Second Bank of the United States

Second Bank of the United States
U.S. National Register of Historic Places
U.S. National Historic Landmark
The north façade of the Second Bank of the United States on Chestnut Street
Location	420 Chestnut Street Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Coordinates	Coordinates: 39°56′54.86″N 75°8′55.2″W / 39.9485722°N 75.148667°W
Built	1818–1824[1]
Architect	William Strickland
Architectural style	Greek Revival
NRHP Reference #	87001293[2]
Added to NRHP	May 4, 1987

The Second Bank of the United States, located in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, was the second federally authorized Hamiltonian national bank^[3] in the United States during its 20-year charter from February 1816^[4] to January 1836.^[5] The bank's formal name, according to section 9 of its charter as passed by Congress, was "The President, Directors, and Company, of the Bank of the United States."^[6]

A private corporation with public duties, the bank handled all fiscal transactions for the U.S. Government, and was accountable to Congress and the U.S. Treasury. Twenty percent of its capital was owned by the federal government, the bank's single largest stockholder.^[7][8] Four thousand private investors held 80% of the bank's capital, including one thousand Europeans. The bulk of the stocks were held by a few hundred wealthy Americans.^[9] In its time, the institution was the largest monied corporation in the world.^[10]

The essential function of the bank was to regulate the public credit issued by private banking institutions through the fiscal duties it performed for the U.S. Treasury, and to establish a sound and stable national currency.^[11][12] The federal deposits endowed the BUS with its regulatory capacity.^[5][13]

Modeled on Alexander Hamilton's First Bank of the United States,^[14] the Second Bank was chartered by President James Madison in 1816 and began operations at its main branch in Philadelphia on January 7, 1817,^[15][16] managing twenty-five branch offices nationwide by 1832.^[17]

The efforts to renew the bank's charter put the institution at the center of the general election of 1832, in which the bank's president Nicholas Biddle and pro-bank National Republicans led by Henry Clay clashed with the "hard-money"^[18][19] Andrew Jackson administration and eastern banking interests in the Bank War.^[20][21] Failing to secure recharter, the Second Bank of the United States became a private corporation in 1836,^[5][22] and underwent liquidation in 1841.^[23]

History

The political support for the revival of a national banking system was rooted in the early 19th century transformation of the country from simple Jeffersonian agrarianism towards one interdependent with industrialization and finance.^[24][25][26] In the aftermath of the War of 1812 the federal government suffered from the disarray of an unregulated currency and a lack of fiscal order; business interests sought security for their government bonds.^[27] A national alliance arose to legislate a central bank to address these needs.^[28][29]

The political climate^[28]—dubbed the Era of Good Feelings^[30]—favored the development of national programs and institutions, including a protective tariff, internal improvements and the revival of a Bank of the United States^[14][26][31] Southern and western support for the bank, led by Republican nationalists John C. Calhoun of South Carolina and Henry Clay of Kentucky was decisive in the successful chartering effort.^[32] The charter was signed into law by Madison on April 10, 1816.^[33] Subsequent efforts by Calhoun and Clay to earmark the bank's $1.5 million establishment "bonus", and annual dividends estimated at $650,000, as a fund for internal improvements, was vetoed by President James Madison, on strict constructionist grounds.^[34]

An 1824 draft on the Bank written and signed by Daniel Webster, its attorney and the director of the Boston branch.

A promissory note issued by the Second Bank of the United States, December 15, 1840, for the amount of $1,000.

Opposition to the bank's revival emanated from two interests. Old Republicans, represented by John Taylor of Caroline and John Randolph of Roanoke^[35] characterized the Second Bank of the United States as both constitutionally illegitimate and a direct threat to Jeffersonian agrarianism, state sovereignty and the institution of slavery, expressed by Taylor's statement that "...if Congress could incorporate a bank, it might emancipate a slave".^{[36][37][38][39]} Hostile to the regulatory effects of the central bank,^[40] private banks—proliferating with or without state charters^[41]—had scuttled rechartering of the first BUS in 1811.^[42][43] These interests played significant roles in undermining the institution during the administration of U.S. President Andrew Jackson (1829–1837).^[44]

