Pune Metro

Pune Metro
पुणे मेट्रो
Overview
Owner N/A
Locale Pune, Maharashtra
Transit type Rapid Transit
Number of stations 30(phase 1)
Daily ridership 5,71,000 (phase 1)(2018 estd.)
Operation
Began operation N/A
Operation will start July 2019(estd.)
Operator(s) Pune Metro Rail Corporation
Reporting marks N/A
Technical
System length 600.515 km (phase 1)
Track gauge 1,435 mm (4 ft 8 1⁄2 in) (Standard gauge)
Electrification 25 kV AC through overhead catenary
System map

Pune Metro (Marathi: पुणे मेट्रो) is a proposed metro rail project for the Pune Metropolitan Area.

History

Pune has witnessed enormous industrial growth since 2000. Rapid urbanization in the recent past has put the city’s travel infrastructure to stress. With a large number of units have come up both in small scale as well as in heavy & medium scale industry etc., traffic in the city is rising at alarming rates. As the population of a city grows, share of public transport, whether road or rail-based, should increase. Experience has shown that, in cities like Pune where roads do not have adequate width and which cater to mixed traffic conditions comprising slow and fast moving vehicles, road transport can optimally carry 8,000 persons per hour per direction (phpdt). Being a thickly populated area, Pune’s traffic needs cannot be met by road-based system and additional flyovers. When traffic density increases beyond this level, average speed of vehicles comes down, journey time increases, air pollution goes up and commuters are put to increased level of inconvenience. The existing urban transport system of Pune City which is road-based has already come under stress leading to longer travel time, increased air pollution and rise in number of road accidents.[1] Public Transport System is an efficient user of space and with reduced level of air and noise pollution. Thus when on a corridor, traffic density during peak hours crosses this figure, provision of rail-based mass transport should be considered. The preparation of detailed project report (DPR) work was undertaken by the Delhi Metro Rail Corporation and submitted their report on 15 August 2008.[2] In 2010, the Pune Municipal Corporation (PMC) delayed submitting the proposal to the Union government to make provisions in the annual budget for the project.

PMRDA's Role

The Pune Metropolitan Region Development Authority (PMRDA) had proposed to take over the Metro project, which was declined by the PMC and PCMC. The opposing representatives said that the Metro rail is going to be implemented by Special Purpose Vehicle. Instead, the Corporations suggested inclusion of PMRDA in the SPV to increase the reach of the Metro rail.[3]

Cost

The estimated project cost for Phase I and II are INR 69.6bn and INR 32.24bn respectively. The project cost will be funded by the PMC and PCMC together bearing 10% of this cost, the state government 20% and the central government will bear 20% of this cost. The remaining 50% will be obtained from loans. The state government's share of 20% includes the expenses of acquiring land, including government land, at market price.[4]

The Pune metro project will now cost Rs 11, 522 crores, up from Rs 10,183 crores estimated in 2013.

The delay in the execution of the project has resulted in an upward revision of Rs 1,700 crores in the draft civic budget for 2015-16 presented by municipal commissioner Kunal Kumar.[5]

Budget Allocations

For the financial year 2015-16, the Union government made an allocation of Rs 126.58 crores and the State government allocated Rs 174.99 crores.[6] The budget allocation raised high hopes for the city's most awaited project but failed to keep the momentum, since apart from re-assurance nothing major happened that year.

