Michael Lowry

Michael Lowry TD
Minister for Transport, Energy and Communications
In office 15 December 1994 – 30 November 1996
Taoiseach	John Bruton
Preceded by	Brian Cowen
Succeeded by	John Bruton
Teachta Dála
Incumbent
Assumed office February 1987
Constituency	Tipperary
Personal details
Born	13 March 1953 Thurles, Tipperary, Ireland
Nationality	Irish
Political party	Independent (since 1997)
Other political affiliations	Fine Gael (until 1997)
Website	www.michaellowry.ie

Michael Lowry (born 13 March 1953) is an Irish politician. He has been a Teachta Dála (TD) since 1987, at first representing the Tipperary North constituency and then, from 2016, that of Tipperary.^[1]

Lowry is a former Chairman of the Fine Gael political party and was Minister for Transport, Energy and Communications between 1994 and 1996. He resigned from his ministry in some controversy. Fine Gael barred him from standing for the party again. Thereafter he ran as an independent candidate, and has maintained his seat in the Dáil ever since. The Moriarty Tribunal concluded "beyond doubt" that Lowry was a tax evader and had assisted businessman Denis O'Brien's Esat Digiphone consortium in acquiring a lucrative mobile phone licence in the mid-1990s, during Lowry's time as Communications Minister. O'Brien went on to become one of the richest men in Ireland.^[2]

Lowry initiated a defamation lawsuit against an Irish Independent journalist, Sam Smyth, over an article that Smyth had written regarding the Moriarty Tribunal as well as comments that Smyth made on a TV3 show. The lawsuit was thrown out of several courts and Lowry was ordered to pay Smyth's legal costs. More recently his relationship with Kevin Phelan has come under scrutiny, with the emergence of a recorded conversation in which Lowry claims to have made an undeclared payment of €250,000.

Despite being the subject of a criminal investigation resulting from several scandals pursuing him from his time in office, he continues to be very popular in his constituency.^[3]

Early life

Lowry was born in County Tipperary and educated at Thurles CBS. He was elected to North Tipperary County Council in 1979. In the early 1980s he was a Gaelic Athletic Association administrator, and was the youngest-ever Chairman of the Tipperary GAA Board.^[4] He runs a commercial refrigeration business, Streamline Enterprises, that he founded in controversial circumstances in 1988.^[4][5] Later, as chairman of the Semple Stadium Development Committee, he was involved in raising the necessary funds for the refurbishment of the stadium in preparation for the All-Ireland Centenary Hurling final in 1984.^[4]

National politics

Lowry was first elected to Dáil Éireann as a Fine Gael TD for Tipperary North at the 1987 general election and in 1993 he became Chairman of the Fine Gael Parliamentary Party.

In 1994 he was appointed Minister for Transport, Energy and Communications in the Rainbow Coalition government.

A succession of political scandals pursued Lowry throughout his time in office. These included allegations of irregularities relating to the granting of a mobile phone licence to Esat Telecom, which were later investigated by the Moriarty Tribunal, plans for the Dublin Light Rail System and the closure of rural post offices. The 1997 McCracken Tribunal revealed supermarket tycoon Ben Dunne had paid IR£395,000 for an extension to Lowry's home in Tipperary.^[6] The Tribunal concluded that Lowry had evaded tax.

This allegation prompted Lowry's resignation from the Cabinet in November 1996. Taoiseach John Bruton announced that Lowry would not be allowed to stand as a Fine Gael candidate at the next election, and he resigned from the party.

Lowry announced that he would stand as an independent candidate in the 1997 general election. He topped the poll in his constituency in that election, and did so again in the 2002 and 2007 general elections.^[7]

Lowry is backed by a strong local organisation in Tipperary, known informally as "Team Lowry".^[8]

Lowry was re-elected to represent Tipperary North at the 2011 general election, heading the poll on the 1st count with 14,010 votes.^[9] Along with Michael Healy-Rae and Noel Grealish, he is not a member of the Dáil Technical Group. He was elected again, for Tipperary, at the 2016 general election. He voted for Enda Kenny as Taoiseach on 6 May 2016.^[10] Shortly after Ceann Comhairle Seán Ó Fearghaíl confirmed the result, Lowry was seen to offer a handshake to Kenny.^[11]

Business interests

Lowry has directorships listed with the Companies Registration Office. He has two roles with Garuda Ltd, a manufacturer of electric domestic appliances; Abbeygreen Consulting, which involves construction work and special trades; and Gdlc Business Consultants Ltd., a business and management consultancy registered in Dublin. He also has an unlimited company called Glebeland Farm, which manages his bloodstock and livestock interests.^[12]