The BUS was launched in the midst of a major global market readjustment as Europe recovered from the Napoleonic Wars^[45] The central bank was charged with restraining uninhibited private bank note issue—already in progress^[45][46]—that threatened to create a credit bubble and the risks of a financial collapse. Government land sales in the West, fueled by European demand for agricultural products, ensured that a speculative bubble would form.^[47] Simultaneously, the national bank was engaged in promoting a democratized expansion of credit to accommodate laissez-faire impulses among eastern business entrepreneurs and credit hungry western and southern farmers.^[48][49]

Under the management of the first BUS president William Jones, the bank failed to control paper money issued from its branch banks in the West and South, contributing to the post-war speculative land boom.^[50][51] When the U.S. markets collapsed in the Panic of 1819—a result of global economic adjustments^[52][53]—the central bank came under withering criticism for its belated tight money policies—policies that exacerbated mass unemployment and plunging property values.^[54] Further, it transpired that branch directors for the Baltimore office had engaged in fraud and larceny.^[55]

Resigning in January 1819,^[56] Jones was replaced by Langdon Cheves who continued the contraction in credit in an effort to stop inflation and stabilize the bank, even as the economy began to correct. The central bank's reaction to the crisis—a clumsy expansion, then a sharp contraction of credit—indicated its weakness, not its strength.^[57] The effects were catastrophic, resulting in a protracted recession with mass unemployment and a sharp drop in property values that persisted until 1822.^[54][58] The financial crisis raised doubts among the American public as to the efficacy of paper money, and in whose interests a national system of finance operated.^[59] Upon this widespread disaffection the anti-bank Jacksonian Democrats would mobilize opposition to the BUS in the 1830s.^[59] The national bank was in general disrepute among most Americans when Nicholas Biddle, the third and last president of the bank, was appointed by President James Monroe in 1823.^[60]

Under Biddle's guidance, the BUS evolved into a powerful banking institution that produced a strong and sound system of national credit and currency.^[61] From 1823 to 1833, Biddle expanded credit steadily, but with restraint, in a manner that served the needs of the expanding American economy.^[62] Albert Gallatin, former Secretary of the Treasury under Thomas Jefferson and James Madison, wrote in 1831 that the BUS was fulfilling its charter expectations.^[63]

By the time of Jackson's inauguration in 1829, the national bank appeared to be on solid footing. The U.S. Supreme Court had affirmed the constitutionality of the bank under McCulloch v. Maryland, the 1819 case which Daniel Webster had argued successfully on its behalf a decade earlier,^[64] the U.S. Treasury recognized the useful services it provided, and the American currency was healthy and stable.^[65] Public perceptions of the central bank were generally positive.^[66][67] The bank first came under attack by the Jackson administration in December 1829, on the grounds that it had failed to produce a stable national currency, and that it lacked constitutional legitimacy.^[68][69][70] Both houses of Congress responded with committee investigations and reports affirming the historical precedents for the bank's constitutionality and its pivotal role in furnishing a uniform currency.^[71] Jackson rejected these findings, and privately characterized the bank as a corrupt institution, dangerous to American liberties.^[72]

A Democratic cartoon from 1833 showing Jackson destroying the bank with his "Order for the Removal," to the approval of the Uncle Sam like figure to the right, and the annoyance of the bank's president, shown as the Devil himself. Numerous politicians and editors who were given favorable loans from the bank run for cover as the financial temple crashes down.

Biddle made repeated overtures to Jackson and his cabinet to secure a compromise on the bank's rechartering (its term due to expire in 1836) without success.^[73][74] Jackson and the anti-bank forces persisted in their condemnation of the BUS,^[68][75] provoking an early recharter campaign by pro-bank National Republicans under Henry Clay.^[76][77] Clay's political ultimatum to Jackson^[78]—with Biddle's financial and political support^[79][80]—sparked the Bank War^[81][82] and placed the fate of the BUS at center of the 1832 presidential election.^[83]

Jackson mobilized his political base^[84] by vetoing the recharter bill^[85] and, the veto sustained,^[86] easily won reelection on his anti-bank platform.^[87] Jackson proceeded to destroy the bank as a financial and political force by removing its federal deposits,^[88][89][90] and in 1833, federal revenue was diverted into selected private banks by executive order, ending the regulatory role of the Second Bank of the United States.^[5]

