Broad gauge

Broad gauge railways use a track gauge (distance between the rails) greater than the standard gauge of 1,435 mm (4 ft 8 ¹⁄₂ in).

History

Great Western Railway broad-gauge steam locomotives awaiting scrapping in 1892 after the conversion of the tracks to standard gauge.

In Britain the Great Western Railway, designed by Isambard Kingdom Brunel, pioneered broad gauge in 1838 with a gauge of 7 ft ¹⁄₄ in (2,140 mm), and retained this gauge until 1892. Some harbours also used railways of this gauge for construction and maintenance. These included Portland Harbour and Holyhead Breakwater, which used a locomotive for working sidings. As it was not connected to the national network, this broad-gauge operation continued until the locomotive wore out in 1913.^[1] The gauge initially proposed by Brunel was 7 ft (2,134 mm) exactly but this was soon increased by ¹⁄₄ in (6 mm) to accommodate clearance problems identified during early testing.

It became apparent that standardization on a single gauge throughout a rail transport system was advantageous. Rolling stock did not need to match the gauge exactly; a difference of a few millimetres could be coped with, so that interoperability on systems with gauges only slightly different was possible. The value of interoperability was initially not obvious to the industry. The standardization movement was gradual; over time the value of a proprietary gauge diminished, being replaced by the idea of charging money for equipment used on other railway lines.

While the parliament of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland was initially prepared to authorise lines built to the broad gauge of 7 ft ¹⁄₄ in (2,140 mm), it was eventually rejected by the Gauge Commission in favour of all railways in the British Isles being built to standard gauge of 1,435 mm (4 ft 8 ¹⁄₂ in), this being the gauge with the greatest mileage. Ireland, using the same criteria, was allocated a different standard gauge, the Irish gauge, of 5 ft 3 in (1,600 mm) which is also used in the Australian states of South Australia and Victoria. Broad-gauge lines in Britain were gradually converted to dual gauge or standard gauge from 1864, and finally the last of Brunel's broad gauge was converted over a single weekend in 1892.

Irish broad gauge tracks

Many countries have broad-gauge railways. Ireland (see History of rail transport in Ireland) and some states in Australia (see History of rail transport in Australia) and Brazil have a gauge of 5 ft 3 in (1,600 mm), but Luas, the Dublin light rail system, is built to standard gauge. Russia and the other former Soviet Republics use a 1,520 mm (4 ft 11 ²⁷⁄₃₂ in) (originally 5 ft (1,524 mm)) gauge while Finland continues to use the 5 ft (1,524 mm) gauge inherited from Imperial Russia (the two standards are close enough to allow full interoperability between Finland and Russia).

In 1839 the Netherlands started its railway system with two broad-gauge railways. The chosen gauge of 1,945 mm (6 ft 4 ⁹⁄₁₆ in) was applied between 1839 and 1866 by the Hollandsche IJzeren Spoorweg-Maatschappij (HSM) for its Amsterdam-The Hague-Rotterdam line and between 1842 and 1855, firstly by the Dutch state, but soon by the Nederlandsche Rhijnspoorweg-Maatschappij, for its Amsterdam-Utrecht-Arnhem line. But the neighbouring countries Prussia and Belgium already used standard gauge, so the two companies had to regauge their first lines. In 1855, NRS regauged its line and shortly afterwards connected to the Prussian railways. The HSM followed in 1866. There are replicas of one broad-gauge 2-2-2 locomotive (De Arend) and three carriages in the Dutch Railway Museum in Utrecht. These replicas were built for the 100th anniversary of the Dutch Railways in 1938–39.

Portugal and the Spanish Renfe system use a gauge of 1,668 mm (5 ft 5 ²¹⁄₃₂ in) called Ancho Ibérico in Spanish or Bitola Ibérica in Portuguese (see Iberian gauge & Rail gauge); there are plans to convert to standard gauge.^[2][3] In India, Pakistan and Bangladesh, a gauge of 5 ft 6 in (1,676 mm) is widespread. This is also used by the Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) system of the San Francisco Bay Area.

In Toronto, Canada the gauge for TTC subways and streetcars was chosen in 1861, years after the establishment of standard gauge in Britain, but well before standard gauge in the US and Canada. Toronto uses a unique gauge of 4 ft 10⅞ in. (1.495 mm), an "overgauge" originally stated to "allow horse-drawn wagons to use the rails", but with the practical effect of precluding the use of standard-gauge equipment in the street. In 1861, the province was supplying subsidies only to broad "provincial gauge" railways.

