Baseball Hall of Fame balloting, 2016

Ken Griffey Jr. (left) and Mike Piazza, the two inductees in 2016

Elections to the Baseball Hall of Fame for 2016 proceeded according to rules most recently amended in 2015. As in the past, the Baseball Writers' Association of America (BBWAA) voted by mail to select from a ballot of recently retired players, with results announced on January 6, 2016.

Ken Griffey Jr. and Mike Piazza were elected to the Hall of Fame. The Pre-Integration Committee, the last of three new voting committees established during an earlier rules change in 2010 to replace the more broadly defined Veterans Committee, convened in December 2015 to select from a ballot of players and non-playing personnel who made their greatest contributions to the sport prior to 1947 – called the "Pre-Integration Era" by the Hall of Fame – but failed to select any inductees.^[1][2]

The Hall of Fame induction ceremonies was held on July 24, 2016 at the Hall of Fame in Cooperstown, New York, with commissioner Rob Manfred presiding. On the day before the actual induction ceremony, the annual Hall of Fame Awards Presentation took place. At that event, two awards for media excellence were presented – the Hall's Ford C. Frick Award for broadcasters and the BBWAA's J. G. Taylor Spink Award for writers. The other major Hall of Fame award, the Buck O'Neil Lifetime Achievement Award, will not be presented again until at least 2017.^[3]

BBWAA election

On July 26, 2014, the Hall announced changes to the rules for election for recently retired players, reducing the number of years a player will be eligible to be on the ballot from fifteen years to ten. Two candidates presently on the BBWAA ballot (Lee Smith and Alan Trammell) in years 10-15 were grandfathered into this system and retained their previous 15 years of eligibility. In addition, BBWAA members who were otherwise eligible to cast ballots were required to complete a registration form and sign a code of conduct before receiving their ballots, and the Hall will make public the names of all members who cast ballots (but not their individual votes) when it announces the election results.^[4] The code of conduct specifically states that the ballot is non-transferable, a direct reaction to Dan Le Batard turning his 2014 Hall of Fame ballot over to the sports website Deadspin and allowing the site's readers to make his Hall votes (an act that drew him a lifetime ban from future Hall voting). Violation of the code of conduct will result in a lifetime ban from BBWAA voting.^[5]

The most recent rules change, announced on July 28, 2015, tightened the qualifications for the BBWAA electorate. Beginning with the 2016 election, eligible voters must not only have 10 years of continuous BBWAA membership, but also be currently active members, or have held active status within the 10 years prior to the election. A BBWAA member who has not been active for more than 10 years can regain voting status by covering MLB in the year preceding the election.^[6] As a result of the new rule, the vote total in 2016 decreased by 109 from the previous year, to 440.^[7]

The BBWAA ballot was announced on November 9, 2015; ballots were submitted by December 21, and results were announced on January 6, 2016. The ballot included two categories of players:

• Candidates from the 2015 ballot who received at least 5% of the vote but were not elected, as long as they first appeared on the BBWAA ballot no earlier than 2002.
• Selected individuals, chosen by a screening committee, whose last appearance was in 2010.

All BBWAA members with at least 10 years of continuous membership and active membership status at any time in the preceding 10 years were eligible to vote.

As in most recent elections, the controversy over use of performance-enhancing drugs (PEDs) is likely to dominate the election.^[8][9] ESPN.com columnist Jim Caple noted in the days before the announcement of the 2012 results that the PED issue and the BBWAA's limit of 10 votes per ballot was likely to result in a major backlog in upcoming elections:^[9]

Due to the steroid issue and a general lack of consensus, the following players will probably be on the ballot in three years: Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens, Pedro Martinez, Randy Johnson, Sammy Sosa, Jeff Bagwell, John Smoltz, Edgar Martinez, Mark McGwire, Mike Mussina, Jeff Kent, Larry Walker, Alan Trammell, Fred McGriff, Rafael Palmeiro, Lee Smith, Tim Raines, Gary Sheffield, Mike Piazza, Curt Schilling and, of course, Bernie [Williams]. That's 21 players who warrant serious consideration. And that's not counting Barry Larkin, who might be elected this year, and also assuming Greg Maddux, Tom Glavine, Craig Biggio and Frank Thomas make it their first years on the ballot. Finding room for Bonds, Clemens, Pedro, Johnson and others means I'll have to dump more good players from my ballot than the Marlins dumped after winning the 1997 World Series.