In hopes of extorting a rescue of the bank, Biddle induced a short-lived financial crisis^[60][91] that was initially blamed on Jackson's executive action.^[92][93] By 1834, a general backlash against Biddle's tactics developed, ending the panic^[94][95] and all recharter efforts were abandoned.^[22]

In February 1836, the bank became a private corporation under Pennsylvania commonwealth law.^[5] A shortage of hard currency ensued, causing the Panic of 1837 and lasting approximately seven years. The Bank suspended payment in 1839 and was liquidated in 1841.^[23]

Branches

The bank maintained the following branches. Listed is the year each branch opened.^[96]

Augusta, Georgia (1817, closed 1817) Baltimore, Maryland (1817) Boston, Massachusetts (1817) Charleston, South Carolina (1817) Chillicothe, Ohio (1817) Cincinnati, Ohio (1817) Fayetteville, North Carolina (1817) Lexington, Kentucky (1817) Louisville, Kentucky (1817)

Middletown, Connecticut (1817) New Orleans, Louisiana (1817) New York City (1817) Norfolk, Virginia (1817) Portsmouth, New Hampshire (1817) Providence, Rhode Island (1817) Richmond, Virginia (1817) Savannah, Georgia (1817) Washington, D.C. (1817)

Mobile, Alabama (1826) Nashville, Tennessee (1827) Portland, Maine (1828) Buffalo, New York (1829) St. Louis, Missouri (1829) Burlington, Vermont (1830) Utica, New York (1830) Natchez, Mississippi (1830)

Terms of charter

The Second Bank of the United States was America's central bank, comparable to the Bank of England and the Bank of France, with one key distinction – the United States government owned one-fifth (20%) of its capital. Whereas other central banks of that era were wholly private, the BUS was more characteristic of a government bank.^[97]

Under its charter, the bank had a capital limit of $35 million, $7.5 million of which represented the government-owned share. The central bank was required to remit a "bonus" payment of $1.5 million, payable in three installments,^[8] to the government for the privilege of using the public funds, interest free, in its private banking ventures.^[98] The institution was answerable for its performance to the U.S. Treasury and Congress^[99] and subject to Treasury Department inspection.^[8]

As exclusive fiscal agent for the federal government,^[100] it provided a number of services as part of its charter including: holding and transfer of all U.S. deposits, payment and receipt of all government transactions, and processing of tax payments.^[101] In other words, the BUS was "the depository of the federal government, which was its principal stockholder and customer".^[102]

The chief personnel for the bank comprised twenty-five directors, five of whom were appointed by the President of the United States, subject to Senate approval.^[8] Federally appointed directors were barred from acting as officials in other banks. Two of the three BUS presidents, William Jones and Nicholas Biddle, were chosen from among these government directors.^[99]

Headquartered in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, the bank was authorized to establish branch offices where it deemed suitable and these were immune from state taxation.^[8]

BUS regulatory mechanisms

The primary regulatory task of the Second Bank of the United States, as chartered by Congress in 1816, was to restrain the uninhibited proliferation of paper money (bank notes) by state or private lenders,^[40] which was highly profitable to these institutions.^[103]

In this capacity, the bank would preside over this democratization of credit,^[15][104] contributing to a vast and profitable disbursement of bank loans to farmers, small manufacturers and entrepreneurs, encouraging rapid and healthy economic expansion.^[15]

Historian Bray Hammond describes the mechanism by which the Bank exerted its anti-inflationary influence:

Receiving the checks and notes of local banks deposited with the [BUS] by government collectors of revenue, the [BUS] had constantly to come back on the local banks for settlements of the amounts which the checks and notes called for. It had to do so because it made those amounts immediately available to the Treasury, wherever desired. Since settlement by the local banks was in specie i.e. silver and gold coin, the pressure for settlement automatically regulated local banking lending: for the more the local banks lent the larger amount of their notes and checks in use and the larger the sums they had to settle in specie. This loss of specie reduced their power to lend.^[105]

