body;
• Employers governed by federal laws are allowed to provide health and other benefits only to heterosexual couples on a tax-free basis, whereas same-sex couples must pay income taxes on the value of such benefits;
• Partners are treated as unmarried adults under more than 1,100 federal laws;
• May jeopardize a couple's ability to adopt overseas;
• Federal privacy laws can prohibit access to some medical care information without durable power of attorney.^[26]

Marriage

In 1987, New Hampshire modified its statutes to make same-sex marriages invalid.^[28]

On March 18, 2009, the New Hampshire House of Representatives Judiciary Committee sent a same-sex marriage bill, HB 436, to the floor of the House without a recommendation following a tied 10-10 vote.^[29] On March 26, the House voted 182-183, but after a motion to reconsider the first vote, the measure passed 186-179.^[30][31][32] On April 23, the New Hampshire Senate Judiciary Committee by a vote of 3-2 recommended that the full Senate defeat the bill, but a week later the Senate approved an amended version of the bill 13-11.^[33] The amended bill passed the House on May 6, 2009. Governor John Lynch had yet to take a position on the legislation^[34][35] and had five days to exercise his veto.^[36] The bill recognized out-of-state civil unions as marriages. Couples who had New Hampshire Civil Unions would be able to apply for a marriage license, however if they did not apply for a marriage certificate their civil unions would automatically be converted to marriages on January 1, 2011.^[37]

On May 14, Lynch, though personally opposed to same-sex marriages, said he would sign the bill provided it contained increased protections for churches against lawsuits if they refuse to marry same-sex couples.^[38][39] Legislative leaders indicated on the same day that they would allow the changes.^[40] On May 20, 2009, the Senate passed the changes 14-10 along party lines, but the House unexpectedly failed to agree later in the day by a vote of 188-186.^[41] Opponents in that body tried to kill the bill, but failed 173 to 202.^[42] The House then voted 207-168 to ask the Senate to negotiate a compromise.^[42] On May 29, the two chambers reached a compromise with some minor changes that the governor approved.^[43] The revised legislation was approved 14–10 by the Senate and 198–176 by the House on June 3 and signed by the Governor shortly thereafter.^[44][45][46] Lynch was the second governor in the United States to sign a bill to legalize same-sex marriage, the first being John Baldacci of Maine. The definition of marriage in New Hampshire is now the following:^[47]

Marriage is the legally recognized union of 2 people. Any person who otherwise meets the eligibility requirements of this chapter may marry any other eligible person regardless of gender.

Statistics

From 2010 to 2013, approximately 2,329 same-sex couples wed in New Hampshire.^[48]

Transition from civil unions to marriage

As of January 1, 2010, no new civil unions were established in the state.^[49] Parties to a valid civil union before that date were able to have their marriages solemnized, provided they met the legal requirements of the state marriage laws. Additionally, such persons in civil unions before January 1, 2010, were able to record their civil unions with the town or city clerk who recorded the civil union and receive a marriage license, with no additional fee or solemnization required. A civil union entered into before January 1, 2010, that had not been dissolved, annulled, or transformed into a marriage, was converted to a marriage on January 1, 2011.^[37]

Repeal efforts

In 2010, the legislature considered two repeal proposals, a bill to repeal both the same-sex marriage law and the state's 2007 civil union law and a constitutional amendment to ban same-sex marriage.^[50][51][52] The New Hampshire House defeated both of them on February 17, 2010.^[53][54][55]

On October 25, 2011, the House Judiciary Committee voted 11-6 for a bill repealing same-sex marriage and establishing civil unions far more limited than the state's earlier civil unions. The new civil unions would not be covered by the state's anti-discrimination law and no one would be required to recognize them as the equivalent of opposite-sex marriages. The bill's effect on same-sex marriages already performed in the state was disputed.^[56] In January 2012, Representative David Bates, the principal sponsor of the legislation,^[57] said the bill would be the first legislative repeal of same-sex marriage in the U.S.^[58] and Governor John Lynch announced he would veto any repeal of the state's same-sex marriage statute.^[59] New Hampshire Republicans were generally identified with the repeal effort and they controlled the 400-member House by a 3-1 margin. The Nashua Telegraph termed the failure of the repeal effort in March 2012 "a shocking setback". The House defeated a series of attempts to modify the bill to attract moderate support by providing same-sex couples with an alternative to marriage. Bates' own amendment to delay the bill's effective date until March 31 so a non-binding referendum on the issue of same-sex marriage could be held in November failed on a vote of 188-162,^[60] with 96 of the chamber's 293 Republicans voting against the referendum.^[61] Opposing the referendum, Representative Shawn Jasper, House Deputy Majority Leader, said: "We are the most representative body in the country, if not the world. If we feel the need to go to our constituents and ask them a question, we are clearly in trouble."^[60] On March 21, 2012, the House defeated the bill on a vote of 211 to 116.^[62] By the spring of 2012, 1,900 same-sex couples had married in the state.^[60]

