1957–58 Brentford F.C. season

Brentford

1957–58 season
Chairman	Frank Davis
Manager	Malky MacDonald
Stadium	Griffin Park
Third Division South	2nd
FA Cup	First round
Top goalscorer	League: Towers (29) All: Towers (29)
Highest home attendance	25,744
Lowest home attendance	9,130
Average home league attendance	13,084
← 1956–57 1958–59 →

During the 1957–58 English football season, Brentford competed in the Football League Third Division South. The Bees finished as runners-up to Brighton & Hove Albion and narrowly missed out on promotion to the Second Division.

Season summary

After the departure of Bill Dodgin Sr, Brentford recruited Kilmarnock manager Malky MacDonald for their vacant managerial position in May 1957.^[1] MacDonald was no stranger to Griffin Park, having spent just under three years as a player-coach with the Bees between 1946 and 1949.^[1] First on MacDonald's list of priorities was to ensure that Brentford finished in the top half of the Third Division South table, to avoid becoming founder members of the new Fourth Division in the following season.^[1] Ageing and injury-ravaged players Sid Tickridge, Wally Bragg and Frank Dudley were released, while Jeff Taylor, the club's second-leading scorer in each of the previous two seasons, elected to retire and pursue a career in opera.^[1] MacDonald brought in former Brentford player Fred Monk as trainer and made just one signing of note, full back Tom Wilson from Fulham, whom he named captain.^[1] Ken Horne, Ian Dargie and Johnny Rainford, three players who had seen their playing time reduced under previous manager Dodgin, would become regulars again under MacDonald during the season.^[2]

After a mixed start to the season, an unbeaten run of six wins in eight matches in October and November elevated Brentford to 2nd place on 23 November 1957.^[3] The run included a new club record of most consecutive clean sheets (9).^[4] Forwards Jim Towers and George Francis were again in prolific form, having scored 24 of the Bees' 37 league goals at that point of the season.^[2] Brentford failed to win another match in the league or FA Cup in 1957, but began 1958 strongly, beating Norwich City 7–1 at Griffin Park.^[3] For the remainder of the season, Brentford clawed their way back to the higher reaches of the Third Division South table, winning six matches in a row in March and early April to move up to 4th.^[3] A 1–0 defeat to Torquay United on 7 April put Brentford four points behind leaders Brighton & Hove Albion, with the Bees having played one game more.^[1] The damage of draws in the following two matches (versus Southampton and a showdown with Brighton & Hove Albion) was lessened by fellow challengers Plymouth Argyle, Swindon Town and Reading all dropping points.^[1]

The Bees, spurred on by six goals from Jim Towers, won their final three matches of the season versus Reading, Port Vale and leaders Brighton & Hove Albion.^[3] The victory over Brighton put Brentford top on 58 points, ahead of Plymouth Argyle and Brighton on goal average, but Brighton could still win the title by virtue of their game in hand, which would come versus Watford two days later, whom they had beaten 1–0 at Vicarage Road two days before their match at Griffin Park.^[5] Brighton emphatically beat Watford 6–0 in their final match to win promotion to the Second Division, but the manner of their victories over Watford raised concern and the referee of the first meeting between the sides wrote to the Football League outlining his suspicions.^[1] It wasn't until October 1960 that former Brighton & Hove Albion wing half Glen Wilson revealed to the Daily Mail that some of the Watford players had agreed to "lie down" in exchange for money.^[1]