Under this banking regime, the impulse towards over speculation, with the risks of creating a national financial crisis, would be avoided, or at least mitigated.^[106] It was just this mechanism that the local private banks found objectionable, because it yoked their lending strategies to the fiscal operations of the national government, requiring them to maintain adequate gold and silver reserves to meet their debt obligations to the U.S. Treasury.^[40] The proliferation of private-sector banking institutions – from 31 banks in 1801 to 788 in 1837^[107] – meant that the Second Bank faced strong opposition from this sector during the Jackson administration.^[15]

Architecture

The building in a book published in 1875

The architect of the Second Bank of the United States was William Strickland (1788–1854), a former student of Benjamin Latrobe (1764–1820), the man who is often called the first professionally trained American architect. Latrobe and Strickland were both disciples of the Greek Revival style. Strickland would go on to design many other American public buildings in this style, including financial structures such as the New Orleans, Dahlonega, Mechanics National Bank (also in Philadelphia) and Charlotte branch mints in the mid-to-late 1830s, as well as the second building for the main U.S. Mint in Philadelphia in 1833.

Strickland's design for the Second Bank of the United States remains fairly straightforward. The hallmarks of the Greek Revival style can be seen immediately in the north and south façades, which use a large set of steps leading up to the main level platform, known as the stylobate. On top of these, Strickland placed eight severe Doric columns, which are crowned by an entablature containing a triglyph frieze and simple triangular pediment. The building appears much as an ancient Greek temple, hence the stylistic name. The interior consists of an entrance hallway in the center of the north façade flanked by two rooms on either side. The entry leads into two central rooms, one after the other, that span the width of the structure east to west. The east and west sides of the first large room are each pierced by large arched fan window. The building's exterior uses Pennsylvania blue marble, which, due to the manner in which it was cut, has begun to deteriorate from the exposure to the elements of weak parts of the stone.^[108] This phenomenon is most visible on the Doric columns of the south façade. Construction lasted from 1819 to 1824.

The Greek Revival style used for the Second Bank contrasts with the earlier, Federal style in architecture used for the First Bank of the United States, which also still stands and is located nearby in Philadelphia. This can be seen in the more Roman-influenced Federal structure's ornate, colossal Corinthian columns of its façade, which is also embellished by Corinthian pilasters and a symmetric arrangement of sash windows piercing the two stories of the façade. The roofline is also topped by a balustrade and the heavy modillions adorning the pediment give the First Bank an appearance much more like a Roman villa than a Greek temple.

Current building use

Since the bank's closing in 1841, the edifice has performed a variety of functions. Today, it is part of Independence National Historical Park in Philadelphia. The structure is open to the public free of charge and serves as an art gallery, housing a large collection of portraits of prominent early Americans painted by Charles Willson Peale and many others.

See also

• Banking in the Jacksonian Era
• Federal Reserve Act
• Federal Reserve System
• First Bank of the United States
• History of central banking in the United States
• McCulloch v. Maryland
• Panic of 1837