The use of a non-standard gauge precludes interoperability of rolling stock on railway networks. On the GWR the 7 ft ¹⁄₄ in (2,140 mm) gauge was supposed to allow high speed, but the company had difficulty with locomotive design in the early years, losing much of the advantage, and rapid advances in permanent way and suspension technology allowed standard-gauge speeds to approach broad-gauge speeds within a decade or two. On the 5 ft 3 in (1,600 mm) and 5 ft 6 in (1,676 mm) gauges, the extra width allowed bigger inside cylinders and greater power, a problem solvable by using outside cylinders and higher steam pressure on standard gauge. In the event, the most powerful engines on standard gauge in North America and Scandinavia far exceeded the power of any broad-gauge locomotive.

Broad gauges

South Asia

Broad gauge at Chennai, India

The British Raj in India adopted 5 ft 6 in (1,676 mm) gauge, although some standard-gauge railways were built in the initial period. The standard-gauge railways were soon converted to broad gauge. Attempts to economise on the cost of construction led to the adoption of 1,000 mm (3 ft 3 ³⁄₈ in) gauge and then 2 ft 6 in (762 mm) and 2 ft (610 mm) narrow gauges for many secondary and feeder lines, particularly in mountainous terrain. Broad gauge remained the most prevalent gauge spanning the Indian Subcontinent, from Iran into Pakistan to Burma and Kashmir to Sri Lanka. After independence, the Indian Railways adopted 5 ft 6 in (1,676 mm) as the standard Indian gauge, and began Project Unigauge to convert metre-gauge and narrow-gauge lines to this gauge.

Some of the newer specialized rail projects in India, such as the Konkan Railway and the Delhi Metro, also use Indian gauge. The project manager of Delhi Metro initially requested standard gauge for the Metro, but due to Indian Railways having complete control over all railways built in India, the lines were initially built using Indian gauge. As Delhi Metro trains do not use Indian Railways infrastructure, and the widespread manufacturing of standard-gauge trains around the world enabling lower cost, standard gauge is used in the new lines on Delhi Metro, including the Airport Express Line, which uses rolling stock imported from Europe. The new Bangalore Metro is on a standard gauge along with the newly constructed corridors of Mumbai Metro and Chennai Metro, and other metros being planned or under construction (Kochi (Cochin) metro and Hyderabad Metro systems) as of 2011 are also planned to be built to standard-gauge specifications.

Canada

The first railway in British North America, the Champlain and St. Lawrence Railroad, was built in 1835-36 to 5 ft 6 in (1,676 mm) gauge, setting the standard for Britain's colonies for several decades. Today, this is commonly known as Indian gauge, but in 1851 the 5 ft 6 in (1,676 mm) broad gauge was officially adopted as the standard gauge for the Province of Canada, becoming known as the Provincial gauge, and government subsidies were unavailable for railways that chose other gauges. This caused problems in interchanging freight cars with northern United States railroads, most of which were built to standard gauge or a gauge similar to it. In the 1870s, mainly between 1872 and 1874, Canadian broad-gauge lines were changed to standard gauge to facilitate interchange and the exchange of rolling stock with American railroads. Today, all Canadian freight railways are standard-gauge.

The Toronto Transit Commission operates the Toronto streetcar system and three of the Toronto subway lines on its own unique gauge of 4 ft 10 ⁷⁄₈ in (1,495 mm).

Finland

In Finland the gauge is 1,524 mm (5 ft). When the Finnish rail network was founded in 1862, Finland was the Grand Duchy of Finland, a region of Imperial Russia. The first border crossing railway to Russia was opened in 1870, and to Sweden not until 1919. This is why railways were built to the broad Russian track gauge of 1,524 mm (5 ft). In Russia, this gauge was re-standardized to 1,520 mm (4 ft 11 ²⁷⁄₃₂ in) during the 1960s. Finland retained the original gauge with no re-standardization.

Iberian gauge

As finally established, the Iberian gauge of 1,668 mm (5 ft 5 ²¹⁄₃₂ in) is a compromise between the similar, but slightly different, gauges first adopted as respective national standards in Spain and Portugal in the mid-19th century. The main railway networks of Spain were initially constructed to a 1,672 mm (5 ft 5 ¹³⁄₁₆ in) gauge of six Castilian feet. Those of Portugal were initially built in standard gauge, but by 1864 were all converted to a 1,664 mm (5 ft 5 ¹⁄₂ in) gauge of five Portuguese feet – close enough to allow interoperability in practice.^[4] The new high-speed network in Spain and Portugal uses standard gauge. The dual-gauge high-speed train RENFE Class 130 can change gauge at low speed without stopping.

Irish gauge

As part of the railway gauge standardisation considered by the United Kingdom Parliamentary Gauge Commission, Ireland was allocated its own gauge, Irish gauge. Ireland then had three gauges, and the new standard would be a fourth.

