Itata incident

Itata Incident
Part of the 1891 Chilean Civil War
The Itata in San Diego Bay in 1891.
Date 1891 Location off Chile, Pacific Ocean Result American victory Chilean ship and crew captured
Belligerents
United States	Congressionist Junta
Commanders and leaders
W.P. McCann George Brown George Gard	Unknown
Strength
: U.S. Navy U.S. Marshal Service	: Navy of Chile Army of Chile rebels
Casualties and losses
None	Unknown 1 ship captured 5,000 rifles seized Unknown number of Chilean soldiers captured

The Itata incident was a diplomatic affair and military incident involving the United States and Chilean insurgents during the 1891 Chilean Civil War. The incident concerned an arms shipment by the Chilean ship Itata from the United States to Chile, to assist insurgent Congressionalist forces in the war. The Itata Incident was one of the causes of the Baltimore Crisis and is one of the reasons that Benjamin Harrison was not reelected to a second term as President of the United States.

Background

In 1891, after a series of struggles with the multinational nitrate interests, the Chilean National Congress refused to sign the national budget proposed by Chilean President José Manuel Balmaceda. Balmaceda then dissolved Congress. The Navy sided with the Congress. The Chilean Army and others sided with President Balmaceda. An armed conflict ensued.

Supporters of the Congress, including members of the dissolved parliament and their backers among multinational nitrate interests, purchased weaponry from Europe and from the United States. Supported by the navy, these forces rapidly captured Chile's northern provinces, many of which had recently been conquered from Bolivia and Peru during the War of the Pacific.

Washington

The Chilean foreign minister (of Balmaceda) Prudencio Lazcano approached United States Secretary of State James Blaine for assistance. Blaine initially rebuffed Lazcano but later, with the support of his soon-to-be successor John W. Foster and against the advice of Third Under Secretary of State John Basset Moore, agreed to aid the Balmaceda administration. Moore resigned in protest at Blaine's decision.

The U.S. arms shipment

Meanwhile, Ricardo Trumbull, an agent of the Chilean Congressional insurgents, was dispatched to New York. With the advice of William Russell Grace, whose nitrate company had relocated from Peru to New York in the 1860s and who had twice served as New York City mayor, Trumbull purchased for the Congressionalists some of the latest in American arms technology, including Remington rifles. He had the weaponry rail freighted to the Port of Los Angeles. The schooner Robert and Minnie transferred it to the Chilean steamer Itata while sailing near San Clemente Island.

San Diego

Before the Itata could rendezvous with the Robert and Minnie she was detained on May 6 at San Diego harbor on the orders of John W. Foster. Marshal George Gard took charge of the ship, but Gard allowed the Itata to remain under steam and in mid-stream, ready to sail, during her detention.^[1] At 5:30 pm on May 7 the Itata lifted anchor and left San Diego against US orders, while Gard was out in the harbor searching for the Robert and Minnie, which had been sighted the previous day in nearby Mexican waters.^[2] US national newspapers subsequently reported a claim by Marshal Gard, who had been aboard the Itata when she sailed and was put ashore by its crew the same evening at Ballast point, that the ship was loaded with Chilean soldiers.

Iquique

The United States navy dispatched several ships, under two admirals, to chase the Itata, which press reports claimed was expected to meet and supply the Chilean warship Esmeralda with arms and munitions. But both the Esmeralda and the Charleston, a US warship sent out after the Itata from San Francisco, reached the Mexican harbor at Acapulco by May 16, neither having intercepted the Itata.^[3]

The Charleston left Acapulco to join with other US ships, including the San Francisco and the Baltimore, and an international contingent including warships of the Royal Navy and the Imperial German Kaiserliche Marine to await the Itata at the Chilean harbor of Iquique. There, on June 4, U.S. Navy Rear Admirals W.P. McCann and George Brown convinced the Chilean Congressional rebels to give up the Itata and its cargo of around 5,000 rifles.^[4] Ironically another arms shipment from the vessel Maipo with a load of German-made Krupp arms and munitions arrived at Iquique on July 3, making the Itata's cargo unnecessary to the Congressionalist cause.

The Itata's return to the U.S.

Federal prosecutor Henry Gage.

Official White House portrait of William Howard Taft in the Blue Room, 1911, oil on canvas by Anders Leonard Zorn (1860–1920), White House Collection.

After its surrender, the Itata was brought back to San Diego with its crew. The Harrison Administration appointed William Howard Taft, the US Solicitor General (and later U.S. President), and Los Angeles-based federal prosecutor Henry Gage (later Governor of California), to investigate the Itata and prosecute its crew and suppliers.

Following his investigation Gage declined to prosecute the crew, stating his belief that the federal government had made an error regarding the matter. He also stated that he believed that the arms shipment constituted private property, and was outside of the federal government's direct jurisdiction.

Taft did prosecute the cases against the arms and against the ship; however, the U.S. government lost in each instance in the courts.

Ultimately the Chilean congressionalists succeeded in their ouster of the Balmaceda administration and, in 1901, the Chilean steamship company which had chartered the Itata to the congressionalist authorities brought a case against the United States for the ship's detention, claiming the ship had acted on behalf of the legitimate provisional government.^[5] The United States and Chilean Claims Commission ruled that the seizure had been justifiable, and that US authorities had had probable cause in holding the Itata at San Diego.^[6]

References

1. "Seizure of the Itata; the Robert and Minnie not caught", New York Times, May 7, 1891, retrieved 10 August 2008
2. "Away steamed the Itata", New York Times, May 8, 1891, retrieved 10 August 2008
3. "Waiting for the Itata", New York Times, May 17, 1891, retrieved August 10, 2008
4. "The Itata Surrendered", New York Times, June 5, 1891, retrieved August 10, 2008
5. "To decide the Itata case", New York Times, May 18, 1901, retrieved August 10, 2008
6. "Itata seizure upheld", New York Times, June 18, 1901, retrieved August 10, 2008

Sources

• Foreign Relations of the United States of America for the Year 1891. Washington, D.C.: GPO, 1892.
• Foreign Relations of the United States of America for the Year 1892. Washington, D.C.: GPO, 1893.
• "The Itata Incident" Osgood Hardy, in the Hispanic American Historical Review, vol V (1922) pp 195–226.
• The Federal Reporter. vv 47-9, 56
• John W. Foster. Michael Devine, London: The Ohio University Press, 1981.