For the financial year 2016-17, the Union government made an allocation of Rs 10.2 crores and the State government allocated Rs 45 crores off the total 180 crores allocated for Pune and Nagpur metro projects. The citizens of Pune were disappointed with the budget, stating that the government had no interest in addressing Pune's needs. The opposition protested against the State government for sidelining Pune, and that the Nagpur metro was being carried out speedily while Pune project has not even started.[7]

Plan

Network Map

Description

Phase Line Terminals Length (km) Opening date
Phase I Line 1 Pimpri Swargate 16.59 2019
Line 2 Vanaz Ramwadi 14.665 2019
Phase II Line 3 Deccan Gymkhana Bund Garden 11 2021
Line 4 ASI Hinjawadi 18 2021

[8]

Phase I

The two routes that have been identified for the first phase are:

  1. Line 1: Chinchwad – Pimpri – Swargate, via Agriculture college (16.5 km, elevated/underground from Range Hills)
  2. Line 2: Vanaz – Ramwadi, via Deccan Gymkhana, Yerwada (14.9 km, elevated)

Depots for the routes will come up at the following places:

  1. Line 1: Range Hills.
  2. Line 2: Kothrud.

Phase II

The second phase of the project will contain two lines and the extension of first phase:[9]

  1. Line 3: ASI to Hinjawadi via Aundh (18 km elevated)
  2. Extension of lines from Pimpri-Chinchwad to Nigdi and Swargate to Katraj (11.5 km elevated)
  3. Extension of lines from Aundh to Hinjawadi and Ramwadi to Kharadi Naka (13 km elevated)
  4. Extension of lines from Ramwadi to Viman Nagar Airport (elevated)

Line 1 (Pimpri-Chinchwad – Swargate)

Pune Metro

Line 1: Pimpri-Chinchwad – Swargate

Legend
Pimpri-Chinchwad
Sant Tukaram Nagar
Bhosari
To Pimpri station

Kasarwadi
Phugewadi

Dapodi
Mula River
Bopodi

Khadki
Range Hills

Shivajinagar
To Pune Junction
ASI
PMC
Mutha River
Budhwar Peth
Mandai
Swargate

The first line of the Pune Metro will run from Pimpri-Chinchwad to Swargate. This line will be elevated till Range Hills and further underground up to Swargate. In phase II this line will be further extended to Nigdi and Katraj/Hadapsar. This route will go via Bhosari, Khadki and Shivajinagar.[9][10]

Length Travelers Frequency
16.59 km 3,82,000 N/A

Stations

Main Line

  1. Pimpri-Chinchwad
  2. Sant Tukaram Nagar
  3. Bhosari
  4. Kasarwadi
  5. Phugewadi
  6. Dapodi
  7. Bopodi
  8. Khadki
  9. Range Hills
  10. Shivajinagar (underground)
  11. ASI (underground)
  12. PMC (underground)
  13. Budhwar Peth (underground)
  14. Mandai (underground)
  15. Swargate (underground

Extension

  1. Pimpri-Chinchwad
  2. Chinchwad Railway Station
  3. Akurdi
  4. Nigdi Pradhikaran
  5. Nigdi
  1. Aryaneshwar
  2. Natu Baug
  3. Padmavati
  4. Balaji Nagar
  5. Katraj

Line 2 (Ramwadi – Vanaz)

Pune Metro

Line 2: Viman Nagar/Kharadi – Vanaz

Legend
Viman Nagar
Kharadi
Wadgaon Sheri
Ramwadi
Kalyani Nagar
Yerwada
Mula-Mutha River
Bund Garden
To Hadapsar station
Ruby Hall

Pune Station
To Shivajinagar Station
Mangalwar Peth
Mutha River
Civil Court
ASI
Deccan Gymkhana
Garware College
Nal Stop
Ideal Colony
Anand Nagar
Vanaz

Line 2 will be the first line to be built. It will connect Ramwadi to Vanaz via Mangalwar Peth and Deccan Gymkhana. The line will be 15 km long and elevated. It is expected to cost ₹25.93 billion (US$390 million).[11] The main depot will be at Kothrud.