Caple's predictions about the players on the 2015 ballot, as well as the players he expected to be elected before then, mostly proved accurate. Larkin was indeed elected in 2012, and Maddux, Glavine and Thomas were elected on their first ballot appearance in 2014. The main exceptions were Palmeiro and Williams, who got less than 5% of the vote in prior elections and failed to stay on, and Biggio, who fell short of election in both of his first two years on the ballot, missing out in 2014 by two votes. Biggio was finally elected in 2015.

Another ESPN.com writer, Tim Kurkjian, noted that the 2013 ballot would include several new candidates who either tested positive or were strongly linked to PEDs:^[10]

The next Hall of Fame ballot will include Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens, Sammy Sosa, Mike Piazza, Craig Biggio and Curt Schilling. They all have Hall of Fame numbers, some stronger than others, but Bonds, Clemens, Sosa and Piazza certainly are not going to be elected on the first ballot — and in the case of Bonds, Clemens and Sosa, they might not make it to Cooperstown for many, many years to come.

In his first year on the ballot, Ken Griffey Jr. received 99.3% of the vote, a BBWAA election record. Mike Piazza finished second at 83.0% and was the only other player elected.^[7]

Alan Trammell and Mark McGwire were on the ballot for their final time. Neither were elected, meaning they will not be eligible for further consideration by the BBWAA. Under current Hall of Fame rules, they are now awaiting eligibility for consideration by the since-created Today's Game Committee. This body is authorized to consider all MLB figures whose greatest contributions occurred after 1987, with the restriction that the only players that can be considered are those whose BBWAA eligibility has been exhausted. Trammell and McGwire will thus be eligible for consideration when the Today's Game Committee first meets in late 2016 as part of the 2017 election process. Should they not be elected at that time, they will remain eligible at further meetings of that committee (occurring twice in a five-year cycle, as part of the following calendar year's election process).^[11]

Results

Player Votes Percent Change Year Griffey Jr., KenKen Griffey Jr. 437 99.3 – 1st Piazza, MikeMike Piazza 365 83.0 013.1% 4th Bagwell, JeffJeff Bagwell 315 71.6 015.9% 6th Raines, TimTim Raines 307 69.8 014.8% 9th Hoffman, TrevorTrevor Hoffman 296 67.3 – 1st Schilling, CurtCurt Schilling 230 52.3 013.1% 4th Clemens, RogerRoger Clemens 199 45.2 07.7% 4th Bonds, BarryBarry Bonds 195 44.3 07.5% 4th Martínez, EdgarEdgar Martínez 191 43.4 016.4% 7th Mussina, MikeMike Mussina 189 43.0 018.4% 3rd Trammell, AlanAlan Trammell 180 40.9 015.8% 15th Smith, LeeLee Smith 150 34.1 03.9% 14th McGriff, FredFred McGriff 92 20.9 08.0% 7th Kent, JeffJeff Kent 73 16.6 02.6% 3rd Walker, LarryLarry Walker 68 15.5 03.7% 6th McGwire, MarkMark McGwire 54 12.3 02.3% 10th Sheffield, GaryGary Sheffield 51 11.6 00.1% 2nd Wagner, BillyBilly Wagner 46 10.5 – 1st Sosa, SammySammy Sosa 31 7.0 00.4% 4th Edmonds, JimJim Edmonds* 11 2.5 – 1st Garciaparra, NomarNomar Garciaparra* 8 1.8 03.7% 2nd Sweeney, MikeMike Sweeney* 3 0.7 – 1st Eckstein, DavidDavid Eckstein* 2 0.5 – 1st Kendall, JasonJason Kendall* 2 0.5 – 1st Anderson, GarretGarret Anderson* 1 0.2 – 1st Ausmus, BradBrad Ausmus* 0 0 – 1st Castillo, LuisLuis Castillo* 0 0 – 1st Glaus, TroyTroy Glaus* 0 0 – 1st Grudzielanek, MarkMark Grudzielanek* 0 0 – 1st Hampton, MikeMike Hampton* 0 0 – 1st Lowell, MikeMike Lowell* 0 0 – 1st Winn, RandyRandy Winn* 0 0 – 1st

