Jainism and Hinduism

Jainism and Hinduism are two ancient Indian religions. There are some similarities and differences between the two religions.^[1] Temples, gods, rituals, fasts and other religious objects of Jains are different from that of Hindus.^[2]

Jain is derived from the word Jina, referring to a human being who has conquered all inner passions (like anger, attachment, greed and pride) and possess Kevala Jnana (pure infinite knowledge). Followers of the path shown by the Jinas are called Jains.^[3][4] Followers of Hinduism are called Hindus.^[5]

Philosophical similarities and differences

Jainism and Hinduism have many similar characteristic features, including the concepts of samsara, karma and moksha. However, they differ in the precise nature and meaning of these concepts. The doctrine of Jainism has minor similarities with Nyaya-Vaisheshika and samkhya school. The Jain doctrine teaches atomism which is also found in Vaisheshika system and atheism which is found in Samkhya.^[6] Within the doctrine of Jainism, there exist many metaphysical concepts which are not known in Hinduism, some of which are dharma and Adharma tattva (which are seen as substances within the Jain metaphysical system), Gunasthanas and Lesyas.^[6] The epistemological concepts of Anekantavada and Syadvada are not to be found in the Hindu system. There were, in the past, attempts made to merge the concepts of Hindu gods and Tirthankara of Jainism. The cosmography of Hindus resembles that of Jains and there are similar names of heavenly gods within both these system.^[7]

In the Upanishads, there also occur the first statements of the view, dominant in Jain teachings and elsewhere, that rebirth is undesirable and that it is possible by controlling or stopping one's actions to put an end to it and attain a state of deliverance (moksha) which lies beyond action.^[8]

Moksha (liberation)

In Hinduism, moksha means merging of soul with universal soul or eternal stay in paradise, in Jainism, it is action-less and peaceful existence. In Vedic philosophy or Sanatana Dharma, salvation is giving up the sense of doer ship and realizing Self to be the same as Universe and God. In Jainism, salvation can be achieved only through self-effort and is considered to be the right of human beings.^[9]

In Jainism, one definite path to attain liberation (moksha) is prescribed. The prescribed threefold path consists of the three jewels of Jainism (Right belief, Right knowledge, Right conduct). In Hinduism, no one definite path to salvation is prescribed.^[9]

Universe

According to Jain cosmology, the universe is eternal. In Hinduism, it is believed to be made by a creator.^[9]

Karma

Karma is an invisible force in Hinduism, whereas it is a form of matter which can stick to soul in Jainism.^[9]

Worship

In Hinduism, Gods are worshipped for minor boons and are offered food etc.^[9][10] In Jainism, the Tirthankaras represent the true goal of all human beings.^[11] Their qualities are worshipped by the Jains.

Women

The religion of Jains included women in their fourfold sangha; the religious order of Jain laymen, laywomen, monks and nuns.^[12] There was a disagreement between early Hinduism, and ascetic movements such as Jainism with the scriptural access to women.^[12] However, the early svetambara scriptures prevented pregnant women, young women or those who have a small child, to enter to the ranks of nun.^[13] Regardless, the number of nuns given in those texts were always double the number of monks. Parshvanatha and Mahavira, the two historical teachers of Jainism, had large numbers of female devotees and ascetics.^[13] Tirthankara Mahavira and Jain monks are credited with raising the status of women.^[14]

Religious texts

Hindus do not accept any Jain text and Jains do not recognise any Hindu scripture.^[15]

The Vedas

The scriptures known as Vedas are regarded by Hindus as one of the foundations of Hinduism. Those who rejected the Vedas as the prime source of religious knowledge were labeled "nāstika".^[16] As a consequence, Jainism and Buddhism were categorized as nāstika darśana.^[16]