League table

Pos	Team	Pld	Home					Away					F	A	GA	GD	Pts
			W	D	L	F	A	W	D	L	F	A
1	Brighton & Hove Albion	46	13	6	4	52	30	11	6	6	36	34	88	64	1.375	+24	60
2	Brentford	46	15	5	3	52	24	9	5	9	30	32	82	56	1.464	+26	58
3	Plymouth Argyle	46	17	4	2	43	17	8	4	11	24	31	67	48	1.396	+19	58
4	Swindon Town	46	14	7	2	47	16	7	8	8	32	34	79	50	1.580	+29	57
5	Reading	46	14	5	4	52	23	7	8	8	27	28	79	51	1.549	+28	55
6	Southampton	46	16	3	4	78	31	6	7	10	34	41	112	72	1.556	+40	54
7	Southend United	46	14	5	4	56	26	7	7	9	34	32	90	58	1.552	+32	54
8	Norwich City	46	11	9	3	41	28	8	6	9	34	42	75	70	1.071	+5	53
9	Bournemouth & Boscombe Athletic	46	16	5	2	54	24	5	4	14	27	50	81	74	1.095	+7	51
10	Queens Park Rangers	46	15	6	2	40	14	3	8	12	24	51	64	65	0.985	–1	50
11	Newport County	46	12	6	5	40	24	5	8	10	33	43	73	67	1.090	+4	48
12	Colchester United	46	13	5	5	45	27	4	8	11	32	52	77	79	0.975	–2	47
13	Northampton Town	46	13	1	9	60	33	6	5	12	27	46	87	79	1.101	+8	44
14	Crystal Palace	46	12	5	6	46	30	3	8	12	24	42	70	72	0.972	–2	43
15	Port Vale	46	12	6	5	49	24	4	4	15	18	34	67	58	1.155	+9	42
16	Watford	46	9	8	6	34	27	4	8	11	25	50	59	77	0.766	–28	42
17	Shrewsbury Town	46	10	6	7	29	25	5	4	14	20	46	49	71	0.690	–22	40
18	Aldershot	46	7	9	7	31	34	5	7	11	28	55	59	89	0.663	–30	40
19	Coventry City	46	10	9	4	41	24	3	4	16	20	57	61	81	0.753	–20	39
20	Walsall	46	10	7	6	37	24	4	2	17	24	51	61	75	0.813	–14	37
21	Torquay United	46	9	7	7	33	34	2	6	15	16	40	49	74	0.662	–25	35
22	Gillingham	46	12	5	6	33	24	1	4	18	19	57	52	81	0.642	–29	35
23	Millwall	46	6	6	11	37	36	5	3	15	26	55	63	91	0.692	–28	31
24	Exeter City	46	10	4	9	37	35	1	5	17	20	64	57	99	0.576	–42	31

P = Matches played; W = Matches won; D = Matches drawn; L = Matches lost; F = Goals for; A = Goals against; GA = Goal average; GD = Goal difference; Pts = Points

Key
	Division Champions, promoted
	New club in the league (none)
	Moved to 4th Division
	Re-elected, moved to 4th Division
	Failed re-election (none)

Results

Brentford's goal tally listed first.

Legend

Win

Draw

Loss

Football League Third Division South

No.	Date	Opponent	Venue	Result	Attendance	Scorer(s)
1	24 August 1957	Queens Park Rangers	A	0–1	15,734
2	27 August 1957	Exeter City	H	1–0	12,307	Simpson (og)
3	31 August 1957	Colchester United	H	3–3	12,732	Newcombe, Towers (2)
4	4 September 1957	Exeter City	A	5–3	8,498	Towers (2), Francis, Parsons (2)
5	7 September 1957	Norwich City	A	2–3	19,150	Francis (2)
6	10 September 1957	Northampton Town	H	7–1	10,697	Parsons, Rainford (2), Towers (2), Francis (2)
7	14 September 1957	Bournemouth & Boscombe Athletic	H	4–2	13,733	Francis (3), Newcombe
8	16 September 1957	Northampton Town	A	1–3	4,528	Francis
9	21 September 1957	Walsall	A	2–0	10,775	Towers (2)
10	24 September 1957	Watford	A	1–4	7,031	Towers
11	28 September 1957	Coventry City	H	1–3	12,094	Caven
12	1 October 1957	Watford	H	0–0	10,447
13	5 October 1957	Shrewsbury Town	A	2–0	7,057	Francis, Heath
14	12 October 1957	Gillingham	H	1–0	12,488	Towers
15	19 October 1957	Millwall	A	1–0	16,293	Rainford
16	26 October 1957	Swindon Town	H	0–0	13,676
17	2 November 1957	Aldershot	A	2–0	7,133	Francis (2)
18	9 November 1957	Plymouth Argyle	H	2–0	15,594	Newcombe, Francis
19	23 November 1957	Newport County	H	2–1	13,603	Rainford, Towers
20	30 November 1957	Southampton	A	2–4	13,690	Towers, Francis
21	14 December 1957	Southend United	A	0–0	7,952
22	21 December 1957	Queens Park Rangers	H	1–1	12,804	Rutter (og)
23	25 December 1957	Crystal Palace	H	0–3	12,394
24	26 December 1957	Crystal Palace	A	1–2	16,797	Coote
25	28 December 1957	Colchester United	A	1–1	9,548	Francis
26	11 January 1958	Norwich City	H	7–1	11,850	Francis (2), Rainford (2), Parsons, Coote, Newcombe
27	18 January 1958	Bournemouth & Boscombe Athletic	A	0–1	11,090
28	1 February 1958	Walsall	H	2–1	9,130	Rainford, Parsons (pen)
29	8 February 1958	Coventry City	A	0–0	9,391
30	15 February 1958	Shrewsbury Town	H	2–0	12,842	Francis, Parsons
31	22 February 1958	Gillingham	A	2–3	6,626	Parsons, Towers
32	1 March 1958	Millwall	H	4–1	12,919	Towers (3), Francis
33	8 March 1958	Swindon Town	A	1–4	12,755	Francis
34	11 March 1958	Reading	H	2–1	13,230	Towers (2)
35	15 March 1958	Aldershot	H	4–2	10,482	Heath (2), Towers (2)
36	22 March 1958	Newport County	A	2–1	5,621	Heath, Rainford
37	24 March 1958	Port Vale	A	1–0	5,149	Towers
38	29 March 1958	Southend United	H	4–2	12,890	Towers (2), Francis (2)
39	4 April 1958	Torquay United	A	1–0	8,216	Towers
40	5 April 1958	Plymouth Argyle	A	0–0	20,021
41	7 April 1958	Torquay United	H	0–1	15,680
42	12 April 1958	Southampton	H	0–0	11,663
43	19 April 1958	Brighton & Hove Albion	A	1–1	25,613	Heath
44	23 April 1958	Reading	A	2–1	12,852	Towers (2)
45	26 April 1958	Port Vale	H	4–1	11,923	Towers (3), Rainford
46	28 April 1958	Brighton & Hove Albion	H	1–0	25,744	Goundry