Key      Elected to the Hall of Fame on this ballot (named in bold italics).      Elected subsequently, as of 2016 (named in plain italics).      Renominated for the 2017 BBWAA election by adequate performance on this ballot.      Eliminated from annual BBWAA consideration by poor performance or expiration on subsequent ballots.      Eliminated from annual BBWAA consideration by poor performance or expiration on this ballot. † First time on the BBWAA ballot. * Eliminated from annual BBWAA consideration by poor performance on this ballot (not expiration).

Players who were eligible for the first time who were not included on the ballot were: Ronnie Belliard, Eric Byrnes, Frank Catalanotto, Jesús Colomé, Elmer Dessens, Pedro Feliz, José Guillén, Cristian Guzmán, Bob Howry, Gabe Kapler, Mike Lamb, Jason LaRue, Ron Mahay, Dámaso Marte, Gary Matthews Jr., Gil Meche, Brian Moehler, Chad Moeller, Bengie Molina, Russ Ortiz, Chan Ho Park, Jay Payton, Mike Redmond, Juan Rincón, David Riske, Scott Schoeneweis, Scot Shields, Russ Springer, Fernando Tatís, Jeff Weaver and Gregg Zaun.

Pre-Integration Era Committee

In keeping with the voting procedure by eras, the BBWAA-appointed Historical Overview Committee, made up of 11 BBWAA members, identified ten Pre-Integration candidates who were judged to have made their greatest contributions from the origins of the sport to the end of baseball's color line in 1947. This era was previously under consideration in the 2013 election, when three candidates were elected; Bill Dahlen was the only other candidate to receive more than three votes. Along with the era, these rules defined the consideration set:^[2]

• Players who played in at least 10 major league seasons, who are not on Major League Baseball's ineligible list (e.g., Shoeless Joe Jackson), and have been retired for 21 or more seasons.
• Managers and umpires with 10 or more years in baseball and retired for at least five years. Candidates who are 65 years or older are eligible six months after their retirement.
• Executives retired for at least five years. Active executives 65 years or older are eligible for consideration.

However, due to the passage of time, the only listed criteria that materially restricted the field from which the candidates were selected were years of service and presence on baseball's ineligible list.

The eleven BBWAA-appointed Historical Overview Committee members were Dave Van Dyck (Chicago Tribune); Bob Elliott (Toronto Sun); Jim Henneman (formerly Baltimore Sun); Steve Hirdt (Elias Sports Bureau); Rick Hummel (St. Louis Post-Dispatch); Bill Madden (formerly New York Daily News); Jack O'Connell (BBWAA secretary/treasurer); Jim Reeves (formerly Fort Worth Star-Telegram); Tracy Ringolsby (MLB.com); Glenn Schwarz (formerly San Francisco Chronicle); and Mark Whicker (Los Angeles News Group). All except Henneman and Reeves were members of the committee that selected the 2013 candidates.

The Pre-Integration ballot for election was released on October 5, 2015; final voting was conducted by the Pre-Integration Committee, a 16-member body which met at baseball's winter meetings in Nashville on December 6, with 75% (12 of 16 votes) required for election; results were announced the following morning. The committee's members, appointed by the Hall of Fame's board of directors, were announced later in fall 2015 and included members of the Hall, baseball executives, members of the media and historians:

• Hall of Famers: Bert Blyleven, Bobby Cox, Pat Gillick and Phil Niekro
• Executives: Chuck Armstrong, Bill DeWitt, Gary Hughes and Tal Smith
• Media/Historians: Steve Hirdt, Peter Morris, Jack O'Connell, Claire Smith, Tim Sullivan, T.R. Sullivan, Gary Thorne and Tim Wendel

Blyleven, Gillick, Niekro, DeWitt, Hughes, Hirdt, Morris, Smith and T.R. Sullivan previously served on the committee which selected the 2013 inductees. For the second consecutive year, none of the candidates received enough votes for election; it marked the third consecutive year – and the fifth time in seven years – in which no former players were chosen by the Hall's special committees.^[12] Speaking on MLB Network's Hot Stove immediately after it broadcast the announcement, Major League Baseball's official historian John Thorn expressed surprise and disappointment at the results, noting that he had felt there were three particularly strong candidates (prior to the announcement, he had commented favorably on the candidacies of Doc Adams and Harry Stovey); he speculated that the number of good candidates may have deadlocked the voting once again, and suggested that the Hall may need to amend the voting process in the future.

