North Tyrone by-election, 1911

The North Tyrone by-election was a Parliamentary by-election. North Tyrone returned one Member of Parliament to the House of Commons of the United Kingdom, elected by the first past the post voting system. The election was held on 6 October 1911.

Vacancy

The by-election was held due to the incumbent Liberal MP, Redmond John Barry, becoming Lord Chancellor of Ireland, requiring him to cease membership of the House of Commons. Barry had been Liberal MP for the seat of since the Tyrone North by-election, 1907 when he successfully defended the seat for the Liberals.

Electoral history

Unlike most Irish seats, the Liberals rather than the Irish Nationalists, were the standard bearers for Irish Home Rule. Close results were part of the seat's tradition with the Unionists winning three times and the Liberals six times. Barry's hold on the seat had always been tenuous; His three successful defences were all in two-party contests with an Irish Unionist, where he had never polled higher than the 51.1% of the vote he polled last time;

Redmond Barry

General Election 14 December 1910: Tyrone North^[1] Electorate 6,572

Party		Candidate	Votes	%	±
	Liberal	Redmond John Barry	3,170	51.1
	Irish Unionist	Lord Arthur John Hamilton	3,038	48.9
Majority			132	2.2
Turnout			6,572	94.5
	Liberal hold		Swing

Candidates

• The Liberals chose 60-year-old Tyronian Thomas Wallace Russell as their candidate. He had sat in the House as member for neighbouring Tyrone South from 1886 to January 1910 when he had been defeated. Russell had always been a Liberal, but he had not always supported Irish Home Rule. In 1886 he joined the Liberal Unionists as he disagreed with William Gladstone over Home Rule. However he found himself at odds with mainstream Unionism and by 1906, though still describing himself as a Unionist, had reached an understanding with the Liberal party. He eventually changed his mind on Home Rule and contested the January 1910 election as a Liberal.
• The Unionist challenger was 39-year-old Emerson Crawford Herdman. He had contested the seat in January 1910 but not in December 1910.

Campaign

The issue of Irish Home Rule was not prominent in the campaign, even though the Liberal Government, supported by the Irish Nationalists, was about to embark on the 3rd Irish Home Rule Bill. This was because in Tyrone, the electorate had long since made up its mind on this issue. Instead, the Unionist campaign sought to weaken the ties between the Liberal candidate and his would be supporters. A number of the Unionist influenced newspapers attempted to undermine Russell's campaign, by attacking him personally. They referred to the Liberal candidate as a 'Nationalist' and a turncoat. He was even referred to as a political Carpet-bagger, despite the fact that he was a local man.^[2]

Result

The seat was narrowly held by the Liberal candidate Thomas Wallace Russell;

Tyrone North by-election, 1911^[3] Electorate 6,551

Party		Candidate	Votes	%	±
	Liberal	Thomas Wallace Russell	3,104	50.1	-1.0
	Irish Unionist	Emerson Crawford Herdman	3,086	49.9	+1.0
Majority			18	0.2	-2.0
Turnout			6,551	94.5	+0.0
	Liberal hold		Swing	-1.0

Russell's 50.1% vote share was exactly the same as that won by Barry in the 1907 by-election.

Aftermath

Russell retired from politics at the dissolution of parliament in 1918. The seat of Tyrone North was merged with part of Mid Tyrone to create a new seat of Tyrone North West. Herdman eventually was elected to the Northern Ireland Senate.

References

1. British parliamentary election results 1885-1918 by Craig, F. W. S. (1974)
2. OUR CORRESPONDENT. "Election Intelligence." Times [London, England] 9 Oct. 1911: 8. The Times Digital Archive. Web. 22 Apr. 2014.
3. British parliamentary election results 1885-1918 by Craig, F. W. S. (1974)