The orthodox schools of Hinduism, such as Vedanta, Mimamsa and Samkhya, claim the Sruti do not have any author and hence are supreme to other religious scriptures. This position was countered by Jains who said that saying Vedas are authorless was equivalent to saying that anonymous poems are written by nobody. Jain scriptures, on the contrary, were believed by them to be of human origin, brought through omniscient teachers, and hence claimed greater worth.^[17] According to Jains, the origin of Vedas lies with Marichi, the son of Bharata Chakravarti, who was the son of the first Tirthankara Rishabha. Jains maintain that these scriptures were later corrupted by Brahmins.^[18][19] Jains pointed that Hindus do not know their own scriptures since they were unaware of the names of tirthankaras present in Vedas.^[17]

Jains had a long-standing debate with Mimamsa school of Hinduism. Kumarila Bhatta, a proponent of Mimamsa school, argued that the Vedas are the source of all knowledge and it is through them that humans can differentiate between right and wrong. Jain monks, such as Haribhadra, held that humans are already in possession of all the knowledge, which only needs to be illuminated or uncovered in order to gain the status of omniscience.^[20]

Vedic sacrifices

The practice of Vedic animal sacrifices was opposed by Jains. Hemachandra, a Jain monk, cites passages from Manusmriti, one of the law book of Hindus, to demonstrate how, in light of false scriptures, Hindus have resorted to violence. Akalanka, another Jain monk, sarcastically said that if killing can result in enlightenment, one should become a hunter or fisherman.^[17]

Hindu epics and Jain counter epics

The rejection of Hindu epics and scriptures were dominant in Jainism since very early times. The central Hindu scriptures and epics like Vedas, Mahabharata and Ramayana are categorized as false scriptures in Nandi-sutra,^[21][22] one of the svetambara's canonical literature. Later, Jains adapted various Hindu epics in accordance with their own system.^[23][24][19] There were disputes between Jains and Hindus in form of these epics.

Jains and Hindu Gods

Within the doctrine of Jainism, the tirthankara holds the highest status. Hemachandra says that a deva (roughly god) is the one who has conquered his internal desires and passions. This requirement, according to him, was fulfilled only by the tirthankara. The gods of Hindus were attached to worldly pleasures such as women and weapon and hence could not be regarded as necessary for spiritual upliftment.^[25][26]

Some personage mentioned in the Vedas and Jain scriptures are same. There is mention of the first tirthankara, Rishabhanatha in Rig Veda and Vishnu Purana. Rig Veda, X. 12. 166 states^[27]-

“

0 Rudra-like Divinity ! do thou produce amongst us, of high descent, a Great God, like Rishabha Deva, by becoming Arhan, which is the epithet of the first World Teacher; let Him become the destroyer of the enemies !

”

Vishnu Purāna mentions:

ऋषभो मरुदेव्याश्च ऋषभात भरतो भवेत्

भरताद भारतं वर्षं, भरतात सुमतिस्त्वभूत्

Rishabha was born to Marudevi, Bharata was born to Rishabh,

Bharatavarsha (India) arose from Bharata, and Sumati arose from Bharata.

—Vishnu Purana (2,1,31)

In the Skanda Purana (chapter 37) it is stated that "Rishabha was the son of Nabhiraja, and Rishabha had a son named Bharata, and after the name of this Bharata, this country is known as Bharata-varsha."^[28]

In the "Brahmottara-candam" section of the Brahma Purana, the narrator Suta describes many matters relating to Shaivism and in the 16th portion, there is a story about Bhadrabahu receiving instructions in a mantra from Rishabha yogi.^[29]

The Linga Purana mentions that in every kali yuga, Lord Shiva has incarnated, and that in one kali yuga he was a Yogeshwara (one of His 28 incarnations) named Rishabha.^[30]

History

Ancient

Jains and Hindus have coexisted in Tamil country for at least as early as the second century BCE.^[31]

Medieval

Competition between Jains and Brahmans, between Jains and Shaivas, is a frequent motif of all medieval western Indian narratives, but the two communities for the most part coexisted and coprospered.^[32] Shaiva kings patronised Jain mendicants, and Jain officials patronised Brahmana poets.^[32]