At the time of the election, figures from this era were scheduled to be considered prior to the 2019 inductions. However, in July 2016, the Hall announced changes to its era-based committee system, replacing the three then-current committees with four new voting bodies. The Pre-Integration Era body was replaced by the newly created Early Baseball committee. The new committee will consider figures whose greatest contributions occurred before 1950 (a slightly broader time frame from its predecessor), but will not hold its first meeting until 2020 as part of the 2021 election process. Most significantly, this committee will meet only once a decade, specifically in years ending in 0.^[11]

The candidates for election were:

Candidate	Category	Votes	Percent
Adams, DocDoc Adams	Pioneer	10	62.5%
Dahlen, BillBill Dahlen	Player	8	50%
Stovey, HarryHarry Stovey	Player	8	50%
Breadon, SamSam Breadon	Executive	< 4	< 25%
Ferrell, WesWes Ferrell	Player	< 4	< 25%
Herrmann, AugustAugust Herrmann	Executive	< 4	< 25%
Marion, MartyMarty Marion	Player	< 4	< 25%
McCormick, FrankFrank McCormick	Player	< 4	< 25%
von der Ahe, ChrisChris von der Ahe	Executive	< 4	< 25%
Walters, BuckyBucky Walters	Player	< 4	< 25%

Breadon, Dahlen, Ferrell, Marion and Walters were previously candidates on the 2013 ballot.

J. G. Taylor Spink Award

The J. G. Taylor Spink Award has been presented by the BBWAA at the annual summer induction ceremonies since 1962.^[13] Through 2010, it was awarded during the main induction ceremony, but is now given the previous day at the Hall of Fame Awards Presentation. It recognizes a sportswriter "for meritorious contributions to baseball writing".^[14] The recipients are not members of the Hall of Fame but are featured in a permanent exhibit at the National Baseball Museum.

On December 8, 2015, Boston Globe columnist Dan Shaughnessy received 185 out of 417 of the votes cast, making him the 2016 recipient of the J. G. Taylor Spink Award.

Ford C. Frick Award

The Ford C. Frick Award, honoring excellence in baseball broadcasting, has been presented at the induction ceremonies since 1978.^[15] Through 2010, it had been presented at the main induction ceremony, but is now awarded at the Awards Presentation. Recipients are not members of the Hall of Fame but are permanently recognized in an exhibit at the museum. To be eligible, an active or retired broadcaster must have a minimum of 10 years of continuous major league broadcast service with a ball club, a network, or a combination of the two. The honor is based on four criteria: longevity; continuity with a club; honors, including national assignments such as the World Series and All-Star Games; and popularity with fans.

This was the third and final Frick Award selection under a process similar to that instituted for Veterans Committee balloting in 2010. Under this process, candidates were considered every third year, based on the era in which they made their most significant contributions:^[16]

• "Broadcasting Dawn Era" — 1920s to early 1950s, including the early radio broadcasters. Individuals from this era were considered for the 2016 award.
• "High Tide Era" — Mid-1980s to present, including the rise of regional cable networks. Individuals from this era were last considered for the 2014 award.
• "Living Room Era" — Mid-1950s to early 1980s, including the rise of television. Individuals from this era were last considered for the 2015 award.