The Irish gauge of 1,600 mm (5 ft 3 in) is used in Ireland and parts of Australia and Brazil. A problem with the Irish Gauge in Australia is that it is only 170 mm (6.5 in) wider than the standard gauge used in other parts of Australia, principally New South Wales. Therefore, it is not considered advisable to use a third rail to allow dual-gauge operation on mainline sections of track, because of the danger of material lodging between the two rails.^[5] There has been argument for well over a century about the practicability of third rail operation, and numerous devices have been promoted to overcome the problem, especially at turnouts, including "Brennan Switch".^[6]

5 ft and 1520 mm (Russian gauge)

This gauge was first used in the United Kingdom and the United States before it became the standard gauge for most railways in the former Soviet Union.

Russian gauge or CIS gauge 1,520 mm (4 ft 11 ²⁷⁄₃₂ in) is the second most widely used gauge in the world, and spans the whole of the former Soviet Union/CIS bloc including the Baltic states and Mongolia. Finland uses 1,524 mm (5 ft). The difference is clearly lower than the tolerance margin, so through running is feasible. Care must be taken when servicing international trains because the wear profile of the wheels differs from that of trains that run on domestic tracks only.

United States

Originally, various gauges were used in the United States and Canada. Some railways, primarily in the northeast, used standard gauge; others used gauges ranging from 4 ft 10 in (1,473 mm) to 6 ft (1,829 mm). Problems began as soon as lines began to meet and, in much of the Northeastern United States, standard gauge was adopted. Most southern states used 5 ft (1,524 mm) gauge. Following the American Civil War, trade between the South and North grew, and the break of gauge became a major economic nuisance. Competitive pressures had forced all the Canadian railways to convert to standard gauge by 1880, and Illinois Central converted its south line to New Orleans to standard gauge in 1881, putting pressure on the southern railways.

In the early days of rail transport in the US, railroads tended to be built out from coastal cities into the hinterland, and systems did not initially connect. Each builder was free to choose its own gauge, although the availability of British-built locomotives encouraged some railroads to be built to standard gauge. As a general rule, southern railroads were built to one or another broad gauge, mostly 5 ft (1,524 mm), while northern railroads that were not standard gauge tended to be narrow gauge. Most of the original track in Ohio was built in 4 ft 10 in (1,473 mm) , and special "compromise cars" were able to run on both this track and standard gauge track.^[7] When American railroads' track extended to the point that they began to interconnect, it became clear that a single nationwide gauge was desirable.

Six-foot gauge railroads (6 ft [1,829 mm]) had developed a large regional following in New York State in the first part of the 19th century, due to the influence of the New York and Erie, one of the early pioneering railroads in America, chartered in 1832, with its first section opening in 1841. The builders and promoters decided that a six-foot track gauge would be needed for locomotives to be larger and more powerful than were in general use at the time, for pulling very large trains. Also the six-foot gauge provided greater stability, and the New York and Erie would operate passenger cars up to 11 feet (3.4 m) wide. Building westward from the Hudson River, it eventually reached Lake Erie, establishing a mainline longer than 400 miles (640 km) providing a shortcut to the American Midwest region from the New York City vicinity, and helping spawn a regional network of six-foot gauge railroads almost exclusively within New York State.

Many early New York railways were Erie railroad-built branch lines, while others were independent railroads that wanted to partner and interchange with the Erie. These included the Walkill Valley, the Albany and Susquehanna (later part of the Delaware and Hudson); the Elmira, Jefferson & Canandaigua (later the Northern Central, becoming part of the Pennsylvania Railroad); the Delaware, Lackawanna and Western mainline (which also had a significant amount of trackage in Pennsylvania); predecessor lines of the New York and Oswego Midland (later the New York, Ontario, and Western); and the Canandaigua and Niagara Falls (later becoming part of the New York Central railroad's Peanut Route along the shoreline of Lake Ontario). However by the late 1870s, the trend was inevitable, and conversion to standard gauge began, some lines first becoming "dual gauged" with the addition of a third running rail. Between 1876 and 1880, most of the remaining six-foot gauge trackage was converted.^[8]

In 1886, the southern railroads agreed to coordinate changing gauge on all their tracks. After considerable debate and planning, most of the southern rail network was converted from 5 ft (1,524 mm) gauge to 4 ft 9 in (1,448 mm) gauge, nearly the standard of the Pennsylvania Railroad, over two days beginning on 31 May 1886. Over a period of 36 hours, tens of thousands of workers pulled the spikes from the west rail of all the broad gauge lines in the South, moved them 3 in (76 mm) east and spiked them back in place. The new gauge was close enough that standard-gauge equipment could run on it without difficulty. By June 1886, all major railroads in North America were using approximately the same gauge. The final conversion to true standard gauge took place gradually as track was maintained.^[9]