Decline of Jainism

Around the 8th century CE, Hindu philosopher Ādi Śaṅkarācārya tried to restore the Vedic religion. Śaṅkarācārya brought forward the doctrine of Advaita. The Vaishnavism and Shaivism also began to rise. This was particularly in the southern Indian states.^[33]

According to a Saivite legend, the Pandya king Koon Pandiyan ordered a massacre of 8,000 Jain monks. This event is depicted graphically in walls of Tivatur in North Arcot.^[34] However, this legend is not found in any Jain text, and is believed to be a fabrication made up by the Saivites to prove their dominance.^[35][36]

Conversion of Jain temples

In due course of time, some Jain temples have been converted into Hindu temples in India, particularly in South India.^[37]

Jains and the Hindu society

Jain scholars and some monks in general allowed a sort of cautious integration with the Hindu society.^[38] In today's date, there are a lot of common aspects in social and cultural life of Hindus and Jains. It is quite difficult to differentiate a lay Jain from a lay Hindu.^[39] The Jain code of conduct is quite similar to that which is found in Hindu Dharmasashtra, Manusmriti and other Law books of Brahmans.^[40] Many Jains now worship Hindu gods and celebrate Hindu festivals.^[40][41] The difference in the rituals of practitioners of the two religions would be that the Jains do not give any importance to bathing in holy water, cremating or burying ascetics.^[40] According to religious scholar M. Whitney Kelting, some of the "names and narratives" in the Hindu's list of satis are also found in the Jain tradition.^[42] In the Hindu context, a sati is a virtuous wife who protects her husband and his family and has the "intention to die before, or with," her husband.^[42] Kelting notes that those satis who die on the funeral pyre of their husband, or who "intended to die" but were prevented from death, may attain a status called satimata.^[42][43] Kelting says that the Jain tradition, due to principle of non-violence and equanimity, doesn't allow self-immolation.^[44][42] They, instead, see renunciation rather than self-sacrifice as the highest ideal for a Jain sati.^[42] Hindus think Jainism is simply another branch of Hinduism.^[40] Jain apologist like Champat Rai Jain, held that Hindus are Jaina allegorists who have allegorised the Jain teachings.^[45][7] However, such claims are not supported by historical facts.^[7]

Hindu revivalism and Indian identities

With the onset of British colonialism, select groups of Indians developed responses to the British dominance and the British critique of Hinduism.^[46] In this context, various responses toward Jainism developed.

Dayanand Saraswati and the Arya Samaj

The Arya Samaj was founded by Dayanand Saraswati (1824-1883), who "was the solitary champion of Vedic authority and infallibility".^[46] Swami Dayanand Saraswati authored Satyarth Prakash,^[47] a book containing the basic teachings of Saraswati and the Arya Samaj.^[48] It contains "Dayananda's bitter criticisms of the major non-Vedic religions of Indian origins."^[49] In the Satyarth Prakash, he writes that he regarded Jainism as "the most dreadful religion",^[50] and that Jains are "possessed of defective and childish understanding."^{[50][note 1]}

A recent strategy, exemplified by Rajiv Malhotra, is the use of the term dharma as a common denominator, which also includes Jainism and Buddhism.^[52]

Communal harmony

Dharmasthala Temple shows the communal harmony between Jains and Hindus, as the priests of the temple are Shivalli Brahmins, who are Vaishnava, and the administration is run by a Jain Bunt family.^[53]

See also

• Legal status of Jainism as a distinct religion in India
• Religious harmony in India

Notes

1. Daniels cites Dayanand in his investigation of the claim that "Hinduism is the most tolerant of all religions and Hindu tolerance is the best answer in fostering peace and harmony in a multi-religious society",^[51] taking Swami Vivekananda, Swami Dayananda and Mahatama Gandhi as cases.^[51] He asks the question "Why was Dayananda so aggressive and negative in his response to other religions?".^[51] Panicker also mentions that Dayanand's views are "strongly condemnatory, predominantly negative and positively intolerant and aggressive."^[49]