FA Cup

Round	Date	Opponent	Venue	Result	Attendance
1R	16 November 1957	Millwall	A	0–1	20,097

• Sources: 100 Years Of Brentford,^[2] Statto, 11v11

Playing squad

Players' ages are as of the opening day of the 1957–58 season.

Pos.	Name	Nat.	Date of birth (age)	Signed from	Signed in	Notes
Goalkeepers
GK	Gerry Cakebread		1 April 1936 (aged 21)	Youth	1954
GK	Sonny Feehan		17 September 1926 (aged 30)	Northampton Town	1954
Defenders
DF	Alan Bassham		3 October 1933 (aged 23)	Youth	1953
DF	Ken Horne		25 June 1926 (aged 31)	Blackpool	1950
DF	Sid Russell		4 October 1937 (aged 19)	Jolly X	1956
DF	Tom Wilson (c)		3 July 1930 (aged 27)	Fulham	1957
Midfielders
HB	George Bristow		25 June 1933 (aged 24)	Youth	1950
HB	Ken Coote		19 May 1928 (aged 29)	Wembley	1949
HB	Ian Dargie		3 October 1931 (aged 25)	Tonbridge	1952
HB	Ron Peplow		4 May 1935 (aged 22)	Southall	1955
Forwards
FW	Billy Bloomfield		25 August 1939 (aged 17)	Youth	1956
FW	John Caven		6 July 1934 (aged 23)	Kilmarnock	1957
FW	Christy Fletcher		14 June 1933 (aged 24)	Cheltenham Town	1957
FW	George Francis		4 February 1934 (aged 23)	Youth	1955
FW	Billy Goundry		28 March 1934 (aged 23)	Huddersfield Town	1955
FW	Dennis Heath		28 September 1934 (aged 22)	Youth	1954
FW	Len Newcombe		28 February 1931 (aged 26)	Fulham	1956
FW	Eric Parsons		9 November 1923 (aged 33)	Chelsea	1956
FW	Johnny Rainford		11 December 1930 (aged 26)	Cardiff City	1953
FW	Jim Towers		15 April 1933 (aged 24)	Youth	1954
Players who left the club mid-season
HB	Wendell Morgan		22 April 1935 (aged 22)	Cardiff City	1954	Transferred to Gillingham

• Sources: 100 Years Of Brentford,^[2] Timeless Bees,^[6] Barry Hugman's Footballers

Coaching staff

Name	Role
Malky MacDonald	Manager
Fred Monk	Trainer
Jack Holliday	Assistant Trainer

Statistics

Appearances and goals

Pos	Nat	Name	League		FA Cup		Total
			Apps	Goals	Apps	Goals	Apps	Goals
GK		Gerry Cakebread	45	0	1	0	46	0
GK		Sonny Feehan	1	0	0	0	1	0
DF		Alan Bassham	2	0	0	0	2	0
DF		Ken Horne	37	0	1	0	38	0
DF		Sid Russell	15	0	0	0	15	0
DF		Tom Wilson	27	0	0	0	27	0
HB		George Bristow	41	0	1	0	42	0
HB		Ken Coote	45	2	1	0	46	2
HB		Ian Dargie	46	0	1	0	47	0
HB		Wendell Morgan	5	0	—		5	0
HB		Ron Peplow	12	0	1	0	13	0
FW		Billy Bloomfield	1	0	0	0	1	0
FW		John Caven	6	1	0	0	6	1
FW		Christy Fletcher	3	0	0	0	3	0
FW		George Francis	45	22	1	0	46	22
FW		Billy Goundry	12	1	1	0	13	1
FW		Dennis Heath	15	5	0	0	15	5
FW		Len Newcombe	37	4	1	0	38	4
FW		Eric Parsons	30	7	1	0	31	7
FW		Johnny Rainford	45	9	1	0	46	9
FW		Jim Towers	36	29	0	0	36	29