Democrat Maggie Hassan, a supporter of same-sex marriage, ran against the legislature's record and won election as governor in November 2012^[63] and Democrats took control of the House.^[64]

Later legislation

For several years following the legalization of same-sex marriage in New Hampshire, the state's Uniform Marriage Recognition Law invalidated any marriage contracted in New Hampshire by non-residents if their intended state of residence would not recognize the validity of the marriage if contracted within its own jurisdiction.^[65] On July 10, 2014, Governor Hassan signed legislation designed to clarify the status of same-sex marriages. It established that same-sex marriages from other jurisdictions are recognized by New Hampshire as valid from the date they were contracted, even if they pre-dated New Hampshire's recognition of same-sex marriage; that New Hampshire recognizes the same-sex marriages of non-residents whether or not their home jurisdiction recognizes the marriage; and allows those in civil unions in other jurisdictions to marry in New Hampshire without first dissolving their civil union.^[66][67][68]

Public opinion

Public opinion for same-sex marriage in New Hampshire

Poll source	Date(s) administered	Sample size	Margin of error	% support	% opposition	% no opinion
American Values Atlas/Public Religion Research Institute	April 29, 2015-January 7, 2016	189	-	73%	19%	8%
Bloomberg Politics/Saint Anselm New Hampshire Poll	May 2-May 6, 2015	952 likely voters	-	67%	24%	10%
American Values Atlas/Public Religion Research Institute	April 2, 2014-January 4, 2015	219	-	75%	19%	5%
New York Times/CBS News/YouGov	September 20-October 1, 2014	1260 likely voters	± 3%	63%	24%	13%
Public Policy Polling	January 9–12, 2014	1,354 voters	± 2.7%	60%	29%	11%
Public Policy Polling	September 13–16, 2013	1,038 voters	± 3%	55%	32%	13%
Nelson A. Rockefeller Center	April 22–25, 2013	433 registered voters	± 4.7%	55.4%	29.6%	-
Public Policy Polling	May 10–13, 2012	1,163 voters	± 2.9%	57%	35%	8%
Nelson A. Rockefeller Center	April 2–5, 2012	403 registered voters	± 4.9%	55.1%	30.9%	-
Public Policy Polling	June 30-July 5, 2011	622 voters	± 3.8%	51%	38%	11%
Nelson A. Rockefeller Center	April 11–14, 2011	426 registered voters	± 4.8%	41.5%	42.2%	-
Greenberg Quinlan Rosner Research	January 30-February 3, 2011	622 voters	± 3.9%	59%	34%	-
University of New Hampshire Survey Center/New Hampshire Freedom to Marry	April 13–22, 2009	491 voters	± ?%	55%	39%	-
University of New Hampshire Survey Center	February, 2004	-	-	55%	-	-
University of New Hampshire Survey Center	May 2003	-	-	54%	-	-

The University of New Hampshire Survey Center poll, conducted in February 2004, found that 64% of New Hampshire residents opposed federal constitutional amendment that would ban same-sex marriage.^[69]

According to a poll, conducted in February 2005 by Research 2000 for the Concord Monitor, 51% of likely voters in the state supported a federal constitutional amendment to ban same-sex marriage.^[69]

The University of New Hampshire Survey Center poll taken January 27 – February 6, 2011 found that 62% of New Hampshire residents opposed the new Republican-dominated legislature's efforts to repeal the 2009 law legalizing same-sex marriage, with only 29% in favor of repeal. In addition, 51% voiced strong opposition to repeal.^[70][71]

A poll conducted between January 30 and February 3, 2011 by Greenberg Quinlan Rosner Research showed that 63% of residents opposed the bill repealing same-sex marriage, while 29% supported it.^[72][73]

A July 2011 Public Policy Polling survey found that 80% of respondents supported legal recognition of same-sex couples, with 45% supporting same-sex marriage and 35% supporting civil unions, while only 19% thought that there should be no legal recognition and 1% were not sure.^[74]

According to the University of New Hampshire Survey Center poll, conducted between September 26 and October 2, 2011, 62% of the state residents were against repealing same-sex marriage, 27% were for.^[75][76]

A Voter/Consumer Research poll, conducted on December 11–15, 2011, found that 64% of New Hampshire voters opposed repealing same-sex marriage, 31% supported it.^[77]

The University of New Hampshire Survey Center poll, conducted between January 25 and February 2, 2012, found that 59% of New Hampshire voters were against repealing same-sex marriage, 32% were for.^[78]