References

1. Sangave 2001, p. 135-136.
2. Sangave 2001, p. 138.
3. Sangave 2001, p. 15.
4. Sangave 2001, p. 164.
5. "Hinduism". Encyclopedia Britannica.
6. Glasenapp 1999, p. 496.
7. Glasenapp 1999, p. 497.
8. Dundas 2002, p. 15.
9. Sangave 2001, p. 137.
10. Zimmer 1953, p. 181.
11. Zimmer 1953, p. 182.
12. Balbir, p. 121.
13. Balbir, p. 122.
14. Sangave 2001, p. 147-148.
15. Sangave 2001, p. 136.
16. Nicholson 2010.
17. Dundas, p. 234.
18. Feynes, p. xxiv.
19. Glasenapp, p. 497.
20. Olle 2006, p. 91.
21. Dundas 2002, p. 237.
22. Iyengar, p. 62.
23. Schubring, p. 17.
24. Jaini, p. 305.
25. Dundas & 234-235.
26. Cort 2001, p. 93.
27. Jain 1929, p. 74.
28. Sangave 2001, p. 106.
29. P. 88, Madras Journal of Literature and Science, Volume 11 By Madras Literary Society and Auxiliary of the Royal Asiatic Society
30. P. 16 Linga Purana By Vinay. The list is in order is: Shweta, Sutara, Madana, Suhotra, Kanchana, Lokakshee, Jagishavya, Dadhivahana, Rishabha, Muni, Ugra, Atri, Vali, Gautama, Vedashrira, Gokarna, Guhavasi, Shikhandabhriti, Jatamali, Attahasa, Daruka, Langali, Mahakaya, Shuli, Mundishvara, Sahishnu, Somasharma, and Jagadguru.
31. John E. Cort 1998, p. 187.
32. John E. Cort 1998, p. 87.
33. Glasenapp 1999, p. 70.
34. Glasenapp 1999, pp. 70–71.
35. Ashim Kumar Roy (1984). "9. History of the Digambaras". A history of the Jainas. Gitanjali. Retrieved 22 May 2013.
36. K. A. Nilakanta Sastri (1976). A history of South India from prehistoric times to the fall of Vijayanagar. Oxford University Press. p. 424. Retrieved 23 May 2013.
37. "Metamorphosis of a Mahavira image", The Hindu, 4 July 2007
38. Jaini, p. 287.
39. Glasenapp 1999, p. 493.
40. Glasenapp 1999, p. 494.
41. Babb, pp. 3-4.
42. Keilting 2006, p. 183.
43. Keilting 2009, p. 22.
44. Keilting 2009, p. 21.
45. Jain 1929, p. 154.
46. Rambachan 1994, p. 38.
47. Panicker 2006, p. 38.
48. Panicker 2006, p. 38-39.
49. Panicker 2006, p. 39.
50. Daniel 2000, p. 92.
51. Eastern Book Company, About the Book: , Hindu Response to Religious Pluralism (P.S. Daniels (2000))
52. Springer 2012.
53. "Shri Kshetra Dharmasthala". shridharmasthala.org.