• Players listed in italics left the club mid-season.
• Source: 100 Years Of Brentford^[2]

Goalscorers

Pos.	Nat	Player	FL3	FAC	Total
FW		Jim Towers	29	0	29
FW		George Francis	22	0	22
FW		Johnny Rainford	9	0	9
FW		Eric Parsons	7	0	7
FW		Dennis Heath	5	0	5
FW		Len Newcombe	4	0	4
HB		Ken Coote	2	0	2
FW		John Caven	1	0	1
FW		Billy Goundry	1	0	1
Opponents			2	0	2
Total			82	0	82

• Players listed in italics left the club mid-season.
• Source: 100 Years Of Brentford^[2]

Management

Name	Nat	From	To	Record All Comps					Record League
				P	W	D	L	W %	P	W	D	L	W %
Malky MacDonald		24 August 1957	28 April 1958	47	24	10	13	51.06	46	24	10	12	52.17

Summary

Games played	47 (46 Third Division South, 1 FA Cup)
Games won	24 (24 Third Division South, 0 FA Cup)
Games drawn	10 (10 Third Division South, 0 FA Cup)
Games lost	13 (12 Third Division South, 1 FA Cup)
Goals scored	82 (82 Third Division South, 0 FA Cup)
Goals conceded	57 (56 Third Division South, 1 FA Cup)
Clean sheets	18 (18 Third Division South, 0 FA Cup)
Biggest league win	7–1 on two occasions
Worst league defeat	3–0 versus Crystal Palace, 25 December 1957; 4–1 on two occasions
Most appearances	47, Ian Dargie (46 Third Division South, 1 FA Cup)
Top scorer (league)	29, Jim Towers
Top scorer (all competitions)	29, Jim Towers

Transfers & loans

Players transferred in
Date	Pos.	Name	Previous Club	Fee	Ref.
July 1957	GK	Reg Newton	Tunbridge Wells Rangers	n/a	[7]
July 1957	FB	Tom Wilson	Fulham	n/a	[8]
September 1957	FW	Terry Curran	Tottenham Hotspur	n/a	[9]
October 1957	FW	John Caven	Kilmarnock	n/a	[10]
December 1957	FW	Christy Fletcher	Cheltenham Town	n/a	[11]
1957	FW	Paddy Walsh	Hayes	Amateur	[12]
Players transferred out
Date	Pos.	Name	Subsequent club	Fee	Ref.
June 1957	HB	Terry Robinson	Northampton Town	Amateur	[13]
September 1957	HB	Wendell Morgan	Gillingham	n/a	[14]
Players released
Date	Pos.	Name	Subsequent club	Join date	Ref.
May 1958	FB	Alan Bassham	Folkestone Town	n/a	[15]
May 1958	GK	Reg Newton	Yiewsley	n/a	[7]
1958	FW	Paddy Walsh	Southall	1957	[12]

References

1. White 1989, p. 225-228.
2. White, Eric, ed. (1989). 100 Years Of Brentford. Brentford FC. p. 384. ISBN 0951526200.
3. Ltd, Statto Organisation. "Brentford results for the 1957-1958 season - Statto.com". Statto.com. Retrieved 2016-11-24.
4. Haynes, Graham (1998). A-Z Of Bees: Brentford Encyclopedia. Yore Publications. p. 30. ISBN 1 874427 57 7.
5. Ltd, Statto Organisation. "Brentford Table on Monday 28th April 1958 - Statto.com". Statto.com. Retrieved 2016-11-24.
6. Haynes, Graham; Coumbe, Frank (2006). Timeless Bees: Brentford F.C. Who's Who 1920-2006. Yore Publications. ISBN 978-0955294914.
7. Haynes & Coumbe 2006, p. 116.
8. "Barry Hugman's Footballers - Tommy Wilson". hugmansfootballers.com. Retrieved 2016-11-24.
9. Haynes & Coumbe 2006, p. 44.
10. "Barry Hugman's Footballers - John Caven". hugmansfootballers.com. Retrieved 2016-11-24.
11. "Barry Hugman's Footballers - Chris Fletcher". hugmansfootballers.com. Retrieved 2016-11-24.
12. "Hayes & Yeading United FC: The Official Website". www.hyufc.com. Retrieved 2016-11-23.
13. "Barry Hugman's Footballers - Terry Robinson". hugmansfootballers.com. Retrieved 2016-11-23.
14. "Barry Hugman's Footballers - Chris Fletcher". hugmansfootballers.com. Retrieved 2016-11-24.
15. Haynes & Coumbe 2006, p. 16.