Some North American streetcar lines intentionally varied from standard gauge. This may have been to make the streetcar companies less tempting targets for takeovers by the steam railroads (or competing streetcar companies), which would be unable to run their trains over the streetcar tracks.^[10]

Contemporary non-standard broad gauges

A surviving non-standard broad gauge in use is the Pennsylvania trolley gauge of 5 ft 2 ¹⁄₂ in (1,588 mm),^[11] still used on the streetcars in New Orleans, and the Pittsburgh Light Rail system. This gauge was also used for the now defunct Pittsburgh Railways, West Penn Railways, and streetcars in Cincinnati. Similar 5 ft 2 ¹⁄₄ in (1,581 mm) gauge is used in Philadelphia on the SEPTA routes, 15, 101 and 102, the Subway–Surface Trolleys and the SEPTA Market-Frankford.

The Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) system in the San Francisco Bay Area was opened in 1972 with 5 ft 6 in (1,676 mm) gauge (otherwise called Indian gauge), and thus requires all related equipment to be custom built. The system trackage has been extended multiple times since then, and new railcars have been ordered with this non-standard gauge.

Broader gauges

Broad gauge track for CSIRO Australia Telescope in Narrabri

Dockside crane on wide gauge tracks at the former South Boston Naval Annex's Dry Dock Number 3

Some applications require broader gauges, including:

• Large telescopes and telescope arrays.
• Rocket launchers—The European Space Agency, Russian Federal Space Agency, NASA and SpaceX use double-track railroad to move rockets and supporting equipment at launch sites.^[12] (with exceptions such as the US Apollo program and Space Shuttles, which used caterpillar tracks on a river stone roadbed because other solutions could not support the loads required).
• Dockside cranes for unloading cargo from ships and for constructing ships.
  • The Kockums Crane, now in Ulsan, South Korea, has 175 m (574.1 ft) gauge.
• Funiculars

These applications might use double track of the country's usual gauge to provide the necessary stability and axle load. These applications may also use much heavier than normal rails, the heaviest rails for trains being about 70 kg/m (141 lb/yd).

Vehicles on these gauges generally operate at very low speeds.

Cultural references

A P. G. Wodehouse character, Roderick Spode, suggests widening the rails of the entire British railway network so sheep may stand sideways on trains.^[13]

See also

• Breitspurbahn
• Ramsey Car Transfer Apparatus

References

1. Connection
2. Verkehrsrundschau, April 30, 2007
3. Spanien: Bahn bis 2020 auf Normalspur
4. PEQUENA HISTÓRIA DOS CAMINHOS DE FERRO EM PORTUGAL
5. "Third Rail System: Increased Danger Alleged". The Argus. 12 March 1926. Retrieved 3 September 2012.
6. "BREAK OF GAUGE.". The Sydney Morning Herald. National Library of Australia. 13 April 1915. p. 10. Retrieved 26 August 2011.
7. John F. Stover (1995). History of the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad. Purdue University Press.
8. The Day They Changed the Gauge on the D.L.& W. by Richard Palmer
9. "The Days They Changed the Gauge". southern.railfan.net. Retrieved 3 September 2012.
10. E.g., Columbus' Streetcar Track Gauge: 5'2" vs 4'8 1/2", Columbus Railroads, accessed 22 March 2011
11. Hilton, George W.; Due, John Fitzgerald (1 January 2000). The Electric Interurban Railways in America. Stanford University Press. ISBN 978-0-8047-4014-2. Retrieved 10 June 2014. Worst of all, not all city systems were built to the standard American and European gauge of 4'- 8 ¹⁄₂". Pittsburgh and most other Pennsylvania cities used 5'- 2 ¹⁄₂", which became known as the Pennsylvania trolley gauge. Cincinnati used 5'- 2 ¹⁄₂", Philadelphia 5'- 2 ¹⁄₄", Columbus 5'-2", Altoona 5'-3", Louisville and Camden 5'-0", Canton and Pueblo 4'-0", Denver, Tacoma, and Los Angeles 3'-6", Toronto an odd 4'- 10 ⁷⁄₈", and Baltimore a vast 5'- 4 ¹⁄₂".
12. The New York Times Magazine, 11 May 2008, p. 65
13. "Comrade Bingo". Jeeves and Wooster. 27 minutes in.

External links

• Broad Gauge Society
• Brunel's Broad Gauge Railways
• Jane's World Railways (hard copy)
• "Railroad Gauge Width".
• Brunel portal