Sources

• Springer (2012), International Journal of Hindu Studies, Vol. 16, No. 3, December 2012
• Nicholson, Andrew J. (2010), Unifying Hinduism: Philosophy and Identity in Indian Intellectual History, Columbia University Press
• Kelting, M. Whitney (2009), Heroic Wives Rituals, Stories and the Virtues of Jain Wifehood, Oxford University Press, ISBN 978-0-19-973679-9
• Lockard, Craig A. (2007), Societies, Networks, and Transitions. Volume I: to 1500, Cengage Learning, ISBN 0618386122
• Kelting, Whitney (2006), "Thinking collectively about Jain Satis: The uses of Jain Sati name lists", in Peter Flügel, Studies in Jaina History and Culture: Disputes and Dialogues, Taylor & Francis, ISBN 978-0-203-00853-9
• Panicker, P.L. John (2006), Gandhi on Pluralism and Communalism, ISPCK, ISBN 9788172149055
• Qvarnström, Olle (2006), Peter, Flügel, ed., "The Jain-Mimamsa Debate on Omniscience", Studies in Jaina History and Culture: Disputes and Dialogues, ISBN 9780203008539
• Iyengar, Kodaganallur Ramaswami Srinivasa (2005), Asian Variations In Ramayana, Sahitya Akademi, ISBN 978-81-260-1809-3
• Sangave, Vilas Adinath (2001), Aspects of Jaina religion (3 ed.), Bharatiya Jnanpith, ISBN 81-263-0626-2
• Cort, John E. (2001), Jains in the World : Religious Values and Ideology in India: Religious Values and Ideology in India, Oxford University Press, ISBN 978-0-19-803037-9
• King, Richard (2001), Orientalism and Religion: Post-Colonial Theory, India and "The Mystic East", Taylor & Francis e-Library
• Schubring, Walther (2000), The Doctrine of the Jainas: Described After the Old Sources, Motilal Banarsidass, ISBN 978-81-208-0933-8
• Daniel, P.S. (2000), Hindu Response to Religious Pluralism, Kant Publications, ISBN 8186218106
• Jaini, Padmanabh S. (2000a), "Jaina Purana: A counter Puranic Tradition", Collected Papers on Jaina Studies, Motilal Banarsidass, ISBN 978-81-208-1691-6
• Jaini, Padmanabh S. (2000b), "Jina Rsabha as an Avatara of Visnu", Collected Papers on Jaina Studies, Motilal Banarsidass, ISBN 978-81-208-1691-6
• Glasenapp, Helmuth von (1999), Jainism: An Indian Religion of Salvation, Motilal Banarsidass, ISBN 978-81-208-1376-2
• Feynes, R.C.C (1998), The Lives of the Jain Elders, Oxford University Press, ISBN 978-0-19-283227-6
• Jaini, Padmanabh S. (1998), The Jaina Path of Purification, Motilal Banarsidass, ISBN 978-81-208-1578-0
• John E. Cort, ed. (1998), Open Boundaries: Jain Communities and Cultures in Indian History, SUNY Press, ISBN 0-7914-3785-X
• Babb, Lawrence A. (1996). Absent Lord: Ascetics and Kings in a Jain Ritual Culture. University of California Press. ISBN 978-0-520-91708-8.
• Rambachan, Anatanand (1994), The Limits of Scripture: Vivekananda's Reinterpretation of the Vedas, University of Hawaii Press
• Nalini Balbir Sharma, Arvind (1994), Religion and Women, SUNY Press, p. 121, ISBN 978-0-7914-1690-7
• Dundas, Paul (2002) [1992], The Jains (Second ed.), Routledge, ISBN 0-415-26605-X
• Ramanujan, A.K. (1991), "Three Hundred Ramayanas: Five Examples and Three Thoughts on Translation", in Paula Richman, Many Rāmāyaṇas: The Diversity of a Narrative Tradition in South Asia, University of California Press, ISBN 978-0-520-07589-4
• Zimmer, Heinrich (1989), Philosophies of India, Princeton University Press
• Embree, Ainslie T. (1988), Sources of Indian Tardition. Second Edition. volume One. From the beginning to 1800, Columbia University Press
• Zimmer, Heinrich (1953), Joseph Campbell, ed., Philosophies Of India, London, E.C. 4: Routledge & Kegan Paul Ltd, ISBN 978-8120807396
• Jain, Champat Rai (1929), Risabha Deva - The Founder of Jainism, Allahabad: The Indian Press Limited, Not in Copyright