What Ifs? of American History

First edition

What Ifs? of American History, subtitled Eminent Historians Imagine What Might Have Been, is a collection of seventeen essays dealing with counterfactual history regarding the United States. It was published by G.P. Putnam's Sons in 2003, ISBN 0-399-15091-9, and this book as well as its two predecessors, What If? and What If? 2, were edited by Robert Cowley.

Essays

• "Might the Mayflower Not Have Sailed?" by Theodore K. Rabb
  • What if the Mayflower had not set sail from England in 1620?
• "William Pitt the Elder and the Avoidance of the American Revolution" by Caleb Carr
  • What if Parliament had pursued a more conciliatory policy regarding the Thirteen Colonies' war debts?
• "What the Fog Wrought: The Revolution's Dunkirk, August 29, 1776" by David McCullough
  • What if George Washington's retreat after the Battle of Long Island had not succeeded? (This essay is a reprint from What If?)
• "'His Accidency' John Tyler" by Tom Wicker
  • What if the tenth President of the United States had not assumed the full power of the presidency after the death of his predecessor, William Henry Harrison?
• "Lew Wallace and the Ghosts of the Shunpike" by Victor Davis Hanson
  • What if General Wallace's reinforcement of General Grant at the Shiloh had been successful?
• "If the Lost Order Hadn't Been Lost: Robert E. Lee Humbles the Union, 1862" by James M. McPherson
  • What if Lee had succeeded in destroying the Army of the Potomac? (This essay is a reprint from What If?.)
• "The Northwest Conspiracy" by Thomas Fleming
  • What if the Copperheads in Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, and Ohio had succeeded in inciting protest against the Lincoln administration?
• "Beyond the Wildest Dreams of John Wilkes Booth" by Jay Winik
  • What if Booth's co-conspirators had succeeded in assassinating Johnson and Seward?
• "The Revolution of 1877" by Cecelia Holland
  • What if the Great Railroad Strike of 1877 had turned into a full-blown worker's uprising?
• "The Whale Against the Wolf: The Anglo-American War of 1896" by Andrew Roberts
  • What if the United Kingdom and the United States went to war over the border dispute between Venezuela and British Guiana?
• "No Pearl Harbor? FDR Delays the War" by John Lukacs
  • What if Japan had not attacked Pearl Harbor?
• "If Eisenhower Had Gone to Berlin" by Antony Beevor
  • What if the Allied armies had not stopped at the Elbe?
• "Joe McCarthy's Secret Life" by Ted Morgan
  • What if Senator McCarthy had done more damage than he did?
• "If the U-2 Hadn't Flown" by George Feifer
  • What if there had been no U-2 flight on May 1, 1960?
• "The Cuban Missile Crisis: Second Holocaust" by Robert L. O'Connell
  • What if the Crisis had spiraled into World War III?
• "JFK Lives" by Robert Dallek
  • What if President Kennedy had not been assassinated in 1963?
• "What if Watergate Were Still Just an Upscale Address?" by Lawrence Malkin and John F. Stacks
  • What if the Watergate break-in had not been discovered?

Reviews

• "Great for history buffs not quite ready for fiction, it is suitable for public libraries and general academic collections."—Library Journal^[1]
• "In this interesting book, the latest in a series using the same gimmick, experts speculate on how things might have worked out differently if some pivotal historical event had not happened." —New York Times^[2]

See also

• What If? (essays)
• What If? 2

References

1. Frederick J. Augustyn Jr., “Review of What Ifs? of American History: Eminent Historians Imagine What Might Have Been,” Library Journal 128.17 (10/15/2003): 83.
2. Genzlinger, Neil (September 7, 2003). "JERSEY; History Could Have Gone Something Like This . . .". New York Times. Retrieved 23 June 2012.