A May 2012 Public Policy Polling survey found that 85% of respondents supported legal recognition of same-sex couples, with 54% supporting same-sex marriage and 31% supporting civil unions, while only 13% thought that there should be no legal recognition and 2% were not sure.^[79]

The University of New Hampshire Survey Center poll, conducted between August 1 and 12, 2012, found that 61% of New Hampshire voters were against repealing same-sex marriage, 28% were for.^[80]

Economic impact

A UCLA study from March 2009 estimates the impact of allowing same-sex couples to marry on New Hampshire’s state budget. The study concludes that allowing same-sex couples to marry, as opposed to the old civil union scheme, would result in a net gain of approximately $500,000 each year for the State.^[81] This net impact will be the result of savings in expenditures on state means-tested public benefits programs and an increase in meals and room tax revenues from increased wedding-related tourism.

See also

• LGBT rights in New Hampshire
• Gene Robinson

References

1. Russell, Jenna (November 24, 2005). "N.H. Panel Would Bar Gays from Marrying". Boston Globe. Retrieved August 13, 2013.
2. Wang, Beverly (May 9, 2005). "N.H. gay marriage commission faces obstacles to finish report". Bangor Daily News. Retrieved August 13, 2013.
3. Liebowitz, Sarah. (March 5, 2007) Gay unions could gain support Concord Monitor. Accessed April 11, 2007.
4. Wangsness, Lisa (April 20, 2007). "Civil unions advance in N.H.". Boston Globe. Retrieved August 13, 2013.
5. N.H. House approves civil union measure
6. New Hampshire House passes civil union bill
7. Moskowitz, Eric. (April 5, 2007) N.H. House passes civil unions Concord Monitor. Accessed April 11, 2007.
8. New Hampshire governor says he'll sign civil union bill
9. Belluck, Pam (April 27, 2007). "New Hampshire Senate Votes to Allow Same-Sex Civil Unions". New York Times. Retrieved July 14, 2014.
10. New Hampshire lawmakers approve gay civil unions
11. Wang, Beverley. (April 26, 2007) State Senate approves civil unions for same-sex couples Concord Monitor. Accessed April 26, 2007.
12. N.H. governor signs civil unions bill
13. New Hampshire law makes same-sex civil unions legal
14. Docket of HB437 New Hampshire General Court.
15. Fahey, Tom. (November 25, 2007) State House Dome: Date set for civil union licenses New Hampshire Union Leader. Accessed November 25, 2007.
16. AP. (November 25, 2007) Civil unions license available by Dec. 10 Concord Monitor. Accessed November 25, 2007.
17. Timmins, Annmarie. (January 1, 2008) Same-sex couples say 'I Do' just after midnight Concord Monitor. Accessed January 3, 2008.
18. (4 April 2007) House Bill: 437-FN-LOCAL New Hampshire General Court (State Legislature). Accessed 29 August 2007.
19. (December 31, 2007) Midnight Ceremonies Mark Civil Unions WMUR-TV. Accessed January 3, 2008.
20. HB 1415 Text New Hampshire General Court. Accessed January 3, 2008.
21. HB 1415 Legislative History New Hampshire General Court. Accessed February 14, 2008.
22. AP. (January 9, 2009) 600 civil unions in first year for N.H. Concord Monitor. Accessed January 11, 2009.
23. HB 73 Bill Status
24. HB 437-FN-L Text New Hampshire General Court. Accessed January 3, 2008.
25. (December 31, 2007) N.H. Civil Unions Have Protections, Pitfalls WMUR-TV. Accessed January 3, 2008.
26. AP. (January 2, 2008) Benefits and pitfalls for gay couples Concord Monitor. Accessed January 3, 2008.
27. AP. (January 2, 2008) N.H. same-sex unions: promise and reality Chicago Tribune. Accessed January 3, 2008.
28. 457:1 Marriages Prohibited; Men and 457:2 Marriages Prohibited; Women
29. HB436 Docket report
30. House Approves Same-Sex Marriage After Bill Initially Fails WMUR
31. Love, Norma (March 26, 2009). "New Hampshire Takes Step Closer to Approving Same-Sex Marriage". CNS News. Retrieved February 28, 2014.
32. Same-sex marriage wins by 7 votes
33. Goodnough, Abby (April 29, 2009). "New Hampshire Senate Passes Gay Marriage Bill". New York Times. Retrieved February 28, 2014.
34. Adams, Glenn (May 6, 2009). "Maine legalizes gay marriage; N.H. Legislature votes in favor". Seacoast Online. Retrieved February 28, 2014.
