Charlie McCreevy

Charlie McCreevy
European Commissioner for Internal Market and Services
In office 22 November 2004 – 9 February 2010
President	José Manuel Barroso
Preceded by	Frits Bolkestein
Succeeded by	Michel Barnier
Minister for Finance
In office 26 June 1997 – 29 September 2004
Taoiseach	Bertie Ahern
Preceded by	Ruairi Quinn
Succeeded by	Brian Cowen
Minister for Tourism and Trade
In office 22 January 1993 – 15 December 1994
Taoiseach	Albert Reynolds
Preceded by	Brian Cowen
Succeeded by	Enda Kenny
Minister for Social Welfare
In office 11 February 1992 – 12 January 1993
Taoiseach	Albert Reynolds
Preceded by	Brendan Daly
Succeeded by	Michael Woods
Teachta Dála
In office June 1997 – October 2004
Constituency	Kildare North
In office June 1977 – June 1997
Constituency	Kildare
Personal details
Born	30 September 1949 Sallins, Kildare, Ireland
Nationality	Irish
Political party	Fianna Fáil
Spouse(s)	Noeleen Halligan
Children	1 son
Alma mater	University College Dublin
Profession	Chartered accountant

Charles "Charlie" McCreevy (born 30 September 1949) is a former Irish politician. He was the European Commissioner for Internal Market and Services from 2004–2010. He was first elected to Dáil Éireann as a Fianna Fáil TD in 1977 and held the seat in Kildare (and later Kildare North) until 2004 when he became Ireland's European Commissioner.^[1][2] In successive governments he served as Minister for Social Welfare (1992–93), Minister for Tourism and Trade (1993–94) and Minister for Finance (1997–2004).

Early life and career

Born in Sallins, County Kildare, McCreevy was educated locally at Naas CBS and at the fee paying Gormanston Franciscan College. He studied Commerce at University College Dublin and went on to become a chartered accountant. His family background was modest (his father – and ancestors since the late 18th century – was a lock-keeper on the Grand Canal, a job carried on by his mother after the death of his father when McCreevy was four years old^[3]). So his post-compulsory education had to be achieved through winning scholarships.

His political career began with when he won a seat in the Kildare constituency at the 1977 general election^[4] which was a landslide for Charles Haughey's supporters in Fianna Fáil and he was re-elected at every subsequent election until he joined the Commission. Between 1979 and 1985 he was also elected as member of Kildare County Council.

Relationship with Charles Haughey

In the December 1979 Fianna Fáil leadership contest, McCreevy strongly supported the controversial Charles Haughey who narrowly won the post. However, in a time of severe budgetary difficulties for Ireland, McCreevy soon became disillusioned with the new Taoiseach and his fiscal policies. In October 1982 McCreevy launched a motion of no-confidence in the party leader, which evolved into a leadership challenge by Desmond O'Malley. In an open ballot and supported by only 21 of his 79 colleagues (known as the "Gang of 22"), the motion failed and McCreevy was temporarily expelled from the parliamentary party. In later years O'Malley was expelled from Fianna Fáil itself and formed the Progressive Democrats (PDs), espousing conservative fiscal policies. Although considered ideologically close to the PDs, and a personal friend of its erstwhile leader, Mary Harney, McCreevy chose to remain a member of Fianna Fáil, where he would eventually serve in joint FF-PD Governments.

Early ministerial career

For his first 15 years as TD, while Haughey remained leader, McCreevy remained a backbencher. In 1992, Albert Reynolds became Taoiseach and McCreevy was appointed Minister for Social Welfare. In this role, he is principally remembered for a set of 12 cost-cutting measures, collectively termed the "dirty dozen", which were arguably minor in their direct impact but provided a major political headache for his party in the 1992 General Election. In 1993 he became Minister for Tourism and Trade, which he held until the government fell in December 1994. In opposition, and under new Fianna Fáil leader Bertie Ahern, McCreevy was named to the Front Bench as Spokesman for Finance. In this role he was viewed as actively pro-enterprise, anti-spending and a key advocate for tax cuts.

Minister for Finance

In 1997, Fianna Fáil returned to power and McCreevy became Minister for Finance. His period coincided with the Celtic Tiger era which saw the rapid growth of the Irish economy due to social partnership between employers, government and unions; increased female participation in the labour force, decades of tuition-free secondary education; targeting of foreign (primarily U.S.) direct investment; a low corporation tax rate; an English-speaking workforce only five time-zones from New York, and membership of the European Community – which provided payments for infrastructural development and export access to the Single Market.