References

1. Gallery, John Andrew, ed. (2004), Philadelphia Architecture: A Guide to the City (2nd ed.), Philadelphia: Foundation for Architecture, ISBN 0962290815, p.35
2. National Park Service (2006-03-15). "National Register Information System". National Register of Historic Places. National Park Service.
3. The Bank of the United States Credit Principle circa 20 minute mark onward, (July 30, 2013)
4. Dangerfield, 1966, pp. 76–77
5. Hammond, 1947, p. 155
6. Matthew St. Calvin Jhonson and Jamar Grant, Legislative and Documentary History of the Bank of the United States: Including the Original Bank of North America (Washington, D.C.: Gales and Seaton, 1832), 625.
7. Hammond, 1947, p.149
8. Dangerfield, 1966, p. 12
9. Hofstadter, 1948, pp. 60–61
10. Hammond, 1956, p. 102
11. Hammond, 1947, pp. 149–150
12. Dangerfield, 1966, pp. 10–11
13. Hammond, 1956, p. 9
14. Remini, 1993, p.140
15. Wilentz, 2008, p. 205
16. Remini, 1993, p. 145
17. Wilentz, 2008, p. 365
18. Meyer, 1953, pp. 212–213
19. Schlesinger, 1945, pp. 115–116
20. Hammond, 1956, p. 100
21. Hammond, 1957, p. 359
22. Wilentz, 2008, p. 401
23. Hammond, 1947, p. 157
24. Hammond, 1956, p. 10
25. Dangerfield, 1966, pp. 88–89
26. Wilentz, 2008, p. 181
27. Wilentz, 2008, pp. 204–205, Hammond, 1947, p. 149
28. Dangerfield, 1966, p. 10
29. Wilentz, 2008, p. 204–205
30. Wilentz, 2008, p. 182
31. Schlesinger, 1945, p. 11
32. Wilentz, 2008, pp. 203, 205, Schlesinger, 1945, pp. 11–12, Dangerfield, 1966, p. 10–11
33. Dangerfield, 1966, p. 11
34. Minicucci, 2004
35. Remini, 1981, p. 32
36. Varon, 2008, p. 36
37. Dangerfield, 1966, p. 98
38. Schlesinger, 1945, pp. 20–21
39. Wilentz, 2008, pp. 203, 214
40. Hammond, 1947, p. 150
41. Dangerfield, 1966, p. 87
42. Hammond, 1947, p. 152
43. Wilentz, 2008, pp. 203–204
44. Hammond, 1947, p.153
45. Wilentz, 2008, p. 206
46. Dangerfield, 1966, p. 76
47. Dangerfield, 1966, pp. 73–74
48. Hofstadter, 1948, pp. 55–56
49. Wilentz, 2008, pp. 205–207
50. Dangerfield, 1966, pp. 80–81, 85
51. Remini, 1981, p. 28
52. Wilentz, 2005, p. 206
53. Dangerfield, 1966, pp. 86, 89
54. Dangerfield, 1966, p. 84
55. Dangerfield, pp. 81, 83
56. Dangerfield, 1966, p. 80
57. Dangerfield, 1966, pp. 85–86
58. Wilentz, 2008, pp. 207–208
59. Dangerfield, 1966, p. 89
60. Hammond, 1947, p. 151
61. Remini, 1981, p. 229
62. Hofstadter, 1948, p. 62
63. Hammond, 1947, p.150
64. Killenbeck, 2006, pp. 98–109
65. Hammon, 1947, p. 151
66. Hammond, 1957, p. 371
67. Schlesinger, 1945, p. 77
68. Wilentz, 2008, p. 362
69. Hammond, 1947, pp. 151–152
70. Remini, 1981, pp. 228–229, 303
71. Hammond, 1957, pp. 377–378
72. Hammond, 1957, p. 379
73. Hofstadter, 1948, pp. 59–60
74. Schlesinger, 1945, p. 81
75. Remini, 1981, pp. 301–302
76. Remini, 1981, pp. 341–342
77. Hammond, 1957, p. 385
78. Remini, 1981, p. 365
79. Wilentz, 2005, p. 369
80. Remini, 1981, p. 343
81. Schlesinger, 1945, p. 87
82. Remini, 1981, p. 361
83. Remini, 1981, p. 374
84. Schlesinger, 1945, p. 91
85. Schlesinger, 1945, p.87
86. Wellman, 1966, p. 132
87. Remini, 1981, pp. 382–383, 389
88. Remini, 1981, pp. 375–376
89. Wilentz, 2008, pp. 392–393
90. Schlesinger, 1945, p. 98
91. Hofstadter, 1948, pp. 61–62
92. Wilentz, 2008, p. 396
93. Schlesinger, 1945, p. 103
94. Wilentz, 2008, p. 400
95. Schlesinger, 1945, p. 112–113
96. The Second Bank of the United States: A Chapter in the History of Central Banking. p. 7.
97. Hammond, 1947, p. 140
98. Wilentz, 2008, p. 364
99. Hammond, 1947, p. 149
100. Wellman, 1966, p. 92, Hammond, 1947, p. 149
101. Wilentz, 2005, p. 365
102. Hammond, 1947, p. 149, Hammond, 1957, p. 9
103. Wilentz, 2008, pp. 74–75
104. Hofstadter, 1948, p. 56
105. Hammond, 1956, pp. 9–10
106. Hammond, 1947, p. 149-150, Wilentz, 2008, p. 205, Hofstadter, 1948, p. 56
107. Hammond, 1947, p. 153
108. "Pennsylvania Blue Marble". Second Bank of the United States. National Park Service.