The line will be extended to Chandannagar and a separate line will go to the Pune airport.[12]

Length Travelers Frequency
14.93 km 1,89,000 N/A

Main Line

  1. Ramwadi
  2. Kalyani Nagar
  3. Yerwada
  4. Bund Garden
  5. Ruby Hall
  6. Pune Station
  7. Poolgate
  1. Mangalwar Peth
  2. Civil Court
  3. ASI
  4. Deccan Gymkhana
  5. Nal Stop
  6. Ideal Colony
  7. Anand Nagar
  8. Vanaz

Extension

  1. Ramwadi
  2. Wadgaon Sheri
  3. Kharadi
  1. Ramwadi
  2. Viman Nagar

Alignment Revision

In November 2015, a revised proposal submitted to the PMC by the DMRC suggested realigning the route along the Mutha river as against the earlier alignment along the Jangli Maharaj Road to reduce the project cost. The route length now is 14.665 km, reducing the length by 260 metres. The first corridor would remain same with length of 11.57 km.[13]

Line 3 (Deccan Gymkhana - Bund Garden)

Length Travelers Frequency
11 km N/A N/A

Stations

  1. Deccan Gymkhana
  2. Swargate
  3. Hadapsar Road
  4. Golf Course
  5. Koregaon Park
  6. Bund Garden

Line 4 (Hinjewadi – ASI)

Pune Metro

Line 4: ASI – Hinjewadi

Legend
 ASI
To Pune Junction

Shivajinagar
Agriculture College
Pune University
To Khadki Station
Ganeshkhind
Aundh
Mula River
Sangvi
Pimple Nilakh
Wakad
Hinjewadi

Line 4 of is from ASI to Hinjewadi. The whole route might be elevated. This is part of the second phase of the project.[9]

Length Travelers Frequency
18 km N/A N/A

Stations

  1. ASI
  2. Shivajinagar
  3. Agriculture College
  4. Pune University
  5. Ganeshkhind
  6. Aundh
  7. Sangvi
  8. Pimple Saudagar
  9. Pimple Nilakh
  10. Wakad Mankar Chowk
  11. Bhumkar Chowk
  12. Mezza9
  13. Hinjewadi

In June 2015, CM Devendra Fadnavis announced that the Shivajinagar-Hinjewadi route will be studied to provide direct connectivity and to reduce travelling time. In August 2015, the Pune Metropolitan Region Development Authority (PMRDA) suggested a metro route between Shivajinagar and Hinjewadi in place of the earlier proposed LRT. Preliminary study suggests the route will pass through PMC and PCMC to end up at the Information Technology park of Maharashtra Industrial Development Corporation (MIDC). The decision was unanimously approved by all members, and the LRT plan was scrapped.[14] Preliminary report for the line is underway.

Future Lines

The following routes and extensions have been proposed:

  1. Agriculture college – Warje via JM road and Karve road (9 km elevated)
  2. Extension from Bund Garden to Vishrantwadi (underground)
  3. Extension from Race Course to Hadapsar (elevated)

Airport Line

Pune Metro has a proposal of connection from Bhosari to New Pune International Airport. This line will go via Moshi and Chakan. This will be an elevated line.

Technical side

The proposed routes are to be built mostly on elevated rails, with underground routes and extensions to follow in future phases.[15]

The proposed fare structure in 2013–14 is to be a minimum of ₹ 7 for distances less than 2 km, and a maximum of ₹ 24 for distances above 30 km.

Rolling Stock

Rolling Stock for the metro rail will be procured by floating competitive international tenders. The company bidding the lowest will be awarded the contract. The company will manufacture 104 coaches to form 26 4-coach trains.[1]

Specification

The rolling stock will have the following specifications:[1]

Specification Detail
Driver Trailer coach (DTC) length 21.64 m
Motor coach (MC)/Trailer coach (TC) length 21.34 m
Width 2.90 m
Height 3.9 m
Axle load 16 T
Seat arrangement longitudinal

Capacity

The capacity of rolling stock will be as follows:[1]

Coach/Train Formation Total Capacity Seating Standing
Driver Trailer coach 247 43 207
Motor/Trailer coach 270 50 220
4-coach train 1034 186 848
6-coach train 1574 286 1288

Features

Rolling stock will have the following features:[1]