As part of the rules changes announced in July 2016, the Hall also announced changes to the Frick Award selection process, effective with the 2017 award. While the process will continue to involve three annually rotating voting bodies, the groups of candidates to be considered by each committee have changed. The newly established committees will rotate in the following order: "Current Major League Markets" (team-specific broadcasters), "National Voices" (national broadcasters), and "Broadcasting Beginnings" (early broadcasters). In addition, the number of finalists will be reduced from 10 to 8, and the three ballot slots that had been filled by fan voting on the Hall's Facebook page will now be chosen by a committee of baseball historians.^[11]

Ten finalists from the "Broadcasting Dawn Era" were announced on October 6, 2015.^[17][18] In accord with the current guidelines, seven were chosen by a Hall of Fame research committee, while the other three were selected (for the final time) from a list of candidates by fan voting at the Hall's Facebook page from September 14 to October 2.^[19]

• Jack Graney
• Harry Heilmann
• Al Helfer
• France Laux
• Tom Manning
• Graham McNamee
• Rosey Rowswell
• Hal Totten
• Ty Tyson
• Bert Wilson

All of the candidates were deceased,^[18] with the most recently living among them being Laux, who died in November 1978. Heilmann is a Hall of Fame member as a player.^[18]

On December 9, McNamee was announced as the recipient. The Hall's official announcement called him "quite possibly the first celebrity sportscaster... renowned as the most recognized personality during radio’s formative years." He began his broadcasting career in 1923 with WEAF (now known as WNBC) in New York City, and called 12 World Series, countless other baseball games, and 10 other sports until his death in 1942.^[20]

Notes and references

1. "Hall of Fame Board of Directors Restructures Procedures for Consideration of Managers, Umpires, Executives and Long-Retired Players" (Press release). National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum. July 26, 2010. Archived from the original on 14 December 2010. Retrieved January 15, 2011.
2. "Rules for Election for Managers, Umpires, Executives and Players for Pre-Integration Era Candidates to the National Baseball Hall of Fame". National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum. Archived from the original on November 25, 2011. Retrieved January 10, 2012.
3. "Awards: Buck O'Neil". National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum. Archived from the original on January 11, 2014. Retrieved January 11, 2014.
4. "Hall of Fame Announces Changes to Voting Process for Recently Retired Players, Effective Immediately" (Press release). National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum. July 26, 2014. Retrieved July 30, 2014.
5. Bloom, Barry M. (July 26, 2014). "Hall reduces eligibility from 15 years to 10". MLB.com. Retrieved July 30, 2014.
6. "Hall of Fame Announces Change to BBWAA Voting Electorate" (Press release). National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum. July 28, 2015. Retrieved July 28, 2015.
7. "Ken Griffey Jr. (99 percent of vote), Mike Piazza head to Cooperstown". espn.go.com. January 6, 2016. Retrieved January 6, 2016.
8. Caple, Jim (December 22, 2010). "The Hall of Fame ballot runneth over". Page 2. ESPN.com. Retrieved January 15, 2011.
9. Caple, Jim (January 4, 2013). "Too many good Hall candidates for limit". Page 2. ESPN.com. Retrieved January 9, 2013.
10. Kurkjian, Tim (January 9, 2013). "Whopper of a list of names await in 2014". ESPN.com. Retrieved January 10, 2013.
11. "Hall of Fame Makes Series of Announcements" (Press release). National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum. July 23, 2016. Retrieved August 14, 2016.
12. Bloom, Barry M. (December 7, 2015). "Pre-Integration vote yields no Hall inductees". MLB.com. Retrieved December 7, 2015.
13. "J.G. Taylor Spink Award". baseball-almanac.com. Retrieved July 20, 2010.
14. "Awards: J. G. Taylor Spink". National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum. Retrieved January 11, 2014.
15. "Ford Frick Award". baseball-almanac.com. Retrieved 2010-07-20.
16. "Baseball Hall of Fame Restructures Frick Award Selection Process" (Press release). National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum. September 4, 2013. Retrieved October 20, 2013.
17. "Graney, McNamee voted by fans to Hall ballot for Frick Award". USA Today. Associated Press. October 6, 2015. Retrieved December 2, 2015.
18. "2016 Ford C. Frick Award Ballot" (Press release). National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum. October 6, 2015. Retrieved December 2, 2015.
19. "More Than 20 Broadcasters From the 'Broadcasting Dawn Era' Eligible for 2016 Frick Award" (Press release). National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum. September 14, 2015. Retrieved December 2, 2015.
20. "2016 Ford C. Frick Award Winner Graham McNamee" (Press release). National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum. December 9, 2015. Retrieved December 11, 2015.

External links

• National Baseball Hall of Fame Official Website
• BBWAA Rules for Election to the Hall of Fame