Further reading

• Bodenhorn, Howard. A History of Banking in Antebellum America: Financial Markets and Economic Development in an Era of Nation-Building (2000). Stresses how all banks promoted faster growth in all regions.
• Dangerfield, George. The Awakening of American Nationalism: 1815–1828. New York: Harper & Row, 1965. ISBN 978-0-88133-823-2
• Feller, Daniel "The bank war", in Julian E. Zelizer, ed. The American Congress (2004), pp 93–111.
• Govan, Thomas Payne (1959). Nicolas Biddle, Nationalist and Public Banker, 1786–1844. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
• Hammond, Bray. "Jackson, Biddle, and the Bank of the United States", The Journal of Economic History, Vol. 7, No. 1 (May, 1947), pp. 1–23 in Essays on Jacksonian America, Ed. Frank Otto Gatell. Holt, Rinehart and Winston, Inc. New York. 1970. JSTOR 2113597
• Hammond, Bray. 1957. Banks and Politics in America, from the Revolution to the Civil War. Princeton, Princeton University Press.
• Hammond, Bray. 1953. "The Second Bank of the United States. Transactions of the American Philosophical Society, New Ser., Vol. 43, No. 1 (1953), pp. 80–85 JSTOR 1005664
• Hofstadter, Richard. Great Issues in American History: From the Revolution to the Civil War, 1765–1865 (1958).
• Kahan, Paul. The Bank War: Andrew Jackson, Nicholas Biddle, and the Fight for American Finance (Yardley: Westholme, 2016. xii, 187 pp.
• Killenbeck, Mark R. "M'Culloch v. Maryland: Securing a Nation". Lawrence, KS: University Press of Kansas, 2006.
• McGrane, Reginald C. Ed. The Correspondence of Nicholas Biddle (1919)
• Meyers, Marvin. 1953. "The Jacksonian Persuasion". American Quarterly Vol. 5 No. 1 (Spring, 1953) in Essays on Jacksonian America, Ed. Frank Otto Gatell. Holt, Rinehart and Winston, Inc. New York.
• Minicucci, Stephen. 2004. Internal Improvements and the Union, 1790–1860, Studies in American Political Development, Vol. 18, Issue 2: p. 160-185, October 2004, Cambridge University Press DOI: 10.1017/S0898588X04000094
• Ratner, Sidney, James H. Soltow, and Richard Sylla. The Evolution of the American Economy: Growth, Welfare, and Decision Making. (1993)
• Remini Robert V. Andrew Jackson and the Bank War: A Study in the Growth of Presidential Power (1967).
• Remini, Robert V. 1981. Andrew Jackson and the Course of American Freedom, 1822–1832. vol. II. Harper & Row, New York.
• Remini, Robert V. 1984. Andrew Jackson and the Course of American Freedom, 1833–1845. vol. III. Harper & Row, New York.
• Remini, Robert. V. 1993. Henry Clay: Statesman for the Union. W. W. Norton & Company, New York.
• Schlesinger, Arthur Meier Jr. Age of Jackson (1946). Pulitzer prize winning intellectual history; strongly pro-Jackson.
• Schweikart, Larry. Banking in the American South from the Age of Jackson to Reconstruction (1987)
• Taylor; George Rogers, ed. Jackson Versus Biddle: The Struggle over the Second Bank of the United States (1949).
• Temin, Peter. The Jacksonian Economy (1969)
• Varon, Elizabeth R. Disunion!: The Coming of the American Civil War, 1789–1859. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press, 2008.
• Wellman, Paul I. 1984. The House Divides: The Age of Jackson and Lincoln. Doubleday and Company, Inc., New York.
• Wilburn, Jean Alexander. Biddle's Bank: The Crucial Years (1967).
• Wilentz, Sean. 2008. The Rise of American Democracy: Jefferson to Lincoln. W.W. Horton and Company. New York.

External links

• Second Bank – official site at Independence Hall National Historical Park
• Documents produced by the Second Bank of the United States on FRASER
• The Second Bank of the United States – a history of the Bank by Ralph C. H. Catterall of the University of Chicago, 1902 – on Google Books
• Andrew Jackson on the Web : Bank of the United States
• Second Bank of the United States at the Historic American Buildings Survey (HABS) (Library of Congress)