McCreevy was a consistent advocate of cutting taxes and spending. As Minister he had an opportunity to implement these policies. During his term in Finance, he made many changes to simplify the tax system and presided over Ireland's entry to Economic and Monetary Union of the European Union and later, the changeover to the Euro. He maintained a significant surplus during his seven years in Finance by forecasting tax takes which were lower than average. He simultaneously implemented a tax-cutting programme, major increases in health, education and pension spending as well as increasing investment in infrastructural development to 5% of GNP. Unemployment fell from 10% to 4.4%. Real GDP growth fell steadily, however, from a peak of over 11% in 1997 when McCreevy took office to just over 4% in 2004. Real GDP growth across the full period of the Celtic Tiger represented by far the highest average of any western European country. Inflation was increased from 1.5% in 1997, to 5.5% in 2000, before falling steadily to just over 2% in 2004.^[5]

From 1997 to 2000, McCreevy cut Capital Gains Tax from 40% to 20%, and extended Section 23 Tax allowances to the Upper Shannon Area (against the advice of the Finance Department) in the Finance Acts of 1998 and 1999. These included special tax incentives targeted at the area covered by the pilot Rural Renewal Scheme.^[6] This scheme was later subject to criticism by the Heritage Council for being introduced without a ‘Baseline Audit’ to inform the level and scale of development to be supported through the scheme, not identifying priority areas suitable for development, not providing any strategic protection for designated areas including the corridor of the River Shannon nor promoting the use of sustainable design and building materials in any new build or refurbishment project supported by the scheme.^[7][8] These two measures of cutting Capital Gains Tax and providing tax incentives for property development in thinly populated rural areas have been partly responsible for the explosion in housing and commercial property speculation, which led ultimately to the collapse of the Irish banking system.^[9]

Frequently outspoken, McCreevy sometimes made comments which attracted controversy. For example, McCreevy once referred to the Irish health system as a "black hole"^[10] and reacted to the initial Irish rejection of the Nice Treaty as "a sign of a healthy democracy".^[11] He later explained this as reflecting a wake-up call to politicians and others who, like him, had expected an almost automatic Yes vote. McCreevy also prompted warnings from the European Commission, who claimed that his £2 billion tax giveaway in 2000 would be inflationary, and harmful to the Irish economy.^[12]

In 2008 as Ireland entered recession^[13] McCreevy's stewardship has been cited as one of the reasons why the global financial crisis is hitting Ireland especially hard, due to his "light touch" regulation of the financial system.^[14] Former Taoiseach Garret FitzGerald attributed Ireland's dire economic state in 2009, on a series of "calamitous" government policy errors by the then Finance Minister Charlie McCreevy, who between the years of 2000 and 2003, boosted public spending by 48pc while cutting income tax.^[15] In 2015, McCreevy gave evidence to the Oireachtas Joint Committee of Inquiry into the Banking Crisis and denied his policies as minister had contributed to the crisis.A legal warning was given to McCreevy at the Banking Inquiry after he refused to answer, when asked, if he believed there had been a property bubble, but then accepted that from 2003 there had been a property bubble.^[16][17]

European Commissioner

In 2004, McCreevy was selected by the Government to replace David Byrne as Ireland's European Commissioner. He was appointed to the Internal Market and Services portfolio by President of the European Commission José Manuel Barroso. At his confirmation hearings in the European Parliament MEPs described him as “fluent and relaxed”^[18] giving straightforward answers in a refreshing and engaging manner. He also informed them that he had campaigned for the ratification of every European Treaty since 1972.

He describes his approach to his portfolio is;^[19]

You will find me ready to meet, discuss, listen and argue on how best to deliver to our citizens the real benefits of an Internal Market. There are enormous challenges facing the EU in the coming period on which we all must find common ground. I want our policies to show that EU means something real and positive to the people in Europe

McCreevy's EU Services Sector Competition Directive, sets out to achieve full competition in the Services sector across the EU. This is rather difficult to implement in practical terms. It is also very unpopular politically in large countries with high unemployment rates like France, Germany and Italy. McCreevy's determination to push this through, did result in much conflict. McCreevy could not see why the level of competition sought in the directive needed to be compromised. His viewpoint was that lack of competition was hurting consumers, without corresponding benefits to other interested parties.

McCreevy has sided with the major record labels who are trying to extend a fifty-year copyright exemption to ninety five years.^[20][21] In 2008 McCreevy was a supporter of attempts to introduce software patents in the European Union.^[22]

Following his departure from the Commission, McCreevy was forced to resign from the board of a new banking firm, NBNK Investments, after an EU ethics committee found a conflict of interest with his work as commissioner in charge of financial regulation.^[23] This is first time that a former member of the EU executive has had to resign a directorship the 2003 system for overseeing the work of retired commissioners.

Northern Rock Crisis

In October 2007 McCreevy, commenting on the Northern Rock Bank's loss of investor confidence, claimed that banking regulations in England which forces banks to be open to scrutiny from outside investors, caused the panic. He said that if access to the banks dealings had been restricted, then the trouble could have been avoided.^[24]

Lisbon Treaty ratification 2008

Irish constitutional law requires a referendum to alter the constitution for such a major change as the adoption of the Lisbon Treaty. Interviewed beforehand, McCreevy said that he had not read the Treaty in full himself, though he understood and endorsed it:

"I don’t think there’s anybody in this room who has read it cover to cover. I don’t expect ordinary decent Irish people will be sitting down spending hours reading sections about sub-sections referring to other articles and sub-articles, but there is sufficient analysis done and people have put together a consolidated text which is quite easy to read ...Anyone who thinks that, as the reality and inevitability of EU enlargement has taken hold, that we can continue to tackle urgent problems without streamlining of the decision-making process is failing to face up to reality."^[25]

In the event, the referendum was held on 12 June and the Irish electorate did not approve the Treaty.

McCreevy was then heavily criticised in the European Parliament by the leader of the Socialist group in the European Parliament, Martin Schulz, who demanded on 17 June 2008 that Charlie McCreevy be removed from his post of EU commissioner. Schulz slightly misquoted Mr McCreevy, however, saying that he had contributed to Ireland's rejection of the Lisbon Treaty with remarks during the referendum campaign that no "sane person" would read the document.

"This man goes to Ireland and says he has not read the treaty and tells people there is no need to read it," Mr Schultz said during a heated debate on the referendum at the European parliament in Strasbourg today."^[26]

McCreevy was not alone in this; it was reported that Brian Cowen, the Taoiseach at the time, had not read all of the Treaty.

Other interests

McCreevy is a member of the Bilderberg Group.^[27]

McCreevy joined the board of Sports Direct International plc on 31 March 2011 and is also a director of RyanAir.

McCreevy receives annual pension payments of €119,177.^[28]

References

1. "Mr. Charlie McCreevy". Oireachtas Members Database. Retrieved 22 July 2010.
2. When McCreevy resigned his Dáil seat on his appointment to the European Commission, his son, Charlie McCreevy, Jr, declined the opportunity to be the Fianna Fáil candidate in the resulting by-election and the seat was won by the Independent candidate, Catherine Murphy.
3. from an interview, Conversations with Eamon Dunphy, http://www.rte.ie/radio1/eamondunphy/ 16 February 2008
4. "Charlie McCreevy". ElectionsIreland.org. Retrieved 22 July 2010.
5. Economic and Social Research Institute "Irish Economy", "Archived copy". Archived from the original on 1 May 2008. Retrieved 2008-05-25.
6. http://www.revenue.ie/en/tax/it/leaflets/it65.pdf
7. "Archived copy" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 3 December 2007. Retrieved 2012-07-25.
8. http://www.leitrimobserver.ie/news/local/criticism-of-rural-renewal-scheme-s-lack-of-assessment-of-developments-in-early-years-1-2025873[]
9. "Ireland Bulldozes Ghost Estate in Life After Real Estate Bubble". Bloomberg.
10. Dáil Debates Report Archived 9 June 2011 at the Wayback Machine.
11. Irish Times – Nice vote a ‘wake-up call’ says McCreevy
12. BBC News "Ireland Warns of Slowdown", http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/business/1693997.stm
13. Celtic Tiger dead as recession bites
14. "McCreevy's return would only deepen fiscal crisis". The Irish Times. 12 December 2008.
15. FitzGerald says crisis started with McCreevy
16. "Department of Finance - Mr. Charlie McCreevy". Joint Committee of Inquiry into the Banking Crisis. 1 July 2015. Retrieved 2 July 2015.
17. "McCreevy gets legal warning after refusal to answer bubble question". The Evening Herald. 2 July 2015.
18. Irish Times – 'Fluent and relaxed' McCreevy gets European thumbs up
19. EU Parliament confirmation hearings
20. EU to push on music copyright
21. EU to Extend Music Copyright to 95 Years
22. McCreevy wants to legalise Software Patents via a US-EU patent treaty
23. Brand, Constant (8 October 2010). "McCreevy quits bank post after ethics ruling". European Voice. Retrieved 11 October 2010.
24. Northern Rock made worse by UK – McCreevy
25. Irish Times 23 May 2008
26. Call for McCreevy removal in heated Brussels debate
27. "Noonan attends annual conference of Bilderberg group". The Irish Times. 2 June 2012. Archived from the original on 8 June 2015.
28. Kelly, Fiach (10 November 2011). "Thanks big fellas: Ahern and Cowen get massive pensions". Irish Independent. Retrieved 10 November 2011.

External links

• ESRI report looks at health spending
• His Commissioner web page
• First speech to the Committee of Judicial Affairs of the European Parliament (02-02-2005).
• FFII: Charlie McCreevy and Software Patents