35. Love, Norma (March 26, 2009). "NH House approves gay marriage". Boston Globe. Retrieved February 28, 2014.
36. (May 10, 2009) Same-sex marriage bill in limbo Nashua Telegraph.
37. "HB 436-FN-LOCAL – Version Adopted by Both Bodies". Retrieved May 15, 2009.
38. Moskowitz, Eric (2009-05-15). "N.H. set to OK same-sex marriage". Boston.com. Retrieved January 11, 2016.
39. Governor Lynch Statement Regarding Same-Sex Marriage Legislation
40. New Hampshire Pact Near on Same-Sex Marriage
41. New Hampshire lawmakers reject gay-marriage bill
42. New Hampshire House balks on marriage equality bill, Bay Windows, Lisa Keen, May 20, 2009
43. Compromise reached on NH gay marriage bill, The Boston Globe, Associated Press, Holly Ramer, May 29, 2009
44. New Hampshire Approves Same-Sex Marriage
45. Governor Lynch Statement Regarding Same-Sex Marriage Legislation Signed Into Law Today
46. Manuse, Andrew J. (June 3, 2009). "New Hampshire legalizes gay marriage". Reuters. Retrieved July 17, 2013.
47. "New Hampshire Statutes Marriage Laws". American Marriage Ministries. Retrieved March 7, 2016.
48. How many same-sex marriages in the U.S.? At least 71,165, probably more
49. HOUSE BILL 73 AN ACT affirming religious freedom protections with regard to marriage and prohibiting the establishment of civil unions on or after January 1, 2010.
50. McCord, Michael (January 19, 2010). "Amendment bid aims to stop gay marriage in N.H.". Seacoast Online. Retrieved July 17, 2013.
51. CACR28
52. HB1590 - Bill Status
53. No Repeal to NH Gay Marriage Law, No to a Constitutional Amendment
54. NH House rejects 2 anti-gay marriage measures
55. New Hampshire House rejects bills aimed at repealing gay marriage
56. Love, Norma (October 25, 2011). "NH panel votes to recommend gay marriage repeal". Boston Globe. The Boston Globe.
57. HB437
58. Berger, Judson (January 14, 2012). "Same-Sex marriage faces test in New Hampshire as lawmakers consider repeal". Fox News. Retrieved August 13, 2013.
59. "Gay marriage repeal bill no sure bet". Concord Monitor. January 29, 2012.
60. Landrigan, Kevin (March 22, 2012). "House kills effort to repeal same-sex marriage, law to stay on the books". Nashua Telegraph. Retrieved August 15, 2013.
61. Love, Norma (March 22, 2012). "Gay marriage will be issue in NH's fall elections". Boston Globe. Retrieved August 13, 2013.
62. Geiger, Kim (March 21, 2012). "New Hampshire House rejects repeal of gay marriage law". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved August 13, 2013.
63. Schweitzer, Sarah (November 6, 2012). "Obama wins N.H.; Hassan elected governor". Boston Globe. Retrieved August 15, 2013.
64. Timmins, Annmarie (November 8, 2012). "Democrats take control of N.H. House and make big gains in the Senate". Concord Monitor. Retrieved January 11, 2016.
65. "New Hampshire Revised Statutes Online, Chapter 457 Marriages, Sections 457:43 and 457:44". Retrieved October 11, 2013.
66. "N.H. governor signs bill to update law on same-sex marriage recognition". LGBTQ Nation. Associated Press. July 11, 2014. Retrieved January 11, 2016.
67. "Governor Hassan's Statement on Signing SB 394". Governor of New Hampshire. July 10, 2014. Retrieved July 14, 2014.
68. "SB 394 – Version Adopted by Both Bodies". New Hampshire General Court. Retrieved July 14, 2014.
69. Recent State Polls on Same-Sex Marriage & Civil Unions
70. Social Issues in NH: Little Support for Repeal of Gay Marriage, Support for Parental Notification
71. Poll Shows Support For Same-Sex Marriage In NH
72. New Hampshire Voters Strongly Oppose Repealing Law that Allows Gay and Lesbian Couples to Marry
73. New Hampshire Freedom to Marry Frequency Questionnaire
74. A majority favor legal same-sex marriage in New Hampshire
75. NH Opposed to Repeal of Gay Marriage
76. Poll Shows Little Support For Repealing Same-Sex Marriage
77. Poll: 64% Oppose Repeal of Same Sex Marriage
78. NH Legislature Faces Tough Year, Difficult Issues
79. "Tight gubernatorial race in N.H." (PDF). Public Policy Polling. Retrieved May 16, 2012.
80. NH DIVIDED ON INCOME TAX AMENDMENT, CONTINUE TO OPPOSE REPEAL OF GAY MARRIAGE
81. The Impact on New Hampshire's Budget of Allowing Same-Sex Couples to Marry