Lowry had some success with horse racing as a quarter-partner in the MALM partnership, but has in recent times taken to flat-race breeding.^[12]

Lowry owned a horse called "Wedding Morn", though the price he paid for the horse is not known. The horse was covered by Coolmore's "Danehill Dancer", from the stable of John Magnier. He would have paid up to €75,000 to have the horse covered. Another horse, "Probably", was sold by Lowry, which was the progeny of Wedding Morn. Wedding Morn was delivered of three foals including Probably, and the three were sold for a total of €410,000 by Lowry between 2009 and 2011.^[13] Lowry sold Wedding Morn in 2012 for €361,849.^[14]

Moriarty Tribunal: investigation and results

One of the remits of the Moriarty Tribunal, which sat from 1997 to 2011, was the investigation of payments to Lowry. In early 2007 Lowry announced that he had made a full and final settlement of all outstanding payments with the Revenue Commissioners in response to the findings concerning his tax evasion. His company Garuda had to pay €1.2 million after a Revenue audit. He also paid almost €200,000 to settle his personal taxes.^[15]

In March 2011 the second and final report from the Moriarty Tribunal found that, during his time as Communications Minister, Michael Lowry assisted businessman Denis O'Brien's consortium Esat Digiphone in acquiring a lucrative mobile phone licence in the mid-1990s which ultimately made O'Brien one of the richest men in Ireland.^[2]

It concluded "beyond doubt" that Lowry gave what it termed "substantive information to Denis O'Brien, of significant value and assistance to him in securing the licence".^[2] The Tribunal report found that Lowry, displayed "an appreciable interest" in the process and had "irregular interactions with interested parties at its most sensitive stages".^[2] It also found that one of Lowry's interventions, which cut the selection process to the advantage of Esat, was "disgraceful" and "insidious", and that he had misled the Government, his party leader John Bruton and his own civil servants to influence the selection process in Esat's favour.^[16]

The tribunal also found that Lowry sought to procure unwarranted rent increases that over a seven-year period would have benefited businessman Ben Dunne. Lowry sought to influence the outcome of an arbitration being conducted in 1995 in relation to the rent payable by the then state-owned Telecom Éireann for Marlborough House to a company owned and controlled by Dunne. The report said that the matter was "profoundly corrupt to a degree that was nothing short of breathtaking".^[2]

The report also summarised the cumulative payments made to Lowry, and says "In aggregating the known payments from Denis O'Brien to Michael Lowry, it is apposite to note that, between the granting of the second GSM licence to Esat Digiphone in May 1996, and the transmission of £420,000 sterling to complete the purchase of the latter of Lowry's English properties in December 1999, O'Brien had made or facilitated payments to Lowry of £147,000 sterling, £300,000 sterling and a benefit equivalent to a payment in the form of O'Brien's support for a loan of £420,000 sterling."^[2]

Lowry had addressed the Dáil saying that if he had been trying to hide a lot of money he would have "put it in an offshore account", implying that no such account existed. The Tribunal found that he actually had at least four such accounts that he used for the purpose of evading tax, and had not disclosed these accounts to the previous McCracken Tribunal.^[4]

Lowry rejected the Moriarty report, claiming that it was flawed and that the assumptions and conclusions that Justice Moriarty arrived at were totally baseless.^[16] Nonetheless the Criminal Assets Bureau and the Bureau of Fraud were called in on 29 March 2011 to begin investigating his finances, since his €1.4 million settlement with the revenue commissioners did not grant him immunity from prosecution.^[17]

On 31 March 2011, following the Moriarty Report's publication, the Dáil passed an all-party motion calling on Lowry to voluntarily resign his seat.^[18]

Lowry v. Sam Smyth

In 2010 Lowry launched a defamation lawsuit against Irish Independent journalist Sam Smyth, over an article Smyth had written regarding the Moriarty Tribunal^[19] as well as comments Smyth had made on a TV3 show describing Lowry as having been "caught with his hand in the till."^[20] Smyth defended the defamation claim, stating he "did not call Michael Lowry TD a thief, but did believe he was a liar and a tax cheat".^[21] Lowry's defamation lawsuit was thrown out in the Circuit court,^[22] and again on appeal to the High Court.^[23] High Court Justice Nicholas Kearns noted that Lowry "did not dispute that he engaged in tax fraud",^[23] and ordered Lowry to pay Smyth's legal costs.^[24]

Undeclared land interest

It emerged in October 2012 that Lowry owned land in Wigan which he had failed to declare in his register of members' interests. Between 2001 and 2003 the 25-acre site had been owned by Liam Carroll and Vineacre Ltd, a UK property company owned by him and Lowry. Vineacre Ltd was removed from the title in 2003 and Lowry declared his Vineacre interest until the company was dissolved in 2008. The land then became Lowry's and Carroll's in their own names, but he failed to declare his interest from 2008 onwards.^[25]

On 6 November 2012 Lowry amended his declaration to the Oireachtas to include the land interest, despite claiming previously that the land was "worthless". An unprecedented 380 complaints were made by members of the public in relation to the scandal, partly prompted by an article written by author Elaine Byrne.^[26][27] According to rules, the property must be worth more than €13,000 to be declared an interest. Lowry claimed the complaints were part of an "orchestrated campaign" against him.^[28]

As of December 2012 the probe into Lowry's failure to declare the land interest had been transferred to the Standards in Public Office Commission (SIPO).^[29]

Relationship with Kevin Phelan

In March 2013 Northern Ireland land scout Kevin Phelan revealed that Lowry had made payments to him in 2002, of which only half had been disclosed to the Moriarty Tribunal. The Sunday Independent released a secret recording of a telephone conversation made by Phelan, in which Lowry asks for nothing to be revealed about the payment to the tribunal.^[30] This was also broadcast on Tonight with Vincent Browne.^[31][32] In November 2015, it was announced that Lowry has launched High Court proceedings against INM in relation to the tapes.

Tax affairs

Lowry availed himself of the Tax Amnesty in 1993.^[33] He made a settlement with the Revenue again in 2003. In 2007 he paid a settlement of €192,000 which was due to the emergence of secret payments to him by businessman Ben Dunne. His company Garuda Limited made a settlement of €1.1m in 2005.^[34] In 2014 he faced five charges, including knowingly completing incorrect tax returns on a number of dates between 2003 and 2007. It is expected to go to trial in 2015.^[35]

State board appointments lobbying

In January 2015 it was revealed that he lobbied Taoiseach Enda Kenny to have his female former press adviser reappointed to a State board. Lowry passed a note to the Taoiseach in the Dáil chamber asking him to consider re-appointing Valerie O'Reilly, who runs her own successful public relations agency, to the board of the National Transport Authority (NTA). The note read "Taoiseach, would you please consider re-appointing Valerie O'Reilly to the board of the NTA. A woman, bright, intelligent and not bad looking either!" Her initial appointment by the previous government in March 2010 provoked charges of cronyism. The incident came just three months after Kenny and Fine Gael were engulfed in another cronyism scandal involving John McNulty and the Irish Museum of Modern Art.^[36] The then Fianna Fáil senator Averil Power expressed surprise at the tone of the note and said: "She probably does have strong business credentials, but to be referred to in this Father Ted 'lovely girls' sort of way is every women's worst nightmare. It also shows that we need far greater transparency when it comes to State board appointments".^[37]

Lowry was also revealed to have lobbied Minister for Transport Paschal Donohoe on the same matter. Donohoe told journalists at UCD that he had been "briefly" approached by Lowry. Lowry himself confirmed he had spoken to Donohoe in the Seanad chamber's anteroom. "I had been following a debate on a health-related issue in the Seanad and, out of courtesy, I informed Mr Donohoe, when I met him, that I had sent a note to the Taoiseach on the reappointment" claimed Lowry. When asked to respond to media coverage of the affair, Lowry said: "It is a load of nonsense and, frankly, more irritating than anything else."^[38]

References

1. "Mr. Michael Lowry". Oireachtas Members Database. Retrieved 27 September 2009.
2. "Lowry helped O'Brien get mobile licence". RTÉ News. 22 March 2011. Retrieved 11 March 2011.
3. Lynch, Andrew (23 March 2011). "If he'd been more careful, he could now be Taoiseach". Evening Herald. Retrieved 29 March 2011.
4. Keena, Colm (23 March 2011). "Still topping polls despite frequent falls from grace". The Irish Times. Retrieved 28 March 2011.
5. "Streamline Enterprises: Streamline Enterprises are market leaders in Refrigeration, Air Conditioning and HVAC solutions: Welcome to Streamline Enterprises Website".
6. Smyth, Sam (23 March 2011). "The two-bit politician who committed daylight robbery". Irish Independent. Retrieved 23 March 2011.
7. "Michael Lowry". ElectionsIreland.org. Retrieved 27 September 2009.
8. Ni Bhraonain, Eimear (26 March 2011). "It's the personal touch that earns such a loyal following". Irish Independent. Retrieved 28 March 2011.
9. "Tipperary North". RTÉ News. 28 February 2011. Retrieved 26 February 2011.
10. "Enda Kenny is re-elected as Taoiseach in the Dáil". Newstalk. 6 May 2016.
11. "KENNY ELECTED TAOISEACH, SHANE ROSS REVEALS APPOINTMENT TO TRANSPORT MINISTRY". Carlow Nationalist. 6 May 2016.
12. Ryan, Conor (1 December 2012). "Lowry's stock rises with sale of Wedding Morn foal". Irish Examiner. Retrieved 1 December 2012.
13. Ryan, Conor (11 July 2012). "Lowry has €1m reasons to be happy". Irish Examiner. Retrieved 11 July 2012.
14. Ryan, Conor (5 December 2012). "Lowry's bloodstock secures €813k". Irish Examiner. Retrieved 5 December 2012.
15. O'Toole, Fintan (21 April 2009). "A country still in thrall to the likes of Lowry". The Irish Times. Retrieved 27 September 2009.
16. Phelan, Shane (23 March 2011). "Lowry's disgrace". Irish Independent. Retrieved 23 March 2011.
17. "CAB investigating Michael Lowry finances". RTÉ News. 29 March 2011. Retrieved 29 March 2011.
18. "Lowry Motion passed without vote". RTÉ News. 31 March 2011. Retrieved 31 March 2011.
19. "Tribunal will reveal findings on money trail to ex-minister". Irish Independent. 27 May 2010. Retrieved 27 May 2010.
20. "Lowry loses High Court action". The Irish Times. 10 February 2012. Retrieved 10 February 2012.
21. "Journalist says he called TD a tax cheat not a thief". The Irish Times. 12 December 2010. Retrieved 12 December 2010.
22. "Sam Smyth awarded legal costs against Lowry". RTÉ News. 6 October 2011. Retrieved 6 October 2011.
23. "High Court dismisses Lowry defamation appeal". RTÉ News. 10 February 2012. Retrieved 10 February 2012.
24. McDonald, Dearbhail (11 February 2012). "'A good day for journalism' as Lowry loses libel appeal". Irish Independent. Retrieved 11 February 2012.
25. Ryan, Conor (30 November 2012). "Links between Lowry's 'worthless' Wigan land and deals probed by Moriarty". Irish Examiner. Retrieved 30 November 2012.
26. "Lowry may face standards probe after 380 complaints". Sunday Independent. 2 December 2012. Retrieved 12 December 2012.
27. Byrne, Elaine (4 November 2012). "Stop giving out about Lowry and make an official complaint instead". Sunday Independent. Retrieved 4 November 2012.
28. Brennan, Michael (29 November 2012). "Public inquiry to examine Lowry's land share in UK". Irish Independent. Retrieved 29 November 2012.
29. Ryan, Conor (29 November 2012). "Lowry's UK land interest to be probed". Irish Examiner. Retrieved 29 November 2012.
30. Keena, Colm (19 March 2013). "'Payment from Michael Lowry was part of agreement, says land scout'". The Irish Times. Retrieved 19 March 2013.
31. "Lowry tape broadcast". TV3 News. 15 March 2013. Retrieved 15 March 2013.
32. "Gardaí examining Lowry tape as conversation is aired on national TV: Independent TD Michael Lowry can be heard making reference to a £250,000 payment which he said he never declared". TheJournal.ie. 15 March 2013. Retrieved 15 March 2013.
33. "TD availed of 1993 'last chance' tax amnesty". 6 July 2006. Retrieved 5 December 2014.
34. "Michael Lowry's firm in 1.1m tax settlement". 8 October 2006. Retrieved 5 December 2014.
35. "Michael Lowry to face trial in Dublin Circuit Court". 5 December 2015. Retrieved 5 December 2014.
36. McConnell, Daniel. "Ex-minister passes note to Taoiseach seeking 'crony' appointment". Sunday Independent. Retrieved 27 January 2015.
37. Connolly, Shaun (26 January 2015). "Lovely girls' note embroils Taoiseach in controversy". Irish Examiner. Retrieved 27 January 2015.
38. O'Regan, Michael (27 January 2015). "Independent TD responds to reappointment controversy". The Irish Times. Retrieved 27 January 2015.

External links

• Official website