  1. Proven equipment with high reliability
  2. Passenger safety feature
  3. Energy efficiency
  4. Light weight equipment and coach body
  5. Optimized scheduled speed
  6. Aesthetically pleasing Interior and Exterior
  7. Low Life cycle cost
  8. Flexibility to meet increase in traffic demand
  9. Anti-telescopic

Ticket Fares

The expected ticket fares are:-

Distance (KM) Fare (₹)
up to 2 7
2–4 10
4–6 11
6–9 14
9–12 15
12–15 16
15–18 17
18–21 19
21–24 20
24–27 21
27–30 22
30 or more 24

Project-Related Concerns

Delay in Implementation

The citizens and city-based NGOs have regularly raised questions over the intention of the State governments as to whether they actually want to implement the project. The project was proposed way back in 2007 by the then Chief Minister Prithviraj Chavan of the INC government, but did not move ahead due to red tape and bureaucracy. The DPR was itself approved by the only on 12 June 2012.[16] At an event in 2013 during his tour of the city, the Metroman E. Sreedharan blamed the people involved in planning and implementing the project for the long delay, stating that "Pune lost five valuable years in unnecessary discussions instead of executing the project."[17] After coming in power in 2014, the newly elected Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis had assured fast implementation of the project, stating that it will be taken on priority basis along with Mumbai and Nagpur projects. However, the newly elected government had to bear a lot of protest as Nagpur metro got approval before Pune. The opposition claimed that the BJP-led government was purposely ignoring Pune as the party is not in power in the city.[18]

Alignment Issue

Initial plans were to build a few sections underground and the rest elevated. However, citizens of Pune did not want elevated routes as they felt that the roads could not bear the increased traffic that would result from the construction. Most roads were too narrow to accommodate the pillars of elevated routes. It was decided that all the routes in the city would be underground, although the map and the details of phases showed elevated routes. In November 2011, the Maharashtra Government declared that all the routes would be underground. However, in April 2012, the PMC declared that all routes will be as per the DMRC report, mostly elevated and partially underground in core city areas.[19] On May 27, 2015 the then Union Urban Development Minister M Venkaiah Naidu stated that underground metro was not a feasible option and that Pune, like other cities, will have to get an elevated metro as suggested by the DMRC. But as per the city activists, elevated metro is not possible due to presence of some flyovers along the route of metro and narrow roads on the metro corridor, which will cause traffic congestion and interruption.[5] In order to clarify this confusion, Maharashtra Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis announced that Pune will get "mixed-metro", as the alignment of some routes does support elevated sections.[20]

FSI Debate

The Delhi Metro Rail Corporation (DMRC) had proposed 4 FSI on either side of the corridor to achieve greater population densification through vertical development of residential and commercial properties. The PMC will raise money for the Metro and needed civic amenities to support the higher density. Furthermore, PMC hopes to increase the use of Metro.

Some members of the planning committee have suggested that three FSI be granted not only within 500 metre along the metro corridor but also in the entire city. Members have suggested that the amount collected through the premium on additional FSI should be turned into an urban development fund. A 60% share of this fund should be used for the metro project, while 15% for the PMPML and high capacity mass transit road and monorail and 25% for developing basic infrastructure.[21]

But as per several urban planners,NGOs and experts, the FSI introduction will have more consequences than benefiting the city.[22]

  1. Even if half the landowners along the metro corridor take advantage of the 4 FSI proposal, it will lead to 20 km2 of built up area in coming years, which is more than the total housing needs of Pune for the next 20 years.
  2. The PMC would raise Rs 37,000 CR from the sale of FSI whereas it needs just Rs 3,000 CR.
  3. In the area studied, most of the plots which could consume the 4 FSI were at the edge of the corridor away from the stations, while many plots next to the tracks and the stations would remain as is, since they were too small to accommodate the extra FSI. This plan might backfire as the distance of these plots from the nearby metro corridor might encourage the residents to use private vehicles and thus, defeat the purpose of metro.
  4. Given the prevailing land costs, the new development that comes up will be of the "premium" category. Thus any new housing that comes up through this extra FSI will cater to the more affluent segment, which is the group least likely to ride the Metro.
  5. The open space per capita will be reduced to half or less of what it is at present, in the city. The space required for other public amenities like hospitals, schools, clinics etc. will also fall short since very few plots are large enough to come under the "amenity" space rules under which the landowners have to give small portion to the city for providing amenities.[23]

In March 2015, CM Fadnavis announced that the 'Pune Metro' project is scrapped and wont be implemented al all.[24]

See also

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 http://www.punecorporation.org/informpdf/Metro/DPR_Metro_Aug_2014.pdf
  2. ↑ After Mumbai, Pune to get Metro – Business Today – Business News. Businesstoday.intoday.in (8 June 2012).
  3. ↑ http://indianexpress.com/article/cities/pune/pmrda-bid-to-take-over-metro-project-derails/
  4. ↑ Metro: Notification issued for special purpose vehicle, fare structure approved. Indian Express (15 September 2012).
  5. 1 2 http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/pune/Underground-metro-not-feasible-in-Pune-says-minister/articleshow/47435716.cms
  6. ↑ http://indianexpress.com/article/cities/pune/mahrashtra-budget-rs-174-crore-for-pune-metro/
  7. ↑ http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/pune/Meagre-funds-blow-to-Pune-metro-project/articleshow/51464277.cms
  8. ↑ Pune's metro dream on fast track as Centre backs project in Kochi – Times Of India. Articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com (5 July 2012).
  9. 1 2 3 pune-metro-full-presentation. Slideshare.net (29 April 2010).
  10. ↑ Delhi Metro Rail Corporation to revise metro rail project report – Times Of India. Articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com (27 September 2012).
  11. ↑ Cabinet nod to Pune Metro, in-principle nod to Nagpur Metro. NDTV.com (7 June 2012).
  12. ↑ Expedite SPV for metro, Pune Municipal Corporation tells state – Times Of India. Articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com (16 September 2012).
  13. ↑ http://indianexpress.com/article/cities/pune/after-4th-revision-pune-metro-project-cost-goes-up-by-45-pc/
  14. ↑ http://indianexpress.com/article/cities/pune/pmrda-proposes-metro-line-from-shivajinagar-to-hinjewwadi/
  15. ↑ "Metro rail can be a reality by 2013". Retrieved 30 July 2008.
  16. ↑ Pune Metro: Will it become Reality? | Hill Post. Hillpost.in (19 September 2012).
  17. ↑ http://www.sakaaltimes.com/NewsDetails.aspx?NewsId=5270799605771005380&SectionId=4635700988208141724&SectionName=Nation&NewsDate=20130801&NewsTitle=Sreedharan%20slams%20delay%20in%20Pune%20Metro%20Project
  18. ↑ http://indianexpress.com/article/cities/pune/pmc-corporators-protest-approval-to-nagpur-metro/
  19. ↑ http://www.punescoop.com/story/2008/7/18/04051/0223
  20. ↑ http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/pune/Mixed-metro-for-Pune-says-CM/articleshow/47636683.cms
  21. ↑ http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/pune/Political-infighting-on-three-FSI-proposal-hits-metro-plan-DP/articleshow/46559336.cms
  22. ↑ http://www.railnews.co.in/pune-based-urban-planners-rubbish-dmrc-proposal-for-fsi-along-pune-metro-routes/
  23. ↑ http://janwani.org/site/pune-metro-4-fsi-way-forward/
  24. ↑ http://www.punemirror.in/pune/civic/CM-brings-Pune-Metro-back-on-track-avoids-FSI-question/articleshow/46488104.cms

External links

This article is issued from Wikipedia - version of the 11/20/2016. The text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution/Share Alike but additional